Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 10 · 8 March 1901
2printed page
scan 2 of 16
Facsimile · scan 2 of 16
Scan of p. 2
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 2. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 10.

(continued from page 1)

…plans. The question has become a burning one, but it has for the present not yet come out of the phase of the pourparlers; to the deed men have not yet proceeded.

Quite otherwise is it with the Palestinian labour question. Here we stand before accomplished facts. It is of importance first to discuss the question whether, and how far, the Ica had here to do with a new problem. All Zionists know well enough that a labour question has long existed in Palestine, since the time when men left off making the great plantings and there began to be a lack of opportunity of work for many workmen. Men occupied themselves extraordinarily much with this matter; they went also to the practical solution of the question, in that the founding of two labour colonies had been undertaken — Kastinié by the united Russian and West-European "Chowewe Zion", and "Metullah" by Baron v. Rothschild. The former took in more than 20 families and is already not far from affording the people a secure existence; the second numbers 58 colonists, but increases the number of the unsecured Rothschild colonies, inasmuch as in it also the many faults were committed which marked the former Administration.

Since the taking over of the Rothschild colonies by the Ica we saw ourselves suddenly before a mighty labour current, which swelled ever more. It was now the duty of the representatives of the Ica to let this torrent of discontent flow off, in that they should have cleared the obstacles out of its way. Meanwhile — what do we see? Let the facts speak. The Administration of the Ica saw itself compelled, in consequence of the stopping of new plantations in Zichron-Jacob and of the diminution of work in the cellars of Rischon-le-Zion and Zichron-Jacob, to dismiss several workmen. It does not happen for the first time in Palestine that the hardly earned bread must be taken from workmen for lack of opportunity of work. So it was after the conclusion of the great planting works of Menucha-wenachlah in Rechoboth, of Gan-Schemuel in Chederah. The people went in part into the towns, especially the native Spaniolen, who always furnished a very great contingent of the labouring class; in part employment was found elsewhere also. Only very few took to the wanderer's staff. The employers could personally, unhappily, do all too little to better the fate of the dismissed workmen. The generality of the Zionists, however, sought after various means and ways of securing their position for the time to come, in that a workmen's fund had for a long time been formed for them. Men did not give themselves over to the illusion of being able with insufficient means to reach the goal quickly. But they promised themselves to be able in time to obtain from the Ica a considerable sum for the colonisation of the best workmen dwelling in Palestine. And much spoke for it that this hope would go into fulfilment. At one blow, however, the state of things altered. The Ica undertook the setting in order of the Rothschild colonies, and the official of the society sent out to Palestine in the past year announced that the Ica was not willing to undertake anything new in Palestine before the existing colonies were placed upon firm foundations. We will here leave out of account whether the Ica did rightly in taking this resolution. But after the hopes of the workmen of being at last colonised had already for a considerable time been nourished by the circumstances above mentioned, we must say that this enunciation of the Ica, in the manner in which it was made known, drew after it appalling consequences.

The workmen sent a delegation to Paris, which after long knocking at various doors was at last received by the board of administration of the Ica. It was at first promised to give a sum of 60,000 francs for the dismissed workmen, so that the possibility should be given them either to leave the country or to create for themselves with the money received an existence in the country itself. An order of similar tenor came also to the agency of the Ica in Jaffa. Nothing indeed can be said against this measure. But in consequence of the bureaucratic formalism which reigns both in the society at Paris and among its representatives in Palestine, it has borne quite other fruits. The gentlemen did not take pains to ascertain through his employer the situation of each single workman, but wished to settle the question with general instructions. It was commanded from Paris to give not more than 50 francs per person for the whole number of the members of the workman's family, without taking into consideration how long the workman had been employed and what his capacity is. Since the workmen at once showed themselves discontented with this interpretation of the order concerning the 60,000 francs, and made further demands, the gentlemen resolved to give the workmen the passage money to — Australia and America, and strictly the passage money only. Men spoke no longer of the possibility that the people should find their maintenance in the country with the money received. They gave exclusively steamer tickets for the journey to Australia etc., and indeed very considerable amounts. Sometimes as much as 2000 francs per family was paid out to workmen for steamer tickets. The journey to Australia or America is indeed very costly; and if the workman in question expressed the express wish to create for himself an existence in the country with the same sum, nay even with a smaller one, he was placed before the alternative either of taking the steamer tickets or of going away empty. With Jewish money the steamship companies have been enriched, and to this day men are by no means at the end. Already 60,000 francs have been expended, which served for the departure of about 70 workmen's families, and about 10,000 frcs. more, and probably yet more, are likely to become necessary in order to despatch the people who have given in their names. Besides this, 22 cellar-workmen of Rischon-Lezion, after a four weeks' strike, in consequence of which the cellars of Rischon were closed, stipulated for a sum of 20,000 frcs., and that unconditionally; that is to say, it remained free to them to leave the country or to remain in it. Had then really so many workmen been deprived of their work? By no means! For the present it was mostly the unmarried people who were dismissed. To the heads of families the work was left almost throughout. But the ease with which the money for departure, and only for departure, was distributed attracted very many workmen from whom it was not desired to take the work. Precisely the ablest, the most enterprising said to themselves that no such brilliant opportunity would occur in the future, of obtaining the whole passage money for themselves together with their families to Australia or America. Instances are known in which young, capable workmen who had earned 3—5 frcs. daily in the cellars received the passage money, and that with the declaration that, so long as they were still young and had no large families, it would be easy for them to emigrate to another country; in Palestine they were not sure whether after three months they might not be dismissed, and in general it was indeed made known to them that they can have no future here. Here, then, we have to record a real and very deplorable loss of good working forces, with which much might have been begun in the future. There remained behind for the most part the weaker and the timid elements, who