No. 4. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…economic organisation on political grounds; and still less in the colonial territories.
Whether the Turks, as the possessors of Palestine, would have the will and the power to destroy the settlement plan, I cannot decide; but I hold that no colonisation of any kind, not even the individualistic peasant settlement, ought to be undertaken until ample guarantees against such interference have been given; and that without such guarantees every other form of settlement likewise remains exposed to the same dangers. In Palestine, moreover, conditions are substantially more favourable than with us, since there scarcely any rent exists, and consequently no powerful private interests can be called into action against the settlements; and since, further, the chronic financial distress of the Turks lays open the road by which political rights have hitherto almost exclusively been acquired — purchase.
Should, however, the first flourishing settlements really be brutally destroyed, here or elsewhere, that would perhaps be the most favourable event for the victory of the idea. It would give the idea a notoriety that would bring it capital and men in abundance from all the world; a boundless immigration would enormously increase the political and economic power of those countries which should grant the plan a home. And so in the end the plan of political self-preservation would compel even the most backward states of the old world to further the reform on their part. And by that time the Jewry of Eastern Europe, for whom settlement is evidently to be regarded only as a means and not as the end, would long since have gone off to Western America or Canada and been withdrawn from the dreadful pressure of absolutism.
But let us suppose that the work of settlement is to be allowed to develop undisturbed in Palestine; what shape will the political structure then take?
We shall have a great number of flourishing co-operative settlements, even the smaller ones in a healthy mixture of urban and rural elements, some grown up into purely urban communities, according to the advantages of their position in the network of national and world economy. Each of these co-operatives is at the same time a commune. If, as is natural, they join together into unions, which are graded into ever higher unions until at last they culminate in the apex of a single great organisation resembling the English Wholesale Society — save that, besides wholesale purchasing and wholesale production for the whole body, it also carries out wholesale selling and the procuring of credit — then this entire economic organisation is at the same time a political one, precisely because its individual cells, the co-operatives, are at the same time political communes. Thus it will be able to carry out taxation and administration, so far as these must be centralised, with the greatest ease. Whether it would eventually come to political independence, and what form of external government, whether monarchy or republic, would develop, is of course a matter on which not the least can be said. The first question depends exclusively on the density which the population may attain here and on the prosperity it may win, for these are the factors of all political power.
How, then, to make the first beginning? I hold that one should institute as pure an experiment as possible as a preliminary trial, before laying the foundations of so gigantic an edifice as Zionism intends. By a pure experiment I understand one in which solely the problem of the economic competitive capacity of the settlement co-operative is brought to solution. As soon as other experiments are combined with it, every possibility is afterwards lacking of referring success or failure to an isolated cause. For this reason the first trial should be made only with practised agricultural labourers, in a district which presents no new problems in agricultural technique. Both the introduction of urban elements into primary production and settlement in a new country should be avoided. And just as little should constitutional experiments be carried into the organisation itself at the outset. I therefore plead with all decision for a first trial in a European agricultural district, say in Galicia or in a province of Germany east of the Elbe. This trial should be undertaken exclusively with practised agricultural labourers. If Jewish agricultural labourers are not to be had in sufficient number and of sufficient quality, the trial should without hesitation be made at first with Christian labourers. One would thereby gain, for all further settlements, a stock of foremen and subordinate managers admirably trained both technically and in co-operation. Further, the first trial should be directed by the best expert who can in any way be had — by a Jew, or, if a Jewish expert of the first class cannot be won, without hesitation by a Christian; and thirdly, not the least change should at first be made in the customary order of labour. The full disciplinary authority which the landowner or administrator possesses to-day over his subordinates should be secured to this director also. Only in the administration of the subsidiary co-operatives — at first the consumers' society, and gradually the others as well (credit, building, industrial, marketing co-operatives, etc.) — should a gradually increasing share in the administration be conceded to the labourers; for it must not be forgotten that this work of organisation can prosper only if it is at the same time a work of education. On one point only should the labourers be left in no doubt from the first day: that the founding capital contents itself with a fixed rate of interest, that the entire net profit will be divided among the working members pro rata of their performance, and that they have the certainty of acquiring the estate as their own property within a period fixed in advance and at a price fixed in advance.
Only this pure experiment can give all settlement activity on a co-operative basis the foundation of technical and social certainty. It should serve the same purpose as, say, the construction of a reduced trial machinery before one ventures large capital upon the erection of the actual works. We have now in Germany a "Study Commission" for the working of electric main-line railways, which is making experiments with enormous means on the military railway Berlin–Zossen. Here time and money are seemingly wasted, and yet the excellent men of business who belong to this commission know that an enormous amount of time and money is gained. For the results of this trial will enable them later to carry out their work on the large scale with the least expenditure of time and money. Above all, however, one consideration decides: the strong current that drives all the mill-wheels of present-day economy — capital — turns on a large scale only to such undertakings whose profitableness has already been guaranteed by a trial.
This Zionism too should take to heart. With the few millions contributed à fonds perdu by rich Israelites, the work it has in view is impossible. But if, pointing to a brilliantly successful experiment, it can guarantee to international Jewish capital a decent rate of interest with a very secure investment, the golden stream will soon set its turbines going at full speed. And so a preliminary trial such as I recommend may perhaps postpone the beginning of the work of settlement by some years — by my estimate five at most: but it will then so further the progress of the undertaking that within the shortest time the delay will have been made good and far surpassed.
The capital required at most for such a trial under German conditions amounts to half a million marks, namely 300,000 marks for the purchase of an estate of 500–1000 ha., wholly sufficient for the trial, according to situation and quality of soil, 100,000 marks for working capital, and 100,000