Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 38 · 20 September 1901
13printed page
scan 13 of 16

No. 38. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 13.

(continued from page 12)

… the editorial office of the "Wschod". We congratulate our Lemberg comrades upon their fine work, out of which a new centre of the Zionist movement there may develop.

Review of Books and Periodicals.

Books Received.

יידישער פאָלקס-קאלענדער ("Jewish People's Calendar"). Sixth year, 5662. Edited by גרשם באדער (Gerschom Bader). Price 60 Heller. Lemberg, 5662.

ביבליותיקא עברית "תושיה" (Hebrew Library "Tushijah"), קורות היהודים ברומא ("History of the Jews in Rome"), by A. Kahana, vol. I., book I. Warsaw, 5661.

*

In the latest number of our Berlin sister-paper, the "Israclitische Rundschau", our comrade Dr. Jeremias of Posen comes to terms with the cultural Zionism of Achad-Haam in a stimulating and in many respects apt manner. We reproduce here a great part of these remarks in their own words:

" . . . Zionism has fortunately now advanced so far that it can afford itself the luxury of party formations in parliament and press. Thus, for example, there is detaching itself ever more distinctly a social-political Zionism which, abstracting for the present from the Herzlian model social State, sketches a formal programme of economic reforms for Golus Jewry as well. On the other side a tendency which played a great part in pre-Herzlian Zionism is striving after equal and increased validity within the modern movement: it is cultural Zionism. Only quite lately the "Welt" (Nos. 30, 31) reproduced in substance, from the Jargon periodical "Der Jude", the confession of one of the most notable representatives of that current.

Had Achad Haam contented himself with bringing out more strongly the cultural side of Zionism, as lying especially near to him and congenial to him, that could nowhere have called forth contradiction. For its even and harmonious formation and further development the great idea requires to be contemplated from various sides, and at the present moment, when the practical-economic tendency is pressing somewhat noisily towards action, the marking out of intellectual and cultural interests is even almost to be desired. But Achad Haam sets up cultural Zionism as an exclusive, sovereign ideal, beside which the cultivation of material endeavours is to have no place whatever. "Does Zionism constitute a solution of the economic Jewish question? asks Achad Haam, and he answers roundly: no." The social distress under which the Jews in various countries sigh must, he holds, be regarded as the distress of individuals, for which the economic formations of the present bear the blame, and with which the striving towards Zion has nothing to do. Like an old Manchester man he calls out to those thus suffering: mourn over the misery of the modern age, for what can we do for you? Only those, he says, might strive towards Zion who are united by the need of intellectual union, by the longing for a new spiritual Judaism. Zion is to become a centre of national intellectual culture, a "home for the Jewish spirit", for which our soundest and noblest human material is just good enough. Emanations of this ideal sphere are to penetrate into the Jewish settlements of the Diaspora, enlivening, elevating, ennobling, dispensing intellectual culture and new values of life.

So a super-Judaism is to be created after Nietze's recipe, and for this the land of our fathers is to be reserved?! I wish and hope, and with me assuredly very many, that this Zionism of the elect may remain confined to a narrow circle of highly estimable but unworldly enthusiasts. Their limited special ideal too may work upon the whole great comprehensive movement in a stimulating, fructifying, purifying way, and may hinder an all too crass materialisation. But by itself it is in no wise practicable.

I do not wish to fling catchwords about me. "Everything for the people, through the people, with the people." "The masses are to-day the driving and moving element, the true bearers of every popular movement." I am concerned rather to prove that the very premises of naked cultural Zionism do not hold good. Is it then really true that the economic distress of the Jews is only a sum of individual destinies? It is indeed to carry owls to Athens if I recall that in Achad Haam's own homeland there exists a specifically Jewish proletarian misery such as has not its like in the world. That in Roumania, Galicia and other half-Asiatic countries a social Jewish distress of a peculiar kind exists has not been first discovered by Zionism, nor tendentiously sharpened for purposes of agitation; antisemitic and asemitic boycott are there to be grasped with the hands. But even we in Germany can sing a song of economic distresses; the immense circle of the official and officer class, which secures a quiet livelihood to thousands of sons of Christian parents, the career of the judge and the calling of the teacher are closed to us; the academic career too stands open to us in many cases only as far as the volunteer assistant at royal institutes, seldom does one bring it to a privat-docent or even to an extraordinary professorship. Exchange business and intermediate trade are bolted and barred in every way, the department stores punished with heavy taxes, the pedlar's trade made almost impossible. What then remains over? The German Jew, who has completely assimilated himself to the German Michel in thick-skinnedness, would soon quite forget particular occurrences such as Xanten and Konitz, if it were not precisely these economic restrictions that at all times kept his eyes open to the fact that a special Jewish distress exists.

If one really means to solve a problem thousands of years old, the Jewish question, to make away with it radically, then one must first of all come to terms with such numerous and impressive facts of experience of the past and the present. To seek to remedy the many-sided Jewish distress from one end alone is thoroughly mistaken, but most perverse of all when one expects salvation from intellectual over-culture alone and exclusively. The renaissance of the ancient soil of our home cannot and must not proceed from a small band of intellectual pioneers; only a whole nation, which like others exhibits every stratum of social and intellectual differentiation, will be able to accomplish the work of wonder.

Zionism is not at all an idea, an ideal, but a world-view; it embraces a national-political as well as an ethical-religious, and likewise a social-economic as well as an aesthetic-intellectual ideal. Zion shall one day become a centre of national, intellectual-moral and social culture, protected and supported by the self-sacrificing love of an entire people."

Communications of the Society for the Free Employment Registry.

Vienna, II. Taborstrasse No. 59.

Telephone No. 13920.

offers its services free of charge to P. T. employers. A written or telephonic order suffices to obtain the assignment of qualified male and female workers as well as unskilled labourers, and further of commercial employees and teachers of both sexes.

On the 13th of September the following stood upon the register:

Class I. (Manual Workers).

8 mounters and leather dressers, 2 sculptors and stonemasons, 1 bronze-worker, 1 printer, 5 office attendants, 6 turners, 7 electrical fitters, 1 each butcher, hairdresser, electroplater, 33 shop attendants, 3 glaziers, 6 gold- and silver-workers, 10 house-servants and caretakers, 6 installation fitters, 4 machinists and stokers, 20 unskilled labourers, 2 hatters, 7 cellar-masters and cellar-lads, 7 coachmen, 17 errand-boys and apprentices, 7 storekeepers, 4 mechanics, 4 metal-turners, founders and polishers, 20 locksmiths for building and machinery, 1 smith, 16 tailors, 7 compositors, 11 shoemakers, 7 tinsmiths, 4 bag-makers, strap-makers and saddlers, 5 joiners, 6 watchmakers, 3 draughtsmen for building and construction.

Class II. (Commercial Employees).

12 spirit-retailers, 21 book-keepers and correspondents, 79 clerks of various branches, 39 counting-house clerks and day-book keepers, 12 collectors, 3 clerks and copyists, 6 clerical assistants, 48 probationers, 15 travellers, local representatives and agents.

Female Department.

6 nursery governesses and kindergarten teachers, 46 female counting-house clerks, 3 maidservants and chambermaids, 2 receptionists, 10 female dispatch clerks and clerical assistants, 2 female clerks and stenographers, 2 lady cashiers, 1 each machine-seamstress and umbrella-seamstress, 2 milliners, 21 female probationers, 1 dressmaker, 48 saleswomen, 6 housekeepers and lady-helps.

Class III. (Intellectual Work).

25 private tutors and governors.

Since its opening in November 1899 up to and inclusive of the 13th of September 1901 the bureau of the Society has carried through — 2650 placings, namely:

1119 placings in Class I. (Manual Labour), 674 placings in Class II. (Commercial Employees), 798 placings in the Female Department, 69 placings in Class III. (intellectual work) .