Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 22 · 30 May 1902
3printed page
scan 3 of 16

No. 22 — "Die Welt" — Page 3

(continued from page 2)

…rich Jewesses began to play a part in society; relying upon Moses Mendelssohn, men attempted to found "reformed" congregations, that is, congregations which in their essence strove not for a development of Judaism from within, but sought an approximation to the prevailing Protestantism. *)

And this purely external "reforming" in religious matters brought with it the complete forgetting of Hebrew, the declaring of mixed marriages to be legitimate, and in the end the baptism of oneself and one's family. This course of development has also exercised the decisive influence upon civic development.

Members of a people who are only just entering into an alien national body can maintain a justified self-respect only if, besides their individual qualities, they are able to preserve their pride in their former spiritual possessions, in culture, nationality, religion. Otherwise they must lose themselves in blind admiration of what is alien. Now a Jewish culture of its own did not exist; the Ghetto had had a petrifying effect; one had lagged far behind the present. One's own nationality one would at no price preserve, because one held it to be incompatible with German citizenship. All striving, in the domain of religion as well, was directed precisely towards divesting oneself of this nationality. Samuel Holdheim expressed this clearly. According to him nationality coincides with the State (a gross juridical error!); consequently, with the downfall of the Palestinian State, Jewish nationality too must have been done away with, and the religious bond alone must unite the Jews. And now even this one possession left over from olden times, religion, was declared to stand in need of improvement! Of necessity the remnant of pride in the traditions had to vanish. All values were revalued. If formerly it had been good to lay strong emphasis upon one's Judaism, this now became a wrong.

The Aryan peculiarities, upon which men in the Ghetto had looked down as barbarous, suddenly appeared worthy of imitation. And what had hitherto been bad, the denial of the Jewish character, now appeared a duty towards the mightier, and therefore evidently better, Aryan way of life and outlook. And so men set about anxiously exterminating from civic life everything that could recall the Jew; the individual was proud to root out inexorably even the last Jewish trait of character.

This has in fact been the course of development in numerous families. Only a few have remained faithful to historical Judaism, or have at least possessed sufficient understanding to halt in good time upon the path they had entered.**)


*) Whereas Catholicism, and likewise orthodox Judaism, are religions for every day, pervading the whole of life with their spiritual content and claiming to connect every action, even the slightest, outwardly with definite religious precepts, Protestantism and Reform Judaism are religions for the holiday. On weekdays church and temple remain closed. There is no Mass and no morning prayer; only on Sunday does the priest discharge his function. In the Reform congregations the liturgy is read, not sung as among Catholics and the Orthodox; "preachers" replace the rabbis; the German language fills the prayer-book exclusively, just as the Protestants, in contrast to the Catholics, have banished the foreign tongue of Latin.

**) Very instructive is the ascertainment of the enormous percentage of baptisms among the descendants of those 31 men who, assuredly in the best of faith, signed the appeal for the founding of the Berlin Reform Congregation of 2nd April 1845. The same men who, as Levin ("Die Reform des Judenthums," Berlin 1895, p. 99) holds,

Men looked only to the present; they wished to assimilate themselves to Germanism at any price. And what was the consequence? Men were ashamed to fight for their own interests; they surrendered almost without a struggle their political rights, when these were gradually wrested from them by administrative means. Whenever a strong Jewish feeling stirred, whenever common action was demanded for the threatened common interests, or even for the Jews of the East, then men cried out about treason to Germanism, asked with emphasis whether those who laid such stress upon Judaism absolutely wished to go back into the Ghetto — in short, behaved unworthily. Even where some principles were retained and men held aloof from the great lie of baptism, a monstrous indolence nevertheless came to light. How many in Berlin would like not yet to be Christians, but outwardly no longer to be Jews! And this temper spread to the congregation also, when it forsook the firm ground of tradition and began to reform in order to make concessions to the spirit of the age. Self-respect at once sank to an extraordinary degree. The Conservatives were disorganised and, moreover, belonged for the most part to the lower, uninfluential classes of the population, and so the Liberals ruled unsparingly and with the open tendency of self-annihilation. Whatever was Jewish was held to be ungenteel, beneath one's station; the congregational offices were "honorary offices, just like any others" (so a congregational president expressed himself some years ago), and every suggestion for the inner strengthening of the community was scoffed at. Not one single social institution was created, no apprentices' home and no club-house, no youth associations and no provident-fund institutions, such as were established all around by the Christian congregations and for the only through "full love of Judaism could be moved to the self-sacrifice of maintaining a worship of their own out of voluntary contributions," were not able to keep their own children from the baptismal font. The sons had already lost their "full love" of Judaism!! And that was no wonder. It has already been shown above that the Reform in itself was bound to destroy Jewish self-respect. And the manner of the reforming demanded outright, in its ultimate consequence — as David Friedländer had deliberately held out in prospect — the "entry of a Judaism without dogmas and freed from ceremonies into Christianity." And what power of resistance could reside in a rite which systematically robbed itself of every individuality, which carefully banished from the liturgy every word recalling the national hopes, and zealously sought to root out of the prayer-book even the remembrance of the fact that we are sons of the Patriarchs!

Zacharias Frankel foresaw all this, and therefore at the Frankfort Rabbinical Assembly in the year 1845 made the following declaration, which is still significant to-day:

"In order to understand and to recognise the present of Judaism, we must look into the past. . . . Whither should we come if we tore apart the inner life and let a new one spring from our own head, as Minerva from the head of Jupiter? To the letter of Scripture we cannot return. Shall we then even grant influence to the spirit of the age? The spirit of the age is changeable, like the age itself. It is, besides, cold; it may well appear reasonable, but it will never satisfy, comfort, calm, or bless the heart; Judaism, however, is ever truly inspiring.

"The reform of Judaism, moreover, is not a reform of faith, but of the observances of the Law. These still live in the people and exert their power. It is not our task to weaken this influence, but rather to strengthen it rightly. We have not to take account of individuals who do not practise the customs; we are not a party, but have to care for the community as a whole. We must prevent divisions in Israel; not call forth new parties, but reconcile those that exist." His words died away unheard.