Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 47 · 22 November 1901
9printed page
scan 9 of 16

No. 47 — "Die Welt" — Page 9

Tribune.

We are requested to give space to the following lines: The Elections of the Commercial Employees in Vienna.

As is well known, the new elections to the Assistants' Committee and to the board of the Guild Sick-Fund of the commercial employees take place on Sunday, the 24th of this month, the hitherto chairman of the assistants, the Christian-Social deputy Axmann, having laid down that office.

The Zionist commercial employees must not let this opportunity pass unused.

It is not a matter of indifference to the Jewish employee who sits upon the Assistants' Committee, and still less who sits upon the board of the sick-fund.

For there is ample opportunity of harassing the Jewish patient who is dependent upon the sick-fund and who complains of any grievance whatsoever.

The Jewish physicians and officials, too, are interested in the outcome of the election.

As the situation stands to-day, it is unconditionally advisable to vote for the Social Democratic candidates, in order to forestall a union of the Christian-Social and Pan-German anti-Semites at a possible second ballot.

A glance at the Social Democratic list of candidates informs us that it proposes close upon one half Jews for election. This, to be sure, offers us no guarantee that these Jews will also safeguard their Jewish interests. Let the Jewish employees therefore bring to public knowledge, through the Zionist organisation, every case in which they believe themselves to have been slighted. P. L.

*

Fellow-adherents of the Inner City! The Zionist idea lays hold of ever wider circles. To its convincing power even those can no longer close themselves to-day who until lately still stood strange, nay hostile, over against our movement; society joins itself to society. Ever new branches are put forth by the tree that was once planted by a few young idealists. Only the City of Vienna has hitherto shown itself coy and inaccessible to the winning power of our people-liberating idea. True, a year ago a little band of Zionists planted the white-and-blue banner in the stronghold of Viennese assimilationism; but notwithstanding diligent work, the decisive stroke has still to be struck and the Inner City to be won for the emancipation of Jewry from alien interests. All ye to whom Judaism is more than a reverent memory of the forefathers, all ye who would fight with heart and substance in our people's struggle for self-liberation, come. It is a question of harmoniously closing the chain of the Zionist organisations of Vienna.

All fellow-adherents of the Inner City of Vienna, whether they already belong to the party or have not yet given outward effect to their Zionism, are asked to appear at the meeting of the society to be held on Saturday, the 30th of November of the present year, in the Café "Commercial," I., Augustengasse (speaker: Dr. Severin Landesberger). Applications for membership are to be addressed to Mr. S. Friedmann, I., Hotel Metropole. The Committee of the Society "Inner City."


On H. St. Chamberlain.

A growing clamour proceeds from the name of Houston Stewart Chamberlain. It will not be long before Chamberlain's doctrines have become the small coin of political life. Already many a man has had them changed into his own currency. We meet with them already in sundry articles of a certain press, and of the German Emperor too we hear that "The Foundations of the Nineteenth Century"*) has taken his fancy. But from this acquisition of the coin to the spending of it in party programmes and princely manifestoes is but a step. And therefore Chamberlain deserves that one should occupy oneself with him more closely.

To be sure, I cannot here concern myself with Chamberlain as closely as I should like. I am hindered therein by the narrowness of the space at my disposal, and above all by the self-limitation of this paper to a definite field of work, the Jewish. Yet I do not mean thereby to say that I shall consider Chamberlain only in so far as he occupies himself with Jews and Judaism, and leave his other views, as well as his intellectual physiognomy, wholly out of account. To that I can never bring myself. The anti-Jewish views of Chamberlain cannot, after all, be detached from himself and from his doctrine. And then: I for my own person am penetrated by the deep conviction that a true national-cultural awakening of the Jewish people will become possible only when Europe shall have traversed its road to wholly new conditions of society and of civility. But now there everywhere oppose themselves to this development dark powers, which appear in the seemingly most contradictory shapes, yet have one thing in common, the spirit of enmity to knowledge and to development. And it is as one bound over to these powers that I regard Chamberlain.

There has lately appeared a little critique of Chamberlain,*) which deserves to be read. It is indeed anything but a reckoning conducted from large points of view, but one thing at any rate it does excellently; briefly and trimly, with dry humour, it lays bare the contradictions in Chamberlain's views. Seeking a psychological ground for this phenomenon, the author of the writing mentioned observes: "Chamberlain stands regularly under the influence of the thought which he wishes to expound. He does not master his material, but the material masters him." And to justify this explanation he continues: "If, for example, he wishes to bring out the significance of the prophets as the forerunners of Christ, the contradiction between their conception and the acquisitive fury of the Romans forces itself upon him. If, on the other hand, he wishes to render to the Romans the thanks of Europe for the gift of Roman law, then the Romans are the idealists and the Semites the men possessed by the lust of possession. If he wishes to prove that Paul, who had a Jewish father, may have had a Greek mother, then the Jews think laxly about mixed marriages; if he wishes to vindicate for Christ a wholly un-Jewish descent, then he declares mixed marriages between Jews and Galileans to be impossible."

These examples show well enough that the critic was upon the right scent, but at the same time also that he lost it again, if indeed he followed it at all, because he went astray in his expression. It is not quite correct that Chamberlain stands under the influence of the thought which he wishes to expound, and that not he masters the material, but the material him. The matter is rather this, that Chamberlain adapts himself voluntarily — whether consciously or unconsciously is another question — to the thoughts and materials which he happens to have in hand. But why so? Because he has presupposed ideas which he must at all costs prove to be true and apposite.

To be sure, Chamberlain speaks of the significance of the artistic element, of intuition, for science — and in this respect I can only allow that he is right. But is he entitled to appeal to this intuition? May he give out his preconceived, or, as he expresses it, "experienced" ideas for artistic divination?

He himself wavers whether he is to reckon himself among the artists in science, or among the — dilettanti. In the preface to his principal work he believes, indeed, that he may permit himself the luxury of a quite peculiar modesty. He calls himself a dilettante, but knows at once how to tell things highly laudatory of dilettantism. "Who does not perceive," says he, "that knowledge always wins living interest at the boundary lines. Every special knowledge is in and for itself indifferent: only through its relation to something else does it obtain significance." The traffic across the frontier, the mediation of relations, he now leaves solely and alone to the


*) Just now published in a third edition (F. A. Bruckmann's Verlag, Munich).

*) Houston Stewart Chamberlain. The Foundations of the Nineteenth Century. Discussed by H. C. (Berlin). Dresden and Leipzig. E. Pierson's Verlag, 1901.