No. 35 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 11
(continued from page 10)
…on display. The paper has now received from our fellow-partisan Herr Emanuel Liebermann in Vajdácska a corrective communication, which it printed in full, with a loyalty deserving of acknowledgment. In the communication it is said, among other things: "In your number of the 13th of August there appeared, under the heading 'A Country on Shares', an article signed with the sign 'Nemo', which I, as a good patriot and as good a Zionist, cannot let pass without remark. The writer of the said article occupies himself with Zionism, a movement which in five short years has encircled the whole globe, has found in all quarters of the world numerous enthusiastic adherents ready for sacrifice, and even now in ever greater measure wins hearts in unprejudiced Christian as well as Jewish circles. It might therefore have been expected of the writer of the article that, if he does not know the details of this movement, he should at least make himself acquainted with its essence. Unhappily, however, there is expressed in his lines such an ignorance that I was positively abashed at having to read these lines precisely in this paper, which is otherwise wont to be very matter-of-fact, and precisely from the pen of this writer, who for the most part passes correct and well-considered judgments. I will not enter upon the refutation of all his assertions and sophisms, because I fear to become prolix. But the view which is reflected in the following sentence: 'We do not indeed believe that the Jew longs so very much to get out of his fatherland and for this purpose would readily put his hand in his pocket' — the view, that is, as though Zionism made it anybody's duty to long to get out of his fatherland, this view I must decidedly reject. From the very beginning Zionism has demanded of no single Jew anything other than that he help to save that portion of his racial brethren, to whom in the land of their birth neither civil rights nor so much as the rights of man are granted, whom men suffer neither to live nor to die, from final ruin, from bodily and spiritual stunting — and this by furthering, materially and morally, the founding of a secured home for these unfortunates. I can decidedly maintain that no one can point to any Zionist newspaper or other printed publication which has called for emigration. It is always only a question of creating for those Jews who are thrust out of their land of birth and find admittance nowhere a better and more hopeful home. It is absolutely inadmissible that unpatriotic sentiments should be imputed to so much as a single Hungarian Jew because he desires to help his suffering Russian, Roumanian and Polish racial brethren to nourish themselves in the sweat of their brow by the work of their own hands and to become self-conscious men. I do not appeal at all to individual highly respected English and Hungarian personages, whose patriotism not even the most foolhardy malice can call in question, although they confess themselves to the idea of Zionism, further its progress so far as they are able, and long for the realisation of its aims. Rather do I commend the stenographic report of the Fourth Zionist Congress to the attention of the writer of the article. From it, as from the other Zionist printed writings, he can convince himself that nothing more and nothing less is demanded of the Zionist Jew than that he should not suppress and not disown his human nature; that is to say, that he should not conceal his Judaism, should not be ashamed of his descent, should learn thoroughly the history of his race, should take into himself the content of ideas, the ideal view of the world and the unexampled philanthropic conception of Judaism, and should bring small pecuniary sacrifices towards the bringing about of a better future for his oppressed racial brethren."
The writer of the article of whom we are speaking remarks upon this communication, among other things, that Herr Liebermann has misunderstood him and has taken in earnest that with which the writer of the article merely wished to caricature the argumentation of the trivial anti-Semitism of the streets. For the rest, he subscribes to every word of Herr Liebermann's and salutes his patriotic and noble sentiments.
—z —l.
Breslau Letter.
By Ben Elia.
The Jewish and the liberal German newspapers rejoiced unrestrainedly these last days at being able to give the following notice:
"Upon the fate of anti-Semitism the writer Wilberg expresses himself in a pamphlet in the following manner:
For 16 years I have stood in the Berlin anti-Semitic movement, and as a speaker for our cause in Berlin I am probably the only one who has not only seen but also lived through the time from Henrici until to-day. From Henrici until to-day! Every honest anti-Semite is seized with a grim wrath when he thinks back over this time; and he who has sacrificed for a full 18 years his lungs, his health, his livelihood and no inconsiderable part of his money might well despair when he sees how everything has hitherto been in vain, and how little we have attained in so long a time . . . Had we but always kept one cause in view, we should to-day probably be the mightiest and most influential party in the whole land. But unhappily we have all too often put the question of persons instead of the cause into the foreground. And precisely upon that we were bound to founder again and again. Not a single party has counted so many jugglers and windbags in its ranks as ours, and no party has let itself be led by the nose by heroes of phrases and by wretched speculators as the anti-Semitic party has."
Thou holy simplicity! As though anti-Semitism were dead with that. What the notice says has neither the merit of being anything new nor of being of any significance whatever. We have long known the noble qualities of character of the anti-Semitic spokesmen; but do their words weigh the less on that account? Do they the less meet the instinctive feelings of the people? — And even though the wild outcry against the Jews in Germany has for the present somewhat abated — at a fitting time it will be heard loudly enough again — the really far worse silent hatred against the Jews makes itself felt in all strata of society more than ever.
It is not to be denied that in the last years there has taken place in Germany an almost complete social separation of the Jews from the Christians. Assuredly it has not been brought about by the Jews. They have felt it bitterly enough that it was forced upon them. Perhaps in the circles of the highest Jewish moneyed aristocracy we still find Christian intercourse, and then through a few Odd Fellow and similar lodges, which admittedly have at least 80% of Jews, who thus labour for the universal brotherhood of man. People no longer know one another at all. This struck me quite particularly when I lately had occasion to read, at short intervals, various books by modern German authors of Jewish race. Even where they by no means intend it, they depict a Jewish milieu and above all Jewish characters. The psychology of the Christian is foreign to them. And so it goes with every one of us. We pass judgments upon some process of the soul or other, set it forth as a general human phenomenon or as the inner life of the German, and finally perceive, upon closer reflection, that we do not know the German at all, that we have judged out of the feeling of the Jew. Nor indeed can it be otherwise. At school already the Christian pupils had their secrets from us; we knew them all as anti-Semites; they avoided us when they did not happen to need us. The young Christian merchant is in the anti-Semitic German-National Union of Commercial Employees, or else he agitates — only a few, and these mostly Jews — for Social Democracy. The Christian student, however, may not know a Jew at all, if only by reason of his students' association. If for once one of them is not an anti-Semite, or at the least an a-Semite, one will hardly believe it and does not rightly trust it. Indeed the average Jew in Germany to-day admits without more ado, in intercourse with his own people, that he holds a priori every Christian to be an anti-Semite. If one of them for once does not show it, search is made with all speed for the egoistic motives which move him to conceal his true sentiments.
But in public one must keep up appearances.
