Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 12 · 22 March 1901
6printed page
scan 6 of 16
Facsimile · scan 6 of 16
Scan of p. 6
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 12.

The fear of a demagogic exploitation is rendered groundless by the very slightness of the change, and it would be to sin against the capacity of judgment and against the good Jewish sentiment of precisely these broad Jewish strata of the people were one not to credit them with honouring three men with their confidence who in every direction — save perhaps a well-filled pocket — might redound to the honour of Jewry. If somebody in the Board must needs make a brawl, he need not for that belong precisely to this stratum. I must give expression to my lively regret that the opportunity for altering the composition of the Board in conformity with my proposal was not seized. I add further that the circles for which I have entered the lists do also contribute indirectly to the needs of the Community by the payment of fees for documents, for marriage and burial charges, and so forth, and need not on that account be taxpayers at all; that there are countless officials, smaller tradesmen, teachers and the like, who all fall into this group; and that a facultative 5 fl. tax is not paid, just as taxes in general are hardly paid voluntarily by the mass, and that the facultative 5 fl. tax therefore signified no extension of the franchise.

When I report further that by an urgency motion I have contributed to bringing the treatment of the question of Jewish nurses to the point of actuality, and that in the social-political field at least something will be effected, I have for the present nothing more significant to communicate to my friends, unless it be the report of the proposal of an endowment whose interest is henceforth to be employed for gymnasium pupils who devote themselves to Hebrew studies. If I have perhaps not shaped the motions cited above as they were actually intended by me, or if in their present form they do not correspond to all the wishes and purposes of the various persons interested, I must in explanation point out that with these motions only a groping step was in fact made by me in the direction which I am minded to take. I wished by this "Ballon d'essai" to discover the quarter from which the wind would blow against such opinions. In no case will the question of the composition of the Board vanish from the order of the day, and motions relating thereto will always be brought in by me afresh.

From the Public Plenary Meeting of the Community Board

of the 17th of March, 1901.

An Oratorical Achievement of Herr v. Taussig.

On Sunday the 17th inst. the Board of the Vienna Israelitish Community held a public sitting. Upon the order of the day stood the alteration of the community statute. A commission, namely, had been appointed which had to deliberate upon an amendment of the community ordinances in the sense of a simplification of the conduct of business of the Community Board. This commission had appointed Oberfinanzrath Rapaport as its reporter before the Community Board. Herr Rapaport now rendered his report upon the proposals of the commission.

In the special debate which followed this report, the newly elected member of the Community Board, Herr Eltbogen, seized the opportunity of reverting to the famous electoral reform which, even within the bosom of the Community Board, is publicly approved only by those gentlemen who whipped it through, and at most, besides, by the twelve privilege-councillors who owe to it their seat and voice on the Board. Herr Eltbogen now moved, since the alteration of the statute stood for once upon the order of the day, that § 5 (24 members are to be elected by the totality of those entitled to vote and twelve by the highest taxpayers) be so amended that the new curia of the highest taxpayers be abolished, and that the twelve members by which the Board has been increased through the new electoral reform be likewise elected by the totality of the taxpayers.

It was to be foreseen that this motion would meet with general resistance. The whole of public Jewish opinion had unanimously condemned the creation of the curia of the privileged; but what do the plutocrats on the Board care for public Jewish opinion! Pangs of conscience are, according to Nietzsche, indecent; and our Kahal potentates are, where it is a question of curtailing the rights of the people and of extending the sphere of power of the members of their own estate and clique, adherents of the Aryan master-morality...

Since, then, the Eltbogen motion had no prospect of carrying, our fellow Zionist, Community Councillor Isidor Gewitsch, brought in the assuredly very tame compromise motion that the curia of the highest taxpayers be retained, but should send only nine members into the Community Board, while three members should be elected by a curia to be newly created, which should embrace all Jews of Vienna of full age and full legal right (thus also those who pay no community tax). In the event that the majority should not agree to a diminution of the mandates from the curia of the highest taxpayers, Herr Gewitsch put forward the alternative motion that the number of mandates from the general electoral curia be reduced to 21 and that the newly to be created curia of the untaxed be granted the right of electing six members of the Community Board. The speaker pointed out that those Jews also who pay no community tax help to bear indirectly the burdens of the Community, and that it was a commandment of justice to let the people, whose children, for example, the Community has instructed in the Jewish religion and into whose circle of interests it otherwise intervenes in manifold ways, have a little word to say in community affairs.

One might now have expected that the gentlemen of the Board, or at any rate some among them, would at least theoretically acknowledge the justification of this proposal — which is really evident to every fair-minded person — and would prepare an honourable burial for the Gewitsch motion. It would indeed have sounded quite plausible had one of the gentlemen risen and said: We have now had a report laid before us upon the proposals of the Statute-Amendment Commission with regard to a reform of the administration. Let us then keep to this subject and let § 5 rest for the present. Upon the motion of our colleague Gewitsch, which is indeed quite debatable, we can deliberate upon another and more suitable occasion. Had the gentlemen passed over the motions of Eltbogen and Gewitsch in this manner, decency at least would have been preserved.

Instead of this, one of the twelve elect of the highest taxpayers, Herr R. v. Taussig, delivered a speech which, to put it mildly, was offensive and provoking.

Herr v. Taussig said approximately the following: Colleague Eltbogen has appealed to the religious tradition of Jewry and to the principles of brotherhood. For us, however, catchwords (!) cannot be decisive, but solely and alone the interest of the Community. It is altogether not in place to speak of brotherhood, in view of the circumstance that in the recent electoral campaign the deserving men of the Community Board were attacked in the most hostile fashion. There exists far less brotherhood from below upwards than from above downwards. The speaker is in favour of a representation of all groups of interest upon the Community Board. But were he placed before the dilemma of giving a representation upon the Community Board either only to the materially independent or only to the materially dependent elements, he would decide for the former eventuality as the lesser evil. For the strata materially less favourably situated are accessible to all manner of agitations, in part of the best intention, but in part malicious, as the recent elections have shown. If, then, all 36 community councillors were elected by the general curia, there would be the danger that people would penetrate into the Community Board who chase after fantastic aims, after a fata morgana, and that would be an irreparable injury to the interests of the Community.

Of such elements one cannot say that they offer a guarantee for the fitting representation of the Community's interests within and without. Rather does it lie in the interest of the totality that the economically independent circles be drawn in, and this consideration was decisive for the creation of the curia of the highest taxpayers. If the objection be raised that the materially highly placed might indeed be candidates in the general curia, the speaker must say that his fellows in station have no inclination for that. They wish to be elected by the people with whom a common interest binds them, with whom they stand in constant contact and from whom they can receive suggestions. If they are not in a position, by their