Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 50 · 13 December 1901
26scan
of 52

— 10 —

(continued from page 9)

... to stifle personality, but rather brings the same in its wholeness all the more fully to consciousness, is furnished by the modern party system. Certainly the party system in its prodigious extension is a product of the last few decades. There is hardly any practical-social notion about which a party does not group itself. Just as there are to-day hardly many men who do not belong to some party or other.

Into the party every member now puts a piece, or the whole, of his personality: he subordinates himself at first only to an idea, later to a programme, and finally to one or several leaders as well. This gradation is noteworthy. Whereas the idea is still altogether immanent — however far outside the soul its origin may lie — the programme has already a thoroughly extra-personal, independent existence, which cannot but make the subordination more palpable. As against the leader, subordination means outright a very essential passivity.

Yet even upon this last stage the party subordination is still no opposite pole of personal freedom. That is shown at once by a clear observation of the kind of work performed within a party.

For the performance of a party in its totality consists of a number of part-performances, all of which enter into this totality to the point where their personal origin is no longer recognisable. Naturally there may be very widely divergent differences between the several performances; but all are only parts, none is a whole, a finished thing, and that means their equalisation. If, then, every member surrenders in equal measure the individual character of his performance in favour of the total performance, that can doubtless signify for no single one of them a bond in the sense of unfreedom. There remains, to be sure, the performance of the leader or of the leaders, which frequently bears, or is still expected to bear, an individual stamp. But the performance of the leaders, in so far as it cannot be ranged as a part within the whole — that is to say, in so far as it is really individually stamped — relates only and exclusively to the technical side of the work; in content it too is only a part of a whole, and therefore a quantity.

For this very reason the subordination to the personal leader is likewise no unfreedom, because it is only a technical category, just as the subordination of the soldier and of the officer is not felt as a degradation.

On the contrary, the work within a party heightens the worth of the individual performance by setting it in a disproportionately large frame. Membership of a party releases powers of the soul which otherwise would perhaps never have come into action.

This may also be the deeper connection that subsists between the intense striving of modern men after individual freedom and their grouping in parties: in the striving after individual freedom there lies at the same time the striving to give to every single province of the soul the greatest possible capacity of activity. And that is of course possible only through parties. Hence the founding of parties, and — in particular — of societies, going on to infinity, for which any reminiscence, any bodily or spiritual peculiarity, any small ethical endeavour, in short everything that merely looks like a resemblance between men, suffices as a foundation. Everything in the modern man is to have the possibility of activity, of "living itself out." In this sense the party system heightens beyond all measure the freedom of movement of the soul.

For this reason it is no wonder either that precisely in the party which demands the strictest discipline, the most energetic subordination, there is also found the most intense sense of freedom. For this reason it is likewise no "journey to Canossa," as liberal newspapers have decried it, when Eduard Bernstein subordinates himself to the party resolution which puts a stop to the ruthlessness of his criticism of socialist theory. He has merely purchased for himself the freedom — of late the more valuable to him — of intense activity within the party, at the price of renouncing the freedom of ruthless criticism. That province of the soul evidently demands a possibility of activity more imperiously than this one.

*

Thus, then, the bondage within the party, and likewise the subordination, is in no wise a suppression of individual freedom in the deeper sense of the word. Reality, which indeed everybody knows, entirely confirms these conclusions, obtained purely by theory.

In one party only do I very greatly miss the subordination of the individual to the party, that unconditional subordination which alone is able to bring forth something greater through the folding together of part-performances directed upon one and the same end — in the Zionist party. Fruitful, or also very, very unfruitful criticism of what happens or might merely happen — of that we have more than enough. Projects shoot up like mushrooms, practicable and impracticable, seasonable and unseasonable. But what is not to be seen is this: an organic co-operation of the parts, of the individuals, such that a total performance worth mentioning should come of it.

Wherein may this lie?

First of all, assuredly, in that individualism, already so often observed, which is positively an essential mark of the Jewish psyche. And it is remarkable that with it there is bound up, in some respects, a positively striking homogeneity. Our most intimate poet, S. J. Abrahowitz, once remarked that there is surely no people on earth among whom all, all without exception, on the same day, at the same hour, with almost the same gestures — eat the same dishes in the same order, as among the Jews on Friday evening. This homogeneity, however, which may moreover be demonstrated in a great many other phenomena, does not prevent that as a rule any two Jews represent two different individualities. This instinctive individualism, and still more the conscious individualism in the higher spheres of intelligence, is doubtless a serious hindrance to the subordination of the individual to the party, or rather to the party leadership. But that does not yet explain everything.

We have indeed already made out before that subordination in the party signifies only a technical category, which cannot possibly release any feeling of suppressed independence. After all, subordination relates for the very greatest part only to the: "How is it to be done?", not to the: "What is to be done?", if under the latter question one has the final goal in view.

But perhaps the ground for this lack of subordination within the Zionist party lies deeper still. And here I come once more upon two diametrically opposed fundamental tendencies of the Jewish national soul. It has long since been observed that the Jews unite in themselves an extreme idealism with an equally extreme realism. This contradiction resolves itself, in my judgment, if one look more closely. For it will be remarked that these two fundamental tendencies intersect at no point, since they run parallel side by side towards fundamentally different goals. Idealistic to the extreme is the Jewish national soul in matters of faith, of conviction, of a world-view of the very highest style. Realistic, however, it is in matters of the practical conduct of life, of the view of life in the plainest meaning of the word. Otherwise the existence of the Jewish people would not be comprehensible at all. Or were it possible that this people should hold fast to its faith with this incredible tenacity, although as a vanishing minority it is well-nigh crushed, if its soul were not borne up by an idealism without example? Indeed, one will have to hold fast to this, that a willed persistence in minority presupposes idealism, and the more so in this kind of minority. On the other hand, the Jewish people without its realism in practical worldly prudence would assuredly not have come round the many dangerous reefs which it has in fact weathered.

In any case these two fundamental tendencies are present. It will therefore be necessary to do justice to them, if the Jewish soul is to subordinate itself, if within Zionism a discipline is to prevail such as prevails within the firmly knit parties of Europe. To say it in brief: one will have to accomplish deeds, and that would be ad usum of realism; and one will have to create a theoretically firm and convincing foundation for Zionism, and that would be ad usum of idealism.

First with regard to the former: it is doubtless true that success is everywhere an extraordinarily powerful and recruiting factor. But it is not a question of success alone, it is a question of Zionist deeds in general. "Enough of words have been exchanged; now let us at last see deeds." One says: the founding of Hebrew schools is a Zionist postulate. Well then, let us found them. One says: the founding of Hebrew and Judaic libraries is a postulate of Zionism. Well then, let us found them. And so forth. I do not speak at all of the