Page 8 — "Die Welt" — No. 7
(continued from page 7)
...views than we have. (Quite right! on the Left.) In the Upper House an interpellation upon the question of ritual murder was to have been brought in by Herr Herzberg and his associates. But they were afraid of the disgrace and prevented the bringing in of the interpellation. (Commotion.) The Konitz occurrences present a shocking picture of mediaeval backwardness. "Ritual murder" is indeed being let drop; people speak of "blood murder" and the like — it is only another signboard, the thing is the same. The so-called Jewish Confusion Committee does not exist in Konitz; but anti-Semitic machinations have taken place which have led to confusion. Anti-Semitic comic papers and picture-sheets have carried excitement into the circles of that population. Deputy Crüger has rightly spoken of the Boxer standpoint. The anti-Semites simply wish to treat the Jews as foreigners; that is the Boxer standpoint. I recall the incendiary speeches of Count Pückler. The finding of the court did indeed declare Count Pückler to be a man not to be taken seriously. I grant that in Berlin people are clear about this man. But things go further, and where the man is not known such speeches must work in the highest degree inflammatorily. Before the threshold of the chambers where justice is administered, party passion ought to halt! (Ironical Quite right! on the Right.) If it does not, the sense of right in the people is undermined. That is fraught with fate. Justitia est fundamentum regnorum. (Lively applause on the Left; laughter on the Right.)
Motion of Dr. Barth.
In the meantime a motion of Dr. Barth (fr. Vg.) has come in: The House of Deputies is pleased to resolve to express the expectation that in the appointment of notaries the collective interest of the population shall be given effect in accordance with the provisions of Articles 4 and 12 of the Charter of the Constitution.
Deputy Dr. Irmer: How those gentlemen proceed is shown by the case of a Berlin town councillor who, because it became known that he was a Catholic and an Ultramontane, was removed from all offices of trust. (Hear, hear! on the Right. Cries on the Left: Name him!) If you must absolutely have objects, then regard me as such a pathological object, one who as a town councillor was systematically kept away from all important offices by the Berlin municipal representation on account of his convictions! (Hear! on the Right.) I could name you (turning to the Left) several more, but I refrain out of forbearance. (Laughter on the Right. Cry on the Left: I thought religion was the subject of discussion! Deputy von Pappenheim: Order! Laughter.) With our motion we wish to create clearness. The question of Deputy von Eynern, what then the principles were that we desired, has moved me to have express regard in our motion "to the need of the Christian population". We know that large sections of the Radical gentlemen do not share the views here represented. (Where then? on the Left.) We have not moved for a division by name, in order not to bring you (turning to the Left) into embarrassment. (Laughter on the Right.) But if you wish it, we have nothing against a division by name. (Applause on the Right.)
Deputy Schmitz (Düsseldorf, Ctr.): In the "Frankfurter Zeitung" the reproach of a violation of the constitution was made against the Hessian Government, because in the Grand Duchy of Hesse there is no Jewish judge and no Jewish notary. To the gentlemen of the Left also I can only say: O si tacuisses! You have rendered your friends, the Jews, a bad service: by the way recommended by Deputy Barth there would in many large towns, within a measurable time, be none but Jewish notaries; the Christian element would be got rid of. That we cannot hold to be a desirable state of things. It would call forth a counter-movement and lead to an anti-Semitism which we all in this high House abhor. In order not to be misunderstood, I declare that I personally have worked together with thoroughly capable Jewish colleagues at my district court. But I could name you towns where the appointment of a Jewish judge has been answered with an open protest of the population. If that is how the matter stands, then the administration of justice would not be doing its duty if it took no account of such conditions. To such a judge, and to a notary as well, the exercise of his office would be made difficult on many sides. The interests of the individual judge must in these cases give way to those of the community. The welfare of the community is further endangered by the fact that there does after all exist a considerable difference between the Jewish and the Christian view of the world. The press, moreover, at once makes a cause célèbre of matters that concern the Jews, while upon a like occasion it pecks at other confessions. I need only recall how, in the case of Sister Carola, the whole Jewish press fell upon us. (Quite right!) The grave reproach of a violation of the constitution deserves an expiation, and we shall therefore vote for the Conservative motion. (Applause.)
President von Kröcher: An amendment of Deputies Dr. Irmer and Baron von Zedlitz to the motion of Barth has come in, to insert after the word "notaries" the words "as hitherto", so that the motion now reads: . . . to express the expectation that in appointment to notaryships, as hitherto, the collective interest of the population shall be given effect. (Laughter.)
On a point of order there remarked
Deputy Dr. Barth (fr. Vg.): The amendment turns the sense of our motion into its opposite. That is therefore no amendment, but a counter-motion, upon which there ought to be a separate deliberation. If Baron von Zedlitz desires a motion of that sense, he may surely bring it forward himself. (Laughter.)
President von Kröcher: Under the rules of procedure the amendment is in all circumstances admissible.
Deputy Dr. Barth (fr. Vg.): We shall of course vote against the Irmer–Baron von Zedlitz amendment, and, should it be adopted, against the motion thus turned into its opposite. (Laughter on the Right.)
President von Kröcher: The heading "Minister's Salary" is adopted.
The Irmer–Zedlitz amendment is adopted by the votes of the Right, the Centre, the Poles and a part of the National Liberals; and likewise, by the same majority and amid stormy laughter, the motion of the Radical Barth thus turned into its opposite.
The Conservative main motion is adopted against the votes of the two Radical parties.
*
The debate upon the principles according to which Prussia proceeds in the appointment of Jewish judges and in the nomination of Jewish advocates to notaryships has thus found its conclusion in the adoption of a vote of confidence in the Minister of Justice — and, indeed, of a double vote of confidence. The principle is approved that in the appointment of notaries the need of the Christian population shall be taken into account in suitable measure. And further, it has been certified to the Minister that in the appointment of notaries he has safeguarded the collective interest of the population and has acted in agreement with Articles 4 and 12 of the constitution.
*
A Protest Meeting against Minister Schönstedt in Berlin.
(Orig.-Corr.)
A protest meeting of Jewish citizens of Berlin was held on Sunday in the large hall of the Victoria Brewery. Upon the agenda stood a protest demonstration against the utterances of the Minister of Justice, Schönstedt. Town Councillor Louis Sachs presided. The first speaker was Town Councillor Dr. Nathan, who set forth that in the Minister's declarations it was a question not merely of the appointment of the notaries, but of a great question of principle, of the position of the Jews in the administration of the State. "Nothing is further from the Jews," he said among other things, "than to touch the rights of the Crown; they demand merely that the fine word which the Emperor is said to have spoken to Director Ballin with regard to his faith — 'Creed is a matter of indifference to me' — shall become a principle for the administration of the State." After him spoke Town Councillor and Councillor of Justice Cassel.
The chairman, Town Councillor Sachs, thereupon read out, addressed to the President of the State Ministry, the
