Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 4 · 24 January 1902
4printed page
scan 4 of 20
Facsimile · scan 4 of 20
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 4

The far-sighted and important work of civilisation which has been inaugurated by the Deutsche Bank with the building of the Anatolian railway in Turkey can count on full success only if it draws after it economic enterprises of every kind on a large scale, of which it is the precondition. It is the duty of German business as of German policy to see to it that the share due to the German Empire in the coming upswing be secured in good time. That no thought of political conquest plays any part here is surely self-evident; on the contrary, all such enterprises are to serve to strengthen the Ottoman Empire, which is friendly to us. German enterprise must, however, even now equip itself for the manifold and great tasks that await it in the Levant. It is especially from this point of view that the undertaking of the Palestine Bank and its further plans are to be welcomed with satisfaction. Germany must be on the spot and hold a firm position when, under the influence of the great new undertaking in communications, new blood begins to flow through the veins of the Mesopotamian economic region and its adjoining lands. To help in this should also fall, in an eminent sense, within the sphere of tasks of the German Colonial Society, which cannot regard its programme as fulfilled by the care of the protectorates proper, but is conscious that its activity must be brought to bear wherever economic tasks await a solution in the German national sense. A. S.

Anything but Jewish.

The Vienna "Chewra Kadischah" has resolved to imitate the example which has been set in other cities — in particular in Budapest — and has proved a brilliant success, and has decided to replace the senselessly expended offerings of wreaths by wreath-redemption donations destined for charitable purposes. A most praiseworthy undertaking! On Thursday a Vienna paper published the first list of wreath-redemption donations. It will, however, surely be impossible for the great Jewish and non-Jewish reading public to guess the origin of these wreath-redemption donations. For the "Chewra Kadischah" appeared under the pseudonym "Society for Pious and Charitable Foundations." Who, one wonders, can have indulged in this brilliant translation? In the whole list, moreover, the word "Jewish" or "Israelite" did not occur a single time.

Correction of Misprints.

Some misprints crept into the report on the General Meeting of the Jewish Colonial Trust in our last number. On page 8, 1st column, 13th line from the bottom, it should read, instead of "30th November 1901," correctly "31st December 1900"; in the same column, 10th line from the bottom, the correct figure is "188, 193, 7, 10." Finally, on the same page, IInd column, 15th line from the top, it should read correctly "30th November 1901" instead of "31st December 1901."

Jewish Settlements.

By Dr. Franz Oppenheimer, Berlin. (Conclusion.) *)

To this fundamental difference there corresponds an equally fundamental difference between the industrial and the agricultural productive co-operative society. The three rocks on which we saw the first founder do not exist


*) Cf. Nos. 50, 51 and 52 of "Die Welt."

for the second. For its beginning it needs no personal credit whatever, but only real credit. On the accession of new members it needs no additional credit, since it has neither to enlarge its workshops, nor to procure new machines, nor to buy new raw materials. It is engaged in no struggle for a market, for there is no such struggle over the great raw products of the world market. When the industrial co-operative gains new members, it is compelled to organise its business on an ever higher capitalistic scale, and thereby grows more and more out of the relative freedom from competition of the art-crafts into the furious struggle of competition for the industrial products of the world market; conversely, the agricultural productive co-operative grows more and more out of the world market the more members join it; for so much the more intensive does its husbandry become, and agricultural husbandry, the more intensive it is, produces all the more goods at fancy prices for local markets: "refined" products. And the same holds for discipline: the more members the industrial co-operative has, the more difficult discipline becomes, because they must always be subordinated; in agriculture, however, they are the more co-ordinated, the more labourers till the same area of land, and the more intensive, therefore, the husbandry is.

Finally, the agricultural productive co-operative is not subject to the "law of transformation." This extends exclusively to what I have called "sellers' co-operatives," co-operatives of capitalist sellers, which I should now call "disharmonious" co-operatives; but it does not extend to what I have called co-operatives of buyer-sellers, which I should to-day call "harmonious." And a co-operative of the latter kind is beyond doubt the agricultural productive co-operative, while the industrial represents the type of the disharmonious.⁷)

I must deny myself at this point the repetition here of the extraordinarily subtle analysis of collective economic psychology which has yielded me these results.

At all events I believe myself justified, on the ground of these historical and theoretical findings, in giving the most favourable prognosis for the form of organisation I have planned. To be sure, only the definitive experiment will be able to silence the last objections of the theoretical opponents, who, characteristically enough, are to be found exclusively in the camp of those who understand not the least thing either of agriculture or of co-operation. Facta loquuntur!

Of these objections the most important is the following:

Granted that the settlement co-operative will prosper, it will by its very prosperity rouse against itself all the instincts of the class-State, of the class interests threatened by it; and all the worse if my prediction should be confirmed, that a co-operative of this kind acts destructively upon the capitalist rent of its surroundings, merely through the circumstance that it withdraws labour from them and compels them to pay higher wages for the same work. That no State will put up with, since the State, as is well known, regularly represents nothing other than the committee of the ruling class.

This objection, as I have said, has its justification. I hold it entirely possible, even probable, that in Russia, say, and perhaps in Germany too, the State will try every possible means to crush a settlement co-operative when its fermentative property becomes ever more clearly evident with its flourishing. In Russia it might well succeed; in Germany perhaps no longer. At least a Polish colonisation company has demonstrated ad oculos to the Prussian State that all administrative chicanery rebounds powerless from co-operative settlement. In England and Switzerland, in Holland and France, the State certainly no longer has the power, a purely co-operative-


⁷) Cf. on this my "Grossgrundeigenthum und sociale Frage," Berlin 1898, page 138 f., and my essay "Käufer-Verkäufer," Schmollers Jahrbücher, October number 1900.