Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 7 · 14 February 1902
5printed page
scan 5 of 16

No. 7 — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

It lowers the "Alliance" in the eyes of the public; it renders indifferent the members, who no longer have any opportunity to share by their ballot in the work of the Society; it prevents the "Alliance" from attaining its aim, the liberation and moral elevation of the Jews, since that aim can only be attained if the Society itself cultivates towards its own members the modern principles of liberty and justice.

These principles, which moreover accord with the spirit and the letter of our Statutes, demand that the members of a society be afforded the opportunity of giving expression to their ideas, and that the society take the path which corresponds to the ideas of the majority.

I accordingly demand that elections to the Committee take place, that is to say within a period of two to three months.

It would have been very easy for me to lend my demand greater weight by the signatures of other members of the Society; but I am of opinion that one signature suffices to demand action in conformity with the Statutes, the more so as those to whom the demand is addressed are charged with conducting the "Alliance" according to the laws and the Statutes.

I beg you to acknowledge the receipt of this letter and to inform me of the resolutions which the Central Committee shall adopt.

Respectfully, Dr. Elias (Member of the "Alliance").

Thereupon I received, under date of the 29th January 1902, the following reply:

Dear Sir,

We have received your letter of the 27th January. We have read with interest the arguments which you develop in order to induce us to hold fresh elections. Only recently we asked the most important German committees whether it would be useful to assemble the members of the Society for this purpose. They declared unanimously that it would be imprudent at the present moment to call forth the slightest agitation, by which we should expose ourselves to our adversaries, and they insisted energetically that we should for the present abandon this plan.

The Central Committee has resolved throughout to postpone the elections to a later time.

Respectfully, The Secretary: (Signature illegible.)

This reply, which did not enter into my arguments at all, could not satisfy me. I wrote to the Committee once more, as follows:

Mülhausen, 31st January 1902. To the President of the "Alliance israélite," Paris.

Dear Sir,

I have just received your reply; I cannot, however, regard it as definitive. My demand was to have been laid before the Central Committee.

You answer by a resolution which the Central Committee adopted at some earlier time.

I appeal from the ill-informed Committee to the Committee that is to be better informed.

The German District Committees, which will hear nothing of elections, bear no responsibility; they do not cover the acts of the Central Committee, neither the lawful nor the unlawful.

The fear of exposing a weak spot to one's adversaries at an election is quite comprehensible; it exists, however, with all those who go before the electors.

But the aim of those who do not agree with the administrative measures of the present Committee, and who wish to combat it with the weapons furnished them by the law and the Statutes, likewise deserves the general interest.

Should you not hold the statutory elections, then, instead of the simple agitation which you fear, there will arise a double one: the agitation whose object will be to bring about fresh elections, and the agitation which, once the first aim is attained, will strive to put other men in your places.

As you know, many of our co-religionists no longer agree with you; many are convinced that the means which you employ to raise our brethren intellectually and materially can lead to no goal. They seek to prove this by the fact that, in spite of the work of the "Alliance," the condition of the Jewish people has grown worse from year to year for twenty-five years. They believe that other forces must be set in motion in order to help Judaism.

They will employ every means which the law places at their disposal in order to give back to the members of the "Alliance" their right of voting, and to let the sovereign franchise decide which path the "Alliance" is to take.

Before you adopt a final resolution, before you undertake a struggle in which right will not be on your side, lay my arguments before the Central Committee, and demand that the resolution formerly adopted to postpone the elections be rescinded.

Respectfully, Dr. Elias.

From these three documents the Jewish public will perceive upon what facts elections must be held, and what idle pretexts the Committee of the "Alliance" employs in order to thwart them.

It is fear of its adversaries that prevents the "Alliance" from entering upon an electoral contest. These adversaries are not, as simple souls might perhaps believe, the Antisemites. Those have long existed, and elections were never formerly postponed out of fear of them. Nor are they the Jewish opponents of the Alliance — there are none such; they are only the opponents of the present Committee. These have existed ever since Zionism uplifted the hearts of the Jews and awakened new hopes in them, hopes which run counter to the endeavours of the present Committee of the "Alliance."

Although for the time being the Committee of the "Alliance" will hear nothing of fresh elections, we are preparing ourselves for them.

It is possible that the Committee of the "Alliance" may yet change its tactics; perhaps my arguments, which have merely interested the President of the "Alliance," will make a great impression upon the other members of the Committee and will also in-