Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 6 · 7 February 1902
6printed page
scan 6 of 16

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 6.

(continued from page 5)

…wholly in the Jewish spirit. The "Ica" — pardon! — the secret Scapegoat Committee which took over the playground has, as we have seen, taken the game very seriously and brought a sullen spirit into it, so that all the young people ran away crying. The report has nothing pleasant to announce. It hopes in time to untie all the Rothschild knots. As regards its own earlier activity in Palestine, the "Ica" supports 99 colonists, distributed among 5 colonies!

In the "United States" of America the "Ica" likewise admits to having accomplished but little, since positive activity on its part was prevented "by the absence of the President and the illness of the Director."

In Canada, where only 22 families live, Mark Tapley remarks that the "little Hirsch colony" is gaining strength of itself, without requiring great outlay. Here the threshing-machine bought in 1897 stands idle, because there is not enough grain even to cover the wages of the machinists. So ends the story of the colonies. Little — but bad. They seem to be merely costly children's toys.

Let us turn our attention to the schools. In the whole of Argentina there are, all told, 906 colonists, but for them there are 20 schools with 20 directors and 20 professors, to say nothing of the many schoolmistresses and inspectors. That does not strike me as very economical. But I am no practical man of business; I am an idle dreamer. These schools do not satisfy the educational enthusiasm of the "Ica" in Argentina, for there are in addition schools for adults there.

We are all familiar with the condition of the Jews of Roumania, where the native-born Jews are regarded as foreigners. Roumania means hell on earth for the Jews. Every week we read of fresh atrocities, of fresh attempts to destroy the Jews by laws and decrees. As Mr. Montefiore says: "What is to become of these unhappy people, who are exposed to a persecution no less cunning than aggressive, against which no party raises a hand, and which even the Great Powers of Europe can neither mitigate nor punish?" How, then, does the Association solve the Roumanian problem? Schools again! Everywhere they help with schools! There are 5 schools in Bucharest, 2 schools in Jassy and 3 schools in Botoschany. There are in all a quarter of a hundred schools in Roumania, without counting the naughty schools from which support was withdrawn again because they did not keep to the programme of the "Ica." And for the whole of Roumania there is nothing else!

The school question in Roumania may be as urgent as Mr. Montefiore asserts, but what seems to us more urgent is to teach Roumania a lesson, and that, as he sadly admits, no Jewish body has the power to do. When, in spite of these schools, the Roumanian Jews flee into misery without any organisation, not knowing whither, the "Ica" shares the momentary panic of the Jewish communities everywhere. It tries to keep the Roumanian Jews away from London, away from the United States, away from every land where their presence threatens the existence of the Jews already living there; and when the "Ica" has thus succeeded for a time in cloaking the unrest, it breathes deeply again, and founds yet another new school.

And how does this monstrous report end? It ends as it began: with Argentina, like a great symphony returning to its opening. And this is its last word: "This year we engaged a German teacher for our colonies in Argentina. After he had learned Spanish, he was sent to Buenos Aires and is teaching in one of our colonies."

So ends the great plan of Baron Hirsch for the rescue of Israel: the German teacher has learned Spanish.

The total number of undertakings which the "Ica" itself conducts or supports is no fewer than 193. How many irons in the fire! Far from admiring this distribution of labour over three different continents, I agree with Montefiore — you see, I always agree with Montefiore — that "the eggs are in too many baskets." And I should like to see the body that would be in a position to keep all these eggs from breaking. The whole project of the "Ica" is artificial and impossible. Every single committee, apart from dealing with these 193 undertakings, is occupied with a host of personal affairs. We know — be it said to their honour — how much local activity of every kind is performed here by the three English members. Mr. Montefiore devotes a great part of his life to study. How much time this trio spends on the everlasting pumping which so artificial a machinery necessitates, I leave you to estimate. The annual meeting in Paris was, according to the report, not well attended. The whole affair was over in a few minutes. The 193 undertakings were disposed of in the twinkling of an eye, and the trustees could return to the boulevard. You see, ladies and gentlemen, how the "Ica" lacks an Opposition.

Let us suppose that the machine is in the best of order, and that it performs its task perfectly — what would it then be? A steam-hammer cracking nuts. It would be boastful to say that the machine cracks many kinds of nuts in many countries; it only ever cracks nuts.

Let us suppose that the trustees of the Hirsch Foundation, instead of doing so much wilful good, were to believe a little in the Jewish national spirit. If only they would unite their millions with this great force! That would be the finest example in history of a great work that came about without faith. The trustees are always pointing to the enormous difficulty of their task. Certainly it is infinitely hard to make water flow up the hill. But the difficulty arises from their having sought it out for themselves.

I should like to tell you how a natural movement proceeds as compared with an artificial one. When I was in Sheffield three years ago, a young man called on me and told me he had a business with a small capital of 3—400 pounds, and asked whether I would advise him to sell the business here and emigrate with his means to Palestine. I answered him: "No, not now; wait!" Last year a Jewess from Chicago called on me and told me that her two boys were now grown up, and asked whether I would advise her to buy a farm for them in Palestine and settle them there; and again I said: "Wait!" Although I told her "Wait!", we really cannot wait any longer. For Palestine is awakening, and the nations are discovering the importance of the land. One day, perhaps, the concessions which we desire will have passed to strangers, and Palestine will bloom once more, and the eternally wandering Jew will have his own door shut in his face, so that he must wander on — who knows for how many years yet!

Do not tell me that Palestine is incapable of supporting our refugees. The Mormons came into a Salt Lake district, a desert, and made a garden of it. Why? Because they believed in themselves. If the grotesque gospel of a Joe Smith could bring about so successful a colonisation, what then