No. 22 — "Die Welt" — Page 9
(continued from page 8)
…tacks, he imagines himself to be doing so with full right and title; that everywhere he condemns Judaism, he believes himself to be pronouncing a well-grounded judgment. Such an opponent, an opponent who comes with convictions, with reasons, be he welcome to us; it is the only enmity with which, I think, we are still able to cope, the only one that does honour to our opponents as well as to ourselves. The weapons of intellectual combat are wielded even in times of the profoundest peace; be they whetted never so keenly — so long only as they are not poisoned, they are permitted weapons. It is indeed a fair dream to wish to compose in calm interchange of thought all the antagonisms that divide men from one another; the concepts themselves — and what are concepts? — words, abstractions, hinder and hamper and set themselves against it. Concepts such as people, race, compel science itself to a step-by-step precision of marks, of differences, of antagonisms, and they help, without willing it, to fan the flame of national hatred. "Through the whole judging of peoples," says so temperate an inquirer as Friedrich Ratzel, "there runs the indubitable fundamental fact of the feeling of individual self-exaltation, that one thinks rather unfavourably than favourably of one's fellow-men" — an utterance which neither we nor our opponents would have the courage to contradict. "But," adds the same inquirer, "we will at least strive to be just." — Yes, that we will; and we believe that we attain it above all by laying clear conceptions at the foundation of the notions which we have inherited from of old or now newly coin; by examining how far actual and sincere feelings correspond to them.
With this resolve I mean to approach Chamberlain's assertions, and in particular his judgments upon Judaism. In a series of letters I shall subject his criticism to a criticism; not methodically and systematically, but merely following the inward impulse, I shall bring forward now this, now that out of the whole, spinning the thread at will, now shorter, now longer. Yet I feel that it will nevertheless be no jumble of chance selection. Rather might it befall me that I shall pass over much, in order to dwell with all the greater concentration, and all the longer, upon the piece that touches us most nearly. Wherein this consists you will doubtless divine. Among all the questions that Chamberlain treats, none is so fitted to strike us into the very heart as the religious question, as he unrolls it. Upon the heritage of religion inherited from Judaism the peoples of the Occident have looked as upon the crown of their spiritual life. And to us also it is a crown; a crown which perhaps only for passing times we have not the right to set upon our head — because we have lost the strength to bear it, because we have lost the other tokens of royalty. With the more painful pride do we look upon this our heritage. Even the grimmest enemies of Judaism have not ventured to call this heritage in question: religion, it springs from Judaism. Now there appears an opponent who would rob us of our right, would take the heritage from us. Then let us see whether we cannot defend ourselves against him.
Review of Periodicals and Books
The May number of the "North American Review" brings an essay by our fellow-partisan Rev. Doctor M. Gaster upon: "Jews and Judaism in the Nineteenth Century". After a brief summary of the currents within the Jewry of the nineteenth century, and after the psychology of Jewish emancipation has received a detailed appreciation, Dr. Gaster comes to speak of the causes which made emancipation — from which its champions had promised themselves so uncommonly much — become a farce in most European countries. The great fault which the Jews committed lay in this, that they had learned nothing from the past, and that they regarded a current accidentally drifting upon the surface as an awakening of the sense of justice among the European peoples. This fallacy misled them into breaking impetuously with the past, and all their striving was from that time forth concentrated upon outbidding, if possible, in "patriotism" the very peoples in whose midst they lived. But by their unnatural chauvinism they awakened only suspicion. Dr. Gaster then comes to speak at large of Zionism, which alone and by itself is in a position to solve one of the most difficult of modern social problems, and to free the European peoples from an element which is still always felt by them to be a foreign body. That the greater part of the well-to-do Jews holds aloof from this movement, because it cannot distinguish between citizenship of a State and the historic duties which membership of an ancient nation imposes upon a man, cannot come into consideration. The broad masses of Jewry, among whom the national feeling had never died out, are all fire and flame for the movement. "Therefore must Zionism be regarded as the sign in which Judaism enters upon the new century."
Newark, N. J. Jul. Z.
Dr. S. W. Guttmann: Bikkurim I. — Exhortations, delivered for the Jewish school youth (in Polish). Lemberg, 1901.
By these "first-fruits" of his homiletic talent the author introduces himself as an excellent force in the field of homiletic exegesis.
Every single exhortation develops, upon the basis of the weekly portion in question, some religious-moral or religious-national idea, yet in a form so beautiful and so simple, so appealing alike to the mind of the child and to the childlike heart, that this collection may be set beside the "Sansinim" of Schmiedel as a model of addresses for the services of youth. The exceedingly thoughtful interpretation of biblical events, as well as the pedagogic skill which always hits the childlike tone, nowhere exceeds the child's power of conception, but rather everywhere knows how to hold it fast, make the book one of the best among the so-called "collections of exhortations for youth". — In the interest of the Jewish school youth, and not less of the teachers, it would be very well worth while to translate this little collection into German. Schalom.
Dr. Ludwig Philippson: Did the Jews really crucify Jesus? Second edition. With a preface by Professor Dr. M. Philippson. Leipzig. M. W. Kaufmann.
A can of the milk of right thinking stands at the service of the nations with this pamphlet; only that, unhappily, the thirsty are so few. What does it avail that Jews can preach never so convincingly, when their speeches are drowned by wild cries: Jew, Jew! Triumphantly the preface reports x editions and translations. We readily believe that the Jews of the whole world have bought themselves a logical confirmation of their own opinion. Dr. Philippson, in unshakable faith in the will of non-Jewish humanity to acknowledge the right, has taken pains to assist that will, truly with wit and with compelling deductions. But does not the author himself believe that a witty theologian of the opposite party, with a few colourings and with authors and arguments credible to him, will find a far greater and a far more willing audience? For not even the best of men can live in peace if it does not please his evil neighbour. Certainly we acknowledge that the constant drop hollows the stone. But it is a tedious business, this hollowing, and we Jews have deuced little time to stand looking on until this outrageously hard stone has got its hole, into which we may then pour logic and the sense of right. Our Jewish scholars dream away too much time in their studies; when life shall have seized them, they will, it is to be hoped, cease to live for the past. We need their spirit for our future. M. S.
Of the new Hebrew youth journal "Olam Katan", which by the well-known Warsaw publishing com-
