Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 47 · 22 November 1901
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 47

(continued from page 3)

…was taken, so above all the synagogue conditions were thoroughly untenable. On the periphery of the city, whither the Jewry once dwelling in the centre had been pressed, separate congregations formed themselves, for the most part standing upon the traditional ground of Judaism. Yet even these were not — especially on the high festivals! — in a position to satisfy the religious needs of the thousands. Thus there soon thrust itself forward the downright loathsome phenomenon of the commercially conducted "festival services," which were often held in the meanest and most disreputable taverns and dance-halls. It would be to renew the whole pain that then crushed the breast of every decent Jew, were we to depict the shameful conditions which played themselves out before the eyes, and through the systematic inactivity, of the board of the community. A cry of horror went through that Berlin Jewry still fully conscious of its dignity. Then it was a question of gathering and organising the faithful, in order at last to overrun the downright criminal system. M. A. Klausner especially distinguished himself — a man as much an enemy of Zionism as he is a friend of the Zionists.

Hitherto only his indefatigable readiness to help expelled Jews had been known of him, Jews for whom his influence with the highest authorities procured permission of residence and rights of citizenship. Now he placed his sharp pen in the service of the Jewish cause, illuminating and shattering the crying abuses with unheard-of force, with annihilating scorn, with dazzling wit.

The "Commission of the Seventy-five," which hitherto had exerted itself quite impotently on behalf of the conservative cause at the elections of representatives, unfolded a lively agitation. For the first time the elections, about which hitherto no human being had troubled himself, brought a hitherto unknown movement into Jewish circles.

Indignation and fury at the want of understanding for the needs of the members of the community drove men to the ballot-box. The list of the Central Union for the Conservative Interests of the Jewish Community — as the Commission of the Seventy-five now called itself — came to a complete victory. They commanded a two-thirds majority, and thus had the power in their hands to set the conditions in order, or rather to shape them anew from the ground up. For their task had to be to make of the Berlin Jewish community, from an administrative institution which was steering towards cosmopolitan-ethical ideals, once again — a Jewish community.

Unhappily the "conservative" representatives did not requite the confidence of their electors. Only a few of them carried into the assembly a breath of the enthusiasm which had appointed them representatives. Shall we reproach them that they kept almost nothing of what they promised, that they did not even venture to attempt what, given an earnest will, must surely have succeeded with them? To their credit account there falls at bottom only the provision of a worthy festival service, which gives every Jew the opportunity of prayer. Otherwise they have done nothing. They re-elected the old board, which had ruined Jewry, and in the place of retiring members set purposeful Liberals once again. The religious instruction which they wished to have come to the good of every Jewish child had to be forced upon them by Minister Bosse. For even among the "Conservatives" there were still visionaries of political Liberalism, with its dread of all compulsion, with its pitiable pride in its "let things go" theory. Against the throwing open of the synagogues they set themselves. The gratuitousness of instruction in Jewish history, literature and ritual was combated by a part of them. As to the appointment of a Jewish rabbi, nothing has happened. For the relief of the want of synagogues they have undertaken nothing. Nay, they gave their votes that in the new show-synagogue in the Lützowstrasse — which meets not the faintest need — the castrated prayer-book should be reintroduced. And what have they accomplished to wipe out again the disgrace that in the Siddur all the passages which treat of Zion and of our national independence in past and future are struck out? They appointed a commission — which, however, never met. What has happened, the board pushed through. Not out of love and fidelity to the tradition of our people, but out of policy, in order by little concessions (support of the private congregations, promotion of the manifold societies for the revival of Jewry, etc.) to stop the mouths of the discontented.

But could the "Conservatives" then do anything; did they make themselves guilty only of the sin of omission, the "Conservatives"? Such a thing does not exist at all. One may speak only of the candidates of the Conservative Electoral Union. Of these, however, the fewest had anything to do with a persevering fidelity to Jewry. As unhappily is always the case with us Jews, titles and means rather than conviction were decisive for their designation. One does the conservative representatives wrong in reproaching them with a lack of fidelity to conviction. Who can be faithful to a conviction without possessing one. There were Jews out of resignation, Jews out of defiance, Jews out of inward despair, Jews out of piety, Jews out of habit, Jews out of sloth, but only a very few were Jews out of Jewish pride, out of Jewish self-consciousness, Jews out of the joy of Jewish hope for the future, in short Jews out of Judaism. The conservative representatives were themselves in the moral minority as against the liberals, at the time when they had the crushing majority. For the Liberals had a fixed programme; they knew what they wanted. The Conservatives, however — forgive them, Lord! — they did not know — what they are.

It was thus only the natural consequence that at the next election — three years ago — the Conservatives lost their seats and therewith their majority. In a certain sense a favour was thereby done them, for they now had an excuse for their inactivity, for the impossibility of demanding positive achievements.

So the matter stands to-day, when once again one half of the representatives retires. But what gives the whole situation its significance is the weighty fact that among those retiring are almost all the conservative representatives. Upon this election hangs the fate of the conservative party — not, however, the future of Judaism, as with immoderate exaggeration the wire-pullers of the Conservatives in their despair assert. So badly as that it surely does not yet stand with our Judaism. Though it be a thankless business to foretell the future — almost as thankless as the work for Jewish ends — yet one may say with tolerable certainty that the elections of representatives will sweep the Conservatives out of the community chamber. This issue would be regrettable only on account of a few really worthy and enthusiastic Jews, among them for example Privy Medical Councillor Dr. Blumenthal. But to the conservative cause no greater service can be rendered than that those men be set aside who, under the cloak of a faithful Judaism, profaned the conservative cause.

When we Zionists resolved to enter into the electoral contest, there could not for a moment prevail among us any doubt as to which side we had to take,