Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 32 · 9 August 1901
7printed page
scan 7 of 16

No. 32 — "Die Welt" — Page 7

Whence, under these circumstances, are we to take the energetic and self-sacrificing intellectual forces needed for the regeneration of Jewry, for the national rebirth? Years ago already the well-known Hebrew writer R. Brainin, who then still lived in Vienna and belonged to the students' union, raised in one of his articles the question: הסופרים מאין ימצאו — Whence shall we take writers? And I now ask Whence shall we take Jews at all? Not poor, sick and degenerate Jews — of these our people has more than enough — but Jews bodily and mentally sound, nationally minded, energetic, self-sacrificing, such as our people needs for its rebirth upon the soil of the fathers?

Such a student, who through the better half of his life has had to wage the brutal struggle with oppressive want, who, forsaken of all men, embittered and consumed with care, vegetates on until he comes into possession of the ardently longed-for doctor's diploma — such a student will then perhaps be able to be a good physician, a capable jurist, a practised engineer in life — perhaps; I hold it, indeed, to be very questionable — but never and nevermore will he be a sturdy, self-conscious, self-sacrificing Jew. Rather will he, after he has attained his goal, strive to procure for himself a lucrative benefice . . . .

And here we come directly upon the question of the so-called cultural activity of the Zionists. The Russian Zionists have hitherto, namely, borne themselves quite indifferently towards this question. To be sure, this indifference finds its explanation and justification in the circumstance that on the whole most Russian Zionists confined themselves from the very outset to political, or rather agitational, activity, and would not concern themselves with work of the present. Besides, for the founding of Jewish secondary schools, for the support of university students, etc., very large sums of money were necessary, so that this activity is a far more complicated and more difficult one to carry out than the founding of Jewish elementary schools, model Chedarim, and the like. Now, as concerns the means, the example of the few Jewish private schools already in existence is encouraging; they are very well placed in a financial respect, although they are maintained only by private undertakers and enjoy no subventions whatever. These private secondary schools would indeed be Jewish-national schools in the best sense of the word, since a sufficient instruction in the Hebrew language, in Jewish history and literature could be imparted to the pupils.

Of late, moreover, the Russian Zionists appear to have perceived the necessity of a cultural work of the present, as is to be gathered from the resolutions of the Zionist district conferences of Minsk and Elisabethgrad. Many Russian comrades in conviction, however, will still not reckon with the fact that this original — I would say embryonic — form of the Zionist programme has long since developed into a riper organism, answering to all the demands of life.

"By this local activity we shall stray from our chief aim," one of the most respected Russian Zionists said to me a short while ago. That, however — by your leave — is a wholly groundless view. I hold fast to the conviction that this activity of the present not only cannot lead us away from the chief aim — the rebirth of the Jewish people upon the historic soil of Palestine — but, quite on the contrary, will contribute to the attainment of that final aim. For only where there is inactivity and standstill, there too is decomposition and death. The best proof of it is that, as experience shows, in those Russian Zionist unions and local groups where no local activity has been developed, the political-Zionist activity also gradually declines. In the unions, on the other hand, which devote themselves energetically to the practical tasks of the present, there prevails, in respect of the sale of shares and of the shekel as well as otherwise in the matter of propaganda, a brisk life which warrants the best hopes for the future.

(To be continued.)


Discussion Evenings in the Gumpendorf Workers' Educational Union.

The largest Viennese workers' educational union has seen cause to make the Zionist idea the subject of serious discussions — a progress for which thanks are due to the young critical spirit in the workers' organisations. Admittedly this critical spirit not without presuppositions, but tendentious; yet the mere intention of seeming other than one is, is a sign of a strengthening conscience. Speeches that were delivered were typical, and so likewise were the convictions and characters which sought to overcome one another by mere dialectic: Social Democrats, who out of an ideal attachment to a Marxism desecrated and unhappily only too often carped at in utter want of understanding, have divested themselves of the mere will to take in new ideas; Social Radicals, who exchange the glances of augurs among themselves and within the Social Democratic party make opposition on behalf of free science, but outwardly combat every criticism that is ventured by the unorganised, that is to say by laymen; Social Politicians, who flee from the social din of the world into their quiet study and there divert themselves by puffing social theorems out into the world in the shape of iridescent, empty soap-bubbles; and finally Jewish Socialists, who, hunted by ambition, would have a hand in everything, who pursue criticism and counter-criticism with equal passion, and who burst the iron hoops of their logic upon one theme only: upon the Jewish question. They make a present of their heart and their soul to humanity, and beg for themselves, as a token of gratitude, the toleration and the hushing-up of their Judaism. Objective and just towards the whole world, subjective and unjust towards their own person, their family, their people. Anti-Semitic in consequence of the "disagreeable qualities of the Jews," anational in defiance of history and development, irreligious not out of real conviction, but only in the political interest.

These are the four factions in the free socialist associations; these are the bearers of the struggles for principles and for equality of rights.

Zionism has for its opponents chiefly the real and the Jewish Social Democrats. The latter are fighting for their position in the party, which would be shaken if the bankruptcy of assimilation were suffered to become known. This struggle for existence makes the Jewish Socialists into narrow-minded fanatics, who from sophistical instincts would deny even the misery of the Jews out of the world. Jewish Socialists will not feel their Judaism pulsing again in their veins until, through the most painful experiences, they have recognised the necessity of reconstructing their superficial cosmopolitanism upon a national basis.

The discussion showed that a great confusion of ideas has broken in upon the anti-Zionist heads: Dr. Herzl's "Judenstaat" is combated because it passes for the Basle Programme. The erection of a home is held in horror so long as it is not expressly proclaimed a social republic — and this by Bernsteinians, who declare: "The way is everything to us, the goal nothing!"

Upon one point only was there full harmony between the Zionists and their opponents, namely, in the establishing of the fact that Social Democracy suffers from a hypertrophy of Jewish leaders — a disease which from