12
VI.
Thus have Ury's great works appeared to me.
But he has plans also, world-wide, matured plans. One of them he has confided to me, which I will here only indicate. He means to paint a "Moses."
Michelangelo has shaped the Moses as he stands over against a dull and undifferentiated resistance of the mass. He sees the base doings of the multitude; he would force them down, but he holds himself in. Herman Grimm has before him the feeling "as though the thunders of heaven stood at this man's command, but he were mastering himself before he unleashed them"; and Conrad Ferdinand Meyer has the characteristic words:
"Thou graspest with sinewy hand thy beard, Yet dost thou not, O Moses, spring up."
Ury means to represent the moment after this one: the Moses who springs up, in order to throw at the rigid and corrupted people — that generation grown up in slavery, which may hear the words upon Sinai but shall never behold the land of fulfilment, appointed to die in the wilderness — the first and holiest tables of the Law, "at their heads," as Ury says — as Ury says in a voice in which his wrath and his love tremble.
VII.
Wherein is Ury a Jewish artist?
First of all in his manner of painting, as a colourist. I do not mean by this merely his predilection for sparkling colours drunken with light — colours which he does not arrange for himself by the choice of his material, but rather fetches for himself out of nature with his gifted eye — a predilection which has been interpreted as an Oriental influence. (Thus Franz Servaes says once of Ury's works: "It is again and again the Hallelujah of colour, which swells toward us like a roaring psalm of praise. And one stands spellbound, overwhelmed, drunken before this Old Testament weight of the coloristic vision: Jehovah lives in these flame-colours!") More than this I mean the fact of the extreme colourism itself, in the form in which Ury exhibits it. This colourism seeks to give not the outlines of things, but their nuance, as it arises out of the working of light and air. The stress is laid upon the fine interaction of beings and forces, not upon their outward stepping-forth; yet the softening of the outward boundary (if one may here speak of "softening," where nothing is present but the rendering of what is naturally seen) happens, as we have seen in the "Jeremiah," only in favour of a more inward individualisation. Now this manner of seeing the world is genuinely Jewish. One may convince oneself of it if one makes trial of the Jewish and, for example, the Germanic memory for pictures, or if one compares the descriptions in the old Jewish writings with those in the old Greek. Everywhere among us there prevails a mode of apprehension which is more of the surface, which proceeds from a total mood, and which is directed rather upon the relations of things than upon their forms. By this conception the possibility of a Jewish plastic art is of course not called in question. Yet I believe that it will develop chiefly from the relief, even as Jewish sculptors, with those of their works which stand nearest to the form of the relief (I need only recall Nossig's mask of King Solomon), attain the finest, the most intimate, the — so to speak — most Jewish effects.
Next, Ury is a Jewish artist as a revolutionary, that is to say, as one from whom movement, transforming movement, proceeds. This he is already by the fact that he hastened on ahead of the collective development of art and found, out of himself, first the radical impressionism and then the modern painterly monumental style. He has not merely divined and prepared the new, as the Jews have done at all times, but has also known how to give it shape. But he is above all a revolutionary in his manner of creating, which is an eternal struggle, and from the standpoint of which he regards repose as the one and unpardonable sin — "To will is life, to be able is death," he holds — and that is a Jewish way. And he is a revolutionary in his pictures, in which again and again a living force rears itself up against the dull powers of destiny and seeks a redemption. As such a revolutionary, however, does the Jewish spirit of the race go through the ages. At the beginning of its history of mankind it has set a rebellion; and though it branded that rebellion, yet the whole rich beauty of human life as we know it is founded thereupon. In the Palestinian epoch this revolutionary tendency shows itself in personal shapings, of which the most fully developed is Job, and in the zeal of the prophets against the will of the people. In the Diaspora this poetically national revolution is narrowed and turned aside into the paths of a morbid Messianism; beside it and out beyond it the fundamental movement develops into an urge toward the redemption of mankind. We live in the transition to a third age, concerning whose revolutionary element precisely he who hopes most richly must keep the most bashful silence. All the phases, however, have found unconscious and intimating expression in Ury's works.
And Ury is a Jewish artist as the poet of the Jewish soul. Apart from everything literary, given over solely to the creation of values of colour, he has nevertheless painted the poems of the Jewish sorrow and of the Jewish longing. He has given the lyric of the new Jew of to-day, who is wroth with his people because he loves it. I hope for things of the morrow from him yet. But to-day let us greet him thankfully as that which he is: Lesser Ury, the master of the sunniest colours, the bringer of movement, the poet of our wrath and of our love.
New Spring.
Hearest thou the song of the storm? It sounds so good And goes about the earth like a wild awaking; Now needest thou to weep no more, Ruth — For it will be spring, it will be spring!
Even as once before it grew to shining spring After the night and the darknesses of long bondage: That was a spring of a wholly peculiar kind, Of which the legends know things of wonder.
That was a man of a wholly peculiar stamp, Who arose to us amid the storms of spring, Who, himself full of light and storm, a day of spring, Set free his people from the bonds of alien serfdom.
Who freed it, led it, and did not rest Until he showed it its homeland upon the earth — Now needest thou to weep no more, Ruth, For once again it will be spring, it will be spring.
Berlin. Martin Friedlaender.
The Utopian.
A Passover Phantasy by Dr. Ph. Menczel.
I am a Utopian. It has been said to me so often that in the end I must believe it. They were clever people who called it out to me in public assemblies and who said it to me in private conversation with a superior, an almost pitying smile. It must therefore be true. In truth, jesting apart. I believe it: I am a Utopian.
I am a Utopian, and must now bestir myself to bring the calling I have chosen into honour. And why not? Joiners, tailors, shoemakers, locksmiths, chimney-sweeps and knackers belong to their guilds, hold their banners high and keep watch over the honour of their estate. Why should we Utopians not likewise set some store by our calling? I say: we Utopians; for at the Congresses in Basle and London, and but lately at the Austrian Zionist Conference at Olmütz, I could perceive with pleasure that I am no hermit, and that the guild of the Utopians numbers a goodly array of members. And more than that. One who is conscious of his estate does not stop short at the present. Where, first of all, is the tradition, the hallowed tradition? Out with the historical examples! Moses, the teacher and creator of our people, was a Utopian. The impudence! So I hear the cry again: Now the man will even set himself in a line with the founder of our sublime religion, with the creator of monotheism. But I am, once for all, so immodest. The greatest of our people must serve for the comparison, and I find therein something far more elevating and at the same time far less pretentious than if I were, say, to venture to compare myself with the eloquent Dr. Güdemann, the Chief Rabbi of Vienna. For Moses is called plainly "Mausche Rabbenu" and not "Mausche Oberrabbenu." He had no golden collar, wore no gown, and did not preach in the Seitenstetten Temple. What was Moses? Nothing more than a Zionist — I would say: a Utopian, an enthusiast for Zion, who led the Jewish people away from the full flesh-pots of Egypt and went with it toward Canaan. The Utopian! How often had he to hear it from the mouths of the clever men of that day! Had Dr. Güdemann lived in those days, into what fine periods would he have cast his glittering mockery,