Page 4. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 18.
(continued from page 3)
…zur Statistik des jüdischen Stammes" by Alfred Nossig.*) But I will not treat the present question here from the exalted standpoint of science at all, but rather keep to the popular framework of this paper. There exist, indeed, a number of popular expositions of this subject which are readily accessible to a larger public. Had Herr Groller read even these alone, he would not have let himself be carried away into the assertion that, upon the demand for proofs of the axiom he castigates, one always meets with a taciturn embarrassment and hears the phrase of embarrassment: "But surely everybody knows that!" As against this, let there be recalled here above all the report which Professor Mandelstamm presented at the last Congress and which is doubtless to Herr Groller's hand as well. M., who in the midst of his fellow-countrymen carries on an extensive practice and who, out of general humane as well as national-Jewish interests, has with high earnestness immersed himself in the sanitary milieu of the Russian Jews, by no means contents himself in his address with the mere establishment of a "decrepit, wretchedly weak bodily constitution", of the "frightful physical degeneracy". Rather does he expressly bring out, therein for the most part following the experiences of Russian military physicians, particular features of the physical inferiority: backwardness in stature (on the average 162·7 cm. against 165—170 among non-Jews), slight development of the chest-bones and muscles, narrowness of chest (in 60% of the Jewish conscripts the girth of the chest fell far short of the norm, that is to say of half the length of the body), stooping carriage, strikingly small power of resistance to tuberculosis, wide prevalence of scrofulous affections, especially affections of the skin, of Egyptian eye-disease and of short-sightedness, greatly heightened disposition to nervous and mental maladies. I myself add to this survey the further fact that, according to the studies which a Russian military physician made upon a large material and published some two years ago, hernias are three times as frequent among Jews as among non-Jews.
All these phenomena of bodily depravation, which Blechmann**) sums up under the catchword "physiological misère", are found above all among the Jewish masses of the East (Russia, Galicia, Roumania), which together constitute about three-fourths of the whole of Jewry. The cause of this inferior constitution Mandelstamm seeks solely in the economic misery of the proletarian Eastern Jews, and for that reason he left the bodily condition of the Jews of the West entirely out of play in his report. Yet I must point out that the physical constitution of the Western Jews also is by no means a normal one. The ghetto-misery of the forefathers, endured through many centuries, has left deep traces behind, which cannot have been wholly eradicated by 50 years of tolerably free development. The lesser stature, the tendency to flat-foot, varicose veins, haemorrhoids and hernias, the disposition to diabetes and to sundry other internal ailments — these are such marks of degeneration as, by the concurrent judgment of all experienced clinicians, belong in a high degree to the West European Jews. It is further statistically established that the birth-rate of the German Jews is steadily declining, whether compared with the earlier time or with the present rate of increase among the German Christians. (If nevertheless the increase among the Jews proceeds proportionately more rapidly, that is because this deficit of births is more than made good by the more careful treatment of the children, so that the percentage of infant mortality among the Jews in Germany is only about a third as high as among the non-Jews.) It is further established statistically beyond doubt that the number of the mentally diseased among the German Jews is twice as high as would correspond to their share of the population.
I may perhaps append to these dry data a few personal impressions which can likewise throw some light upon our theme. From my own experience I can report that in German, or at least in East German, gymnasia the Jewish pupils have a monopoly of the last gymnastic squad; when I was a gymnasium pupil we had in this Jews' squad literally a Minjan, and by that alone received very early a deep impression of our national peculiarity and physical inferiority. In the academic lecture-halls too the Jews are as conspicuous by their indefatigable diligence as by the weakliness of their whole nature. Were one to make the jest of causing all the members of a "mixed" academic society to fall in in rank and file, one could almost sort out the various "confessions" from behind the front: of the tall, broad-shouldered, strong-boned, erectly held figures at least 80% are non-Jews. Or let one go for once into a bathing establishment and study the unveiled corporeality of the assembled youths! The Jewish youth there displays for the most part a sufficiently strong bony framework, at times also an ample or even luxuriant padding of fat. But how seldom does one discover in it the aesthetically refreshing, well-wrought relief of muscle, especially of the arms, a picture of vigorous manliness which in the average Aryan one misses only in relatively few cases. In short, in all the situations touched upon one experiences in oneself ever anew the painful sensation to which the spies lent expression in the words: "There we saw the giant sons of Anak, and we seemed to ourselves as grasshoppers, and so must we have appeared in their eyes also" (Numbers 13, 33).
The material here adduced speaks a plain language and suffices at all events to support the axiom of the physical inferiority of the Jews. It is nevertheless greatly to be desired that for this chapter firmer and broader foundations should be won by systematic investigations upon a large human material. But even this fleeting ethnographic sketch justifies the judgment that the completed picture of the physical peculiarity of Jewry will exhibit gloomy features.
And of what kind is the evidence which Groller brings into the field against our thesis? He rests upon certain physical maximum performances, proceeding from the theory that in the treatment of the present problem far less the average than the maximum values must serve as the standard. Were Groller to assent to this principle also where it is a question, for example, of the financial power of Jewry, he would infallibly arrive, like the anti-Semites, at the conclusion that "Jewish capital" weighs overpoweringly upon the world market; for it cannot be denied that, if only the capitalistic maximum values are entered into the statistics, a relatively higher share falls to the Jews than to the non-Jews. Yet Groller himself says in another place that it is "an old injustice to judge a whole people by certain exceptional phenomena." Therefore it proves, for Jewry taken as an ethnological unity, very little in the first instance if it turns out that it furnishes a considerable contingent to the foremost ranks of the international world of acrobats and of sport. (Groller might also have mentioned that the Jewish students' corporations everywhere furnish the best and most feared swordsmen.) The chief features of the total statistical picture are given precisely by the mean values; maximum performances — and minimum values too! — have doubtless an interest besides, but they permit conclusions only in one quite definite direction.
Well, the maximum performances adduced by G. also permit something to be inferred: namely, that the race cannot be in itself and from the ground up corrupted which still brings forth such men of physical strength at all. As indeed it is in itself already a sign of extraordinary racial qualities that "Jewry has manifested such tenacity in the endurance of hunger and want and, after a Tschandala existence of several thousand years, has not come down still worse." Here I can entirely agree with G. But the essential error in G.'s disquisitions is precisely this, that he does not know how to separate the archetype of the race, its innate physical endowment, from the time-picture of the same, its momentary physical constitution. For that the physical defectiveness is not a peculiarity inhering in the race itself, against this speaks already the testimony which Tacitus*) once bore to the Jews: "Corpora hominum salubria et ferentia laborum." Let one also look up in Nossig, Socialhygiene der Juden**), what he adduces concerning the "biotic advantages" of the Jewish stock; but he too establishes in his closing words a "weakening of the bodily structure and of the musculature", and then continues: "Had the social-hygienic legislation of the Bible prescribed bodily exercises, had Talmud and Schulchan Aruch energetically lent emphasis to that prescription, had Maimonides in "Yad hachasakah" recommended bodily labour not only for the promotion of digestion but for the cultivation of muscular strength,
*) Vienna 1887.
**) A contribution to the anthropology of the Jews.
*) Hist. V. 6.
**) Stuttgart, Vienna 1894.