Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 10 · 8 March 1901
3printed page
scan 3 of 16

No. 10. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3.


(continued from page 2)

…could not feel themselves secure if they left the country. In this emigration-protection on the part of the Ica gross mischief also occurred. Otherwise we cannot designate it. And here it is the workmen's representation which bears the whole blame. The agency in Jaffa took into consideration only the demands of such people as brought with them a card of recommendation from the Workmen's Committee. Cases are known in which this committee caused cards to reach people who were no workmen at all, or had worked somewhere only for a very short time, 3 to 6 months. Thus the responsibility for a loss of considerable moneys falls back also upon the workmen themselves.

The workmen's representation bore itself altogether very questionably in this affair. It spurred the workmen to departure, in that it not only would not maintain in the workmen the hopes of a colonisation possible in the future (an attitude which one might still approve), but simply destroyed this hope. The representation also championed the standpoint of the expatriation of the workmen at Paris, on the occasion of the granting of the 60,000 frcs. by the Ica.

The whole business of so lavish a distribution of money made also upon the townspeople a painful impression — that of a suddenly awakened, wretched impulse to schnorring. Men sought some pretext or other in order to get upon the workmen's lists. Sometimes, as we have said, it also succeeded.

We think that the question could have been solved much more simply, and can even now be so solved. There still remains a great part of the workmen who have not yet departed, and after the close of the winter season further dismissals of workmen are to be expected in Zichron-Jacob. In the first place, one should not seek to satisfy all the workmen without regard to whether they were dismissed or not. One might think that the Ica were as it were seeking to excuse itself for the hopes formerly nourished by it in the workmen, and were providing all without distinction with the opportunity of travel. Only those workmen who were in fact dismissed should receive a compensation, and do with this amount what they please. Definite norms would have to be fixed, according to which the amounts of compensation should be paid out to the various workmen in proportion to the duration of the time spent in the colonies, to the size of the family, and to the quality of the workman. As a maximum limit there might perhaps be set the day's wage for half a year, or possibly for a whole year.

To the people left at their work also the assurance would have to be given that they likewise, upon an eventual dismissal, will receive a corresponding compensation reckoned according to the same norms. Sometimes the workmen not yet dismissed believe that they must leave their work voluntarily, since they were of the opinion that no money would be given them later, that this was now a passing measure, that after the granted sum is consumed no further money will remain for them. Such a compensation will doubtless be generally regarded as completely satisfactory. The highest principle must be: to drive no Jewish workmen out of the country. If one will go away, let him do it upon his own initiative.

We have dwelt somewhat too long upon the description of the present conditions, since we hold it to be very important to set forth the whole state of the case in the most correct manner possible. So much is spoken and written about the labour question which does not correspond with the facts, that we hold it our duty to clear up the affair in its details. (Conclusion follows.)


The General Meeting of the Russian

"Chowewe Zion."

Odessa, 1st March 1901.

The day before yesterday the general meeting of the "Committee for the Support of Jewish Agriculturists and Handicraftsmen in Palestine" was opened here with an imposing attendance. The chair was taken by our excellent fellow-Zionist Dr. Tschlenow of Moscow, member of the Zionist Actions Committee. In his opening speech he set forth that the general meeting had for its purpose to deliberate upon the present state of the Palestinian colonisation in general, but in particular upon the situation of the agricultural day-labourers; to draft a suitable programme for the future; to elect a new managing committee in Jaffa; and further to come to a conclusion upon various questions of detail. Before the presidency lay two reports: one in which the Palestinian colonists, and the other in which the Palestinian workmen, report upon their situation. These two reports had, upon their arrival, been referred by the committee to a special commission. There would now be read out the two reports and the proposals of the special commission thereupon, which the committee has approved.

Thereupon Mr. A. Drujanow read out the report of the workmen, in which they describe their situation and raise objection to the project of helping them by the founding of industries, and that upon the following grounds:

  1. Domestic industry could serve the independent agriculturist only as a subsidiary source of earning, but could not be contemplated as an exclusive branch of livelihood for numerous families;

  2. the workmen had already accustomed themselves to agriculture, whereas all industrial labour was strange to them. They could not all at once take up a new calling after they had for years grown into husbandry:

  3. the prospects for industries in Palestine were uncertain, and the workmen would, should success fail to appear, come again into a precarious position.

The workmen then report that the Ica had originally held out to them the prospect of making them independent peasants, and that the official of the Ica, Mr. Haim, was already about purchasing lands for them; suddenly the direction of the Ica had bethought itself otherwise and cancelled the purchases. Even Sedjerah, which the Ica retained, it destined for the founding of a farm, so that the hope of the workmen of at last becoming independent after all was wholly brought to nothing.

The report expatiates further upon the accomplished founding of a "General Workmen's Committee" and upon the journey of the workmen's deputation to Paris. The results of this journey were: the promise of Baron Edmund v. Rothschild to take part in an eventual settlement of the workmen, in case their number should not be all too great, and the promise of the Ica, for its part, to contribute the twofold or threefold of any amount whatsoever which any other society should give for the workmen.

From the conversations with Baron Rothschild and the members of the board of the Ica the workmen have gained the conviction that two reasons withhold the Ica from complying with the wishes of the workmen. On the one hand, the number of the workmen is very great, and it is at present impossible to assign land and soil to all for independent cultivation. On the other hand, it is impossible to acquire new plots of ground in Palestine. These two reasons