Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 6 · 7 February 1902
8printed page
scan 8 of 16
Facsimile · scan 8 of 16
Scan of p. 8
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 6.

(continued from page 7)

…gards; and he has no further need of Palestine, since his own platform "floweth with milk and honey."

Dr. Gaster asks: "How dares one Jew accuse another?" What? Are we a gang in a league? I assure him that once we are in Zion we shall have a public prosecutor there. How dare Jews who hold a position in public life demand to be spared criticism?

The "Ica" exists, as Mr. Montefiore says, for the sake of the Russian Jews. Will he explain to us how the Russian Jews have been helped? I wish to hear nothing of alms, schools and loan-societies. He himself admits that these are only palliatives. I should like to hear of some statesmanlike plan of eventual regeneration, which in its natural development contains the power of self-emancipation. For that, and nothing else, is what Zionism proposes. In Mr. Montefiore's words — I cannot quote them often enough — "it is the only way in which the unhealthy elements can be eliminated, and in which independence can finally be put in the place of temporary support and subsidies."

Do the beginnings of Baron Hirsch promise such a success? The most remarkable success of Baron Hirsch's doings in Argentina consists in this: that his agent, Mr. Arnold White, was the chief speaker at the antisemitic demonstration in Peoples Palace. Do the trustees perhaps intend to go on paying Arnold White because Baron Hirsch once gave him money? Do they intend to go on believing in Argentina because Baron Hirsch once believed in it? If you wish to see how the "Ica" deals with your plan of rescue, you have only to picture this antisemitic meeting of the "British Brothers" in Peoples Palace enlarged into a general outbreak of English antisemitism. You may picture murderers storming the Ghetto and setting our synagogues on fire, Aliens laws denying every shelter to our fugitive Jews, and special laws against the Jews, greeted with jubilation, to make England worthy of the Continent. Then, in the midst of this mighty darkness, picture the "Ica" founding a new school in Spitalsfields and buying a few acres of marshy soil in Essex, as far as possible from the railway, in order to settle them with 19 families comprising 45 souls.

Was not the real reason why Baron Hirsch went to Argentina this: that Baron Edmund Rothschild was working in Palestine? And now that the two schemes have become one, is it not the task of the trustees to turn both to account in a manner in which they can be made useful to all, namely: to divert the stream of Jewish endeavour towards Palestine? Baron Rothschild and Baron Hirsch are benefactors who will remain immortal even if their project fails; but to rescue their projects from failure is to show them the deepest gratitude. I do not say that the Zionist plan is absolutely certain of success, even if we had the Charter to-morrow. The task that would then lie before us is one of the most difficult in the history of mankind. But it is no disgrace to attempt a thing that may itself fail. It would, however, be an eternal and abiding humiliation for the whole Jewish people — to have made no attempt.

The Jewish Colonial Bank — the surest proof that we are making the attempt — occupies the first floor of a large building in Walbrook, and what, think you, is on the ground floor? "Sandow's School for Self-Development."

Our Bank is in reality borne up by the school of the strongest man on earth. Is that not a fine image of Zionism? Our money is useless without muscular strength, without the physical regeneration of our people, without the strength of mind which alone enables a race to lift its head and stand firm as a rock. And there is yet another thing we need — I say it without hesitation: morals. One of the worst features of a life which we live apart from the rest of the community, and of the criticism to which we are subjected by our opponents, is that the Jewish writer dares not point out the faults of his people. For you would all cry out: "Do not foul your own nest; do not expose us to the Gojim!" When you, gentlemen and ladies, read the novels of Dickens and Thackeray, you will find that they are nothing other than a satire on English life; their works are full of vagabonds, swindlers, rakes, adventurers and even murderers; they pour their scorn upon the best-loved features of country life; they teach the people to know themselves. We, who must always live up to the notions of the Christians, who, if we are not all angels, call us all devils, do not enjoy this freedom of intellectual criticism, and the consequence is an unhealthy public life among the Jews, full of self-adulation. We have, in short, no Opposition. To-night I propose, too, to supply an Opposition: to tell you that we are not yet worthy of Zionism. If we must still wait before we reach our final goal, let us use the time to advantage in raising our morals. Yes, those are the three things upon which our movement must be built, the three M's: Money, Muscle and Morals (Geld, Kraft und Moral).

Though I do not believe all that is said in the antisemitic papers and speeches about East End Jews, I cannot doubt that certain complaints are not altogether without foundation. I do not imagine that Whitechaple is inhabited by nothing but saints because the East End Jews furnish the main contingent of English Zionists, any more than I believe that the anti-Zionists of the West are sinners.

There are unhappily too many Jewish cases at law in the newspapers, too many bankrupts and too many money-lenders, and too many blood-sucking landlords as well. It is a Chillul Haschem, a profanation of the Name. We cannot always excuse ourselves by saying that our wits were sharpened by persecution, that we were so hard pressed by unjust laws that we saw ourselves compelled to evade the laws a little. We must acknowledge that in England the laws are not unjust, are not aggressive; that overreaching others leads to overreaching oneself, and that the hard-hearted landlord becomes the curse of his innocent brethren. I wonder that the Rabbis do not turn more attention to moral teaching proper, although I know that their flocks are so adroit and learned that they could take offence at the Ten Commandments.

I do not know whether there are black sheep among us Zionists; I hope not. It would cause us great concern; it would be a Chillul Zion, a profanation of Zion. It is the duty of every Zionist, in the interval during which he waits for Zion, to make himself a Zion here already — that is, each one a centre of sincerity and honour in his own breast — so that when Zion one day stands open to the Zionists, the Zionists too may be ripe for Zion.

And will the day ever come when Zion open to us