Die Welt · Vol. VI, No. 1 · 3 January 1902
12printed page
scan 12 of 16

Page 12. — "Die Welt" — No. 1.

(continued from page 11)

…move my resolution. The new Moses turned to his people, saw it in its bondage, and saw no deliverance save in a new Exodus. Whither? To a new world, he thought, and so he directed the emigration chiefly to the Argentine. With what success? It has been said that the most important charity consists in making two blades of grass grow where one blade grew before. Of Baron Hirsch's charity it may be said that he made two schnorrers grow where only one schnorrer grew before. (Great laughter and applause.) The director, Colonel Goldsmith, told us what the people looked like who were sent to him as colonists: childless old men, invalids, the sweepings of the slums of the great cities of the world. What does this failure prove? Merely that the idea was bad, and that the execution was worse still. All pioneers must grope in the dark; but Baron Hirsch was a great man, and great men learn from their own errors. Only small men, small creatures standing low on the ladder of living things, never change. Had Baron Hirsch lived long enough to see the modern Zionist movement, had he seen an ardent young generation that desires nothing more fervently than to forge its own destiny with its own muscles on its own soil, he would have rejoiced to find so fine an opportunity of spending his money fruitfully and not uselessly. (Applause.) But the great man is dead, and the executors reign in his stead. More than two hundred millions, to which were later added roughly another hundred millions for the Rothschild colonies, passed into the hands of a mixed company of Parisians and Londoners, without plan, without unity, without definite aim. Some of these gentlemen desire the disappearance of the Jews, others merely the disappearance of Judaism; but all are agreed in hating the idea of any Jewish ingathering and concentration. (Loud applause.)

Little Jews one might call them, although you may be quite sure that the English members are anything but Little Englanders and that the Parisians are ardent Chauvinists. Our movement is reproached with not being led by men who are famous men of business. If famous men of business are those who are chiefly men of business in building up their own fortunes, then they have no time to build up the fortune of their people. (Loud applause.) We must take what we can get, but we are fairly well satisfied. (Loud applause.) The best men of business are not those who have themselves acquired fortunes, and the Minister of Finance is not usually the richest man in the kingdom. (Laughter and applause.) Still, let us suppose that we have bad men of business and that our few million francs are in danger — what, then, will be said of the directors of these 300 millions? How is it that no one is in mortal fear for these men and these millions? Who are these people? There is a famous financier. But where is he to find the time? I suspect that he is merely the golden figurehead of the company. Then there is one whom I know particularly well; he is a man of means, a noble character and a scholar, who has never earned a penny in his life, but who has nobly lost a great many pennies on the publication of a monthly periodical — this Oxford dreamer. (Laughter.) What is this scholar doing? — Then there is a Frenchman, likewise a scholar, who holds a post in a museum, and of whom it can hardly be expected that he should know how to deal with living individuals. (Resounding laughter.) Then another, whom I know to be one of the presidents of the Alliance israélite. I would venture most courteously to suggest to him that he read the Jewish newspapers of forty years ago. There he will find a dreadful cry of alarm over a new and baleful undertaking which gravely threatens the position won by the Jews in Europe and sows the seed of a Jew-baiting. He will hear horrified correspondents and anxious families accusing the new organisation of being political in character, dangerous and un-Jewish. And this so dangerous, so un-Jewish new organisation was — the Alliance israélite, which is at present acknowledged as one of the pillars of Jewry. I beg the President of the Alliance israélite to hasten forty years ahead in our case too, together with the executors, to learn from the lessons of history, and to arrive at once at an understanding of Zionism and an appreciation of our movement. We ask the one to whom I alluded to be with us before he becomes a hundred-year-old jubilarian, and I hope that both he and Sir Francis Montefiore will vie with each other and with their famous kinsman Sir Moses in becoming hundred-year-old Zionist jubilarians. (Laughter and applause.) If, however, the executors do not come to us, I see no purpose that their millions are to serve, nothing but a series of feeble experiments. Baron Hirsch was not a lost Jew, but I greatly fear his millions will be lost. (Laughter.) You know how finely a beginning has already been made. For want of foresight about 25 million francs had to be paid to the English Government as death duty. Add to that the millions paid to the lawyers for conducting this lawsuit, and you have just money enough to serve Zionism as a first fund. It is possible that we are bad men of business. But we can at least say that, in spite of all our outlays, there lie at this moment in the Bank, for every pound our shareholders have paid in, a full 20 shillings. (Loud applause.) There is one thing more we can say: we shall never have to pay a death duty, for our money belongs to no man, but to Zionism, and Zionism can never die. (Stormy applause and clapping of hands.)

We are told: Zionism is a dream. How should it be otherwise, since the Jews are asleep? (Great laughter.) Let the Jews awaken, and it will no longer be a dream. Zionism has a clear aim; the Hirsch millions have none. As I have said of Palestine: Give the land without a people to the people without a land — so I say of the Baron Hirsch bequest: Give the millions without a purpose to the purpose without millions. (Loud applause and clapping of hands.) These millions were left for the rescue of the Jewish people, and the directors cannot stand haughtily beside their treasure and let Israel suffer and be exposed to the death-struggle.

We hear on all sides: Pity for the poor blind dupes from Russia and Roumania who in their bitter poverty band together in societies, family with family, saving trifles week by week in order to buy a one-pound share in our Bank! That is not pitiable; that is sublime. (Loud applause and clapping of hands.) It is the blindness of the Hirsch executors that is pitiable! But, you will say, they cannot simply set aside the testamentary provision. In England, in my practical fatherland, charitable bequests are very often remodelled and applied to more sensible purposes when their original ones grow antiquated. The Zionist idea has moved forward so rapidly that already now the Hirsch policy ver-