Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 7 · 14 February 1902
13printed page
scan 13 of 16
Facsimile · scan 13 of 16
Scan of p. 13
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 7. — "Die Welt" — Page 13.


(continued from page 12)

…themselves, a language which arose in the struggles of life, in suffering and in vice. There is an enormous gulf between the educated and the uneducated, and this must be bridged by sensible discussion with the poor . . . for only Ignorance is always dangerous, Knowledge never is "

In modern social philanthropy, thought and knowledge must take the place of feeling and sentiment. The greater part of mankind is shut out from the epoch-making advances of science, which benefit only a few students. Popular lectures on the most important economic problems of interest and consequence to the working classes ought to be held every year. In the new charity "education" must play the foremost part, for education alone can bring men a knowledge of the conditions and the laws of life. In this "work of enlightenment", which is the quintessence of Toynbee's philanthropy, one must not incite the workmen against the employers, but must strive to soften the bitter struggle between Capital and Labour, must reconcile the antagonisms and show that the true interests of both are identical. Practical and positive where others are dreamers and enthusiasts, the English have for fifty years been thinking of a peaceful solution of the social question, in which they have indeed already for the most part succeeded.

In January 1880 Toynbee delivered at Bradford, a centre of the working classes, three addresses on "Free Trade", "The Law of Wages", and "England's Commercial Supremacy", which were equally well received by employers and employed. Toynbee, as his contemporaries report, always spoke extempore, without having so much as a slip of paper before him, and never thought of publishing his speeches; for this reason we are but little informed as to the content of his addresses. Only his address on the "Law of Wages" was afterwards printed from a shorthand report. We see in it how earnestly Toynbee meant well by the workmen, whom he never in the least sought to flatter, but to whom he always spoke the truth openly, plainly and manfully. He sets forth that the "iron law of wages" of Ricardo and Lassalle is not an inexorable law of "purchase and supply", but that it is influenced by the Trade Unions, by custom, by public opinion and by the character of the master. In this address he lays emphatic stress upon Stuart Mill's distinction between the laws of production, which are natural laws and cannot be regulated by any outward will, and the laws of distribution, which are up to a certain point the results of human contrivance and can be improved with the growth of intelligence and equity.

Exactly one year later (January 1889) Toynbee delivered in London his best address, on "Industry and Democracy". The leading idea of this, his principal speech, is as follows: the enormous spread of machine labour since the end of the eighteenth century has torn asunder England's industrial organisation and loosed the bond of protection and dependence which formerly united employer and employed.

This revolution in the industrial sphere was not followed hard upon the heels by one in the political, and some time elapsed before the economic emancipation of the English workman was accompanied by his political liberation. For him this interval in England was a time of deep moral suffering, and for the whole State a period of danger. But the English workmen soon learned how to organise, and obtained political rights. (The very reverse is the case on the European Continent, where the workmen were first liberated politically and are still not economically free.) Now the English workmen are independent citizens with greater rights and duties than was the case in the industrial order of patriarchal "Old England". In this way, he held, the acute crisis of the double revolution, economic and political, had been overcome in Britain, and a time of tranquil development had become possible. Toynbee delivered many other addresses at workmen's meetings, but these fall short in importance of his principal speech, "Industry and Democracy". Thus in one he defines the sphere of "State Socialism"; in another he seeks to solve the old and grave question of Labour and Capital. He holds that through the Trade Unions and Cooperative Societes the English working class will be best prepared for the solution of this question, which hangs over our heads like a sword of Damocles. In this, he says, one may count upon the ennobling tradition of freedom and love of order, as well as upon the moderation which the English workmen, especially those of the North, have shown.

For the last time Toynbee spoke at the end of January 1883, in St Andrews Hall in London, on the American Henry George's "Progress and Poverty". It was his swan-song; long ill already, and of a weakly constitution in any case, his friends wished to keep him from the great exertion of speaking two evenings in succession. Toynbee would not allow it, but only with great physical effort could he command the numerous audience, especially on the second evening. Some Cockneys who were dissatisfied with his arguments made an unusual uproar, and this gave the death-blow to one who was as sensitive as the mimosa. He died like a general, almost upon the battlefield of the "enlightenment of the workers." When he had finished his two hours' address he was near to fainting. His friends caught him in their arms, and his strong nature triumphed yet this once; but it was a "dead man" who returned to Wimbledon, which he was never to leave again. Six weeks later, on 9th March 1883, he died, in the thirty-first year of his age. By his death the outcasts of London lost a thoroughly sincere friend and a most able defender. He had struck the right chord for their moral liberation, one that set vibrating both their hearts and the hearts of others. Neither a philanthropic Utopian, nor a heaven-storming revolutionary, nor a collectivist Socialist, Toynbee has perhaps found the best means of bridging the yawning gulf that stretches between rich and poor, educated and uneducated. A social eclectic, Toynbee in his unhappily unfinished chief work, "Industrial Revolution", broke with the old social systems. He wants no omnipotent, all-absorbing State; he thinks not in the remotest degree of abolishing individual property; and yet he is a Socialist body and soul, a Socialist in the noblest sense of the word, in that he is convinced of the necessity of a social reorganisation. But not by revolutionary means was the new