Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 26 · 28 June 1901
5printed page
scan 5 of 16
Facsimile · scan 5 of 16
Scan of p. 5
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 26 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 5

(continued from page 4)

…has likewise been attended throughout with good success; for we now count nearly 100 adherents here and in the province. Two societies, "Ahawath Zion" and "Dorsche Schelom Zion," are winning recruits for Zionism. Friends of our persuasion are working for our ideas as far up as East Friesland, and in the Brunswick "Society for Jewish History and Literature" a member of our committee has spoken upon the nature and the aims of Zionism. As our members labour for our ideas not only in the meetings, we have of late been able to create a number of institutions within the association — Hebrew language classes, a Share Club, and the like: new foundations which are furnishing the proof of their vitality. The Shekel Day meeting brought us, like every earlier meeting, a number of new adherents, and carried the Zionist ideas once more into wider circles. As speaker we welcomed Dr. Walter Friedemann of Berlin, who spoke upon the theme "Zionism in the Present and in the Future." The meeting was attended by some 250 persons, who accorded the speaker abundant applause. An animated discussion followed the address. Shekel Day admonishes us to new creation, to fresh activity. We hope that it will prove a successful one.

The Congress of the Zionist Students.

As is known, a Congress of the Zionist students is to take place this summer at Geneva. The programme of this Congress is familiar to the readers of the "Welt." It embraces the whole field of Zionism, in its theoretical and in its practical aspect. One is almost tempted to say that the programme is too fine to be capable of execution.

It is now for us to take up our position towards this Congress.

We would above all answer the primordial question which many a Zionist has already put to himself, and could not but put: Why, then, a Congress specially of the students? Can the younger elements not bring forward their views at the general Congress? Or is Zionism, which is not yet so very old, already to have its "Modernism"?"

If we read through the minutes of the Munich preliminary conference, we find two fundamental causes which led to the summoning of the Students' Congress. In the first place, there are doubtless certain elements among the younger men who may be dissatisfied with what they hold to be the slow advance of Zionism; who would gladly accomplish great deeds; for whom the collection of the shekel and the sale of shares of the Zionist Bank are mere prose; who, in a word, would "organise" the Jewish people, and that upon a progressive basis — in short, for whom the chief value lies in "cultural work."

The second cause is the very sad fact that the Jewish students, and indeed the Jewish intellectuals generally, stand aloof from Judaism — not, forsooth, out of egoism or indifference, but because to many of them Zionism appears too narrow-hearted, too circumscribed, too Utopian. If we take into account the Jewish intellectuals in Russia in particular, we must admit that they take part with great self-sacrifice in all the political and social movements for the benefit of the Russian people. It is therefore not from any lack of capacity for work or for sacrifice that they stand aloof from Zionism, but because they regard Zionism — to put it plainly — as a reactionary or a Utopian movement. We see, then, that the two causes are closely bound up with one another; they complete each other. Taken together, they justify sufficiently the summoning of a Zionist Students' Congress.

The mere fact that the resolution of the Munich preliminary conference quite expressly emphasises that our intellectuals stand upon the ground of the Basle Programme is proof enough that there can be no question of any antagonism between the general Zionist Congresses and the coming Students' Congress. More precisely: the Zionist intellectuals, under the influence of the surrounding general culture, would fain bring to Zionism new points of view, new spheres of action, new objects of struggle, and thereby gain in influence and in effective power; but they do not wish to create antagonisms within Zionism. Nor must we here leave out of account a very important psychological fact: most Jewish intellectuals have become Zionists only after they already possessed a sort of general world-view, after they had worked out within themselves some general ideal. Thus the Zionist and the universally human ideal march side by side. For a time Zionism may indeed have suppressed all other ideals; but so soon as Zionism was led over out of the domain of rhetoric into that of the practical struggle of life, the general tendencies came to light — and so it had to be. In any case it is permissible here to bring forward the opinion of an eminent man who is, precisely in this field, of great authority. We mean Moses Hess, who fought all his life long for a universally human ideal. He says: "Among the Jews, far more even than among nations that are oppressed upon their own soil, national independence must precede every political and social progress. A common native soil is for them the first condition of healthier conditions of labour." And further: "The Jewish masses will take part in the great historical movement of modern humanity only when they shall possess a Jewish fatherland."*)

Nevertheless the endeavour after a synthesis of the Zionist — the purely national — and the social-philosophical — the universally human — ideal is fully warranted, and especially among the studying youth. This endeavour is, in our own personal opinion, the chief motive of the coming Congress at Geneva. Regarded from this point of view, the Congress will be of eminent significance, and that in manifold respects.

In the first place, by this synthesis a means might be gained of making the very numerous Jewish intelligence (especially in Russia) Zionist. There is no denying the fact that Zionism, as a purely national movement, in the midst of an epoch in which the struggle for a better future of all humanity is being fought out, may appear to many a Jewish intellectual somewhat circumscribed, quite apart from the practicability of the Zionist ideal. The abolition of the dualism between Zionism and universalism will most certainly help to bring the idealistic Jewish intelligence nearer to Zionism, or rather to make it more "universally human." It is clear that propaganda among the Jewish intellectuals can best be conducted only by younger, "intellectual" Zionists. The coming Congress is precisely to help towards organising our Zionist youth for the purposes of an intensive propaganda within the Jewish intellectual class. That new forces will thereby be brought to Zionism lies upon the surface. In the second place, by this synthesis a soil can and will be created for a fruitful practical, "real-political" activity. For even though we fight for a national ideal, we do it nevertheless with international means, borrowed from the universally human culture. The more so, as the Zionist ideal not only does not exclude, but positively compels us, only upon the real ground, upon


*) M. Hess: "Rom und Jerusalem," 2nd edition, pp. 92—94.