No. 50 — "Die Welt" — Page 9
(continued from page 8)
. . . opinion all the rest (the economic as well as the cultural and the ethical) are already contained, will indeed be solved by each individual only subjectively for himself; yet through a lively co-operation the particulars can doubtless be furthered and riper fruits thereby brought forth.
Yet the sphere of activity of the student must not be bounded by purely theoretical work. A separation of theory and practice would be either impracticable or harmful. Precisely in this shall the advance upon the Zionism of former years consist: that everything which is undertaken shall serve the immediate life directly. This work for life may, in the widest sense, be summed up in the word "education of the people." Once one is clear upon this point, one sees most plainly how impossible it is, with the motley variety of our masses, to set up a common programme of activity. A mutual support is here again chiefly possible only upon the scientific field. The study of the life of the people and of the soul of the people, which is the fundamental condition of every national education, will shape itself more intensively and more thoroughly through common labour. And here, where a uniform view is needful, an agreement would, I believe, most readily be arrived at, Above all, however, an outward union is necessary to this end — the founding of a general Jewish students' league and the creation of a press organ for the same.
This question is the "most actual" of the Congress. It is to be hoped that it will find a favourable solution, and that solution a speedy realisation.
Of a lack of work the participants in the Congress cannot, as we see, complain. Whether, however, anything real will come of it depends solely upon the good will of the individuals.
Prague. Ferdinand Kobler.
The Social Tasks of the Communities.
By Dr. Adolf Friedemann.
"The Zionist party is bound to conquer the communities." So spoke Max Nordau when, shortly after the first Basle Congress, he for the first time invited the representatives of the various national-Jewish groups in Berlin to a conference. At that time there existed small groups of Zionists, not yet consolidated within themselves, for the most part students, and there was no foreseeing how this tiny number of young people could within any measurable time become a political factor. If one or another ventured to utter his views in public, he was smiled at pityingly or benevolently, according as the hearer desired the destruction of Judaism or its preservation — but smiled at he always was. And now these youths, whom nobody round about took seriously, were called upon for a great public action! Much against Nordau's will we went home from that conference in a very depressed mood. Not for a long time had our own weakness been laid before us so convincingly; not for a long time had we been made to feel so plainly — and with the most benevolent intention — that we were "too young."
And so it was everywhere. Small, feeble organisations, which agitated laboriously in wearing petty work, were glad when every month a new member joined, and were proud of their successes when in the year 300 Mk. had been collected.
Since then four years have gone by. And already Zionism is strong enough to begin the passage of arms for power in the foremost communities of Europe; already in the smaller communities of England and Austria it plants its banner upon the community houses, and the local groups are beginning to force their programmes upon the old parties. How has this been possible in so short a time? How could the change come so swiftly? The answer runs: Success came to us because we were honest.
Never and nowhere have we put our banner into our pocket in order to gain a seat or a few votes more at the election-huckstering so beloved in earlier days. To thousands we have brought the consciousness that in their hearts they desired the outward manifestation of the Jewish sense of honour and of nationality through the official representative bodies, but that they wished at the same time to be no ghetto Jews, but modern men, and that unconsciously they sought to range this striving of theirs under the wholly inapplicable party-designations of the "liberal" or the "conservative" Jews. And finally we have everywhere striven to make clear to the hereditary representatives of Judaism — after Shylock, good men because rich men — the conception of social obligation.
There are even to-day many thousands who wholly lack understanding for our ultimate aims. What will one day be away yonder, far off in Turkey, whether the grandchildren will be free and happy there — that they simply do not understand.
The people are not numerous who plant fruit-trees that their descendants may hold harvest. And what we say there of moral ennoblement and of the dignity of the righteous struggle — that too, it must sadly be confessed, only a small portion has grasped. But we share with the Socialists the good fortune that we could live upon the follies of our opponents even had we the most lamentable of programmes. What independent idea, adapted to modern feeling, has animated the Jewish community administrations these 30 years? Apart from consistent attempts to restrict the franchise, it will be hard to name any deeds. And what was set on foot to adapt the institutions of the communities to the conditions of the great cities? Infirmaries were built, in which the proletarian was tended when, old and broken, he appealed to charity. Had he still sap and strength in him, then there was no helping him. For that indeed is the likeness between the habitual benefactor and the bad physician, that both on principle intervene only when the misfortune has already broken in. That one spares strength, time and money by preventing — that the well-meaning but unwise practitioners of the healing art, who went operating upon the suffering body of the people, did not understand.
And then came Zionism. It demanded not merely medicine for the sick, but above all light and air for the healthy. For the little man it built Toynbee Halls and set up savings and loan banks for him, For the small tradesman it created the employment bureau, and the workman it supported in the hard struggle for daily bread. Certainly we never believed that the Jewish question could thus be solved; but we have striven none the less to make the sad every-day somewhat more endurable until the final solution of the problem. For that men have been grateful to us. Everywhere that we applied the often misused term "Realpolitik" in its old honest sense, there we have had successes to record.
When we emphasise again and again that we conceive the communities not as mere institutions of religion and charity, but as organised parts of the great community of the people, which besides religious tasks have also great social and popular-