Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 7 · 15 February 1901
7printed page
scan 7 of 16

No. 7 — "Die Welt" — Page 7

(continued from page 6)

...stricted numbers or not be admitted at all — that has now become a doctrine of constitutional law. Although a practice corresponding to this theory has been followed hitherto as well, the German Jews of assimilation have nevertheless allowed themselves too often to be deceived by the fiction. Now they stand face to face with the brutal unambiguousness of the facts. The future will teach what consequences they will draw from the given circumstances. Reserving to ourselves a further and detailed discussion of the subject, we let there follow below a report of the proceedings of the Prussian Chamber of Deputies:

Deputy Richter: The anti-Semites fall into three groups: the anti-Semites for sport — those are the Junkers —, the business anti-Semites and the rowdy anti-Semites! In Konitz it is the business and the rowdy anti-Semites. But they are still protected. I am glad that Minister Schönstedt has declared that he is no anti-Semite. Will it help? Prince Bismarck, too, only remembered his Jewish business friend Behrend when he made a fiasco of his commercial policy. The authorities here behave towards the anti-Semites as the mandarins did towards the Boxers. I should have wished that the Centre, which otherwise professes to protect parity everywhere, had here also come forward as the protector of parity. When it is a question of the complaints of Catholic fellow-citizens, then you are all fire and flame. In the case of the Jews you hold the conditions here laid before you to be an ideal state of things. No, gentlemen, the sentiments of the administrative official in charge must accord with the system that is at the helm; the officials must be chosen with regard to that, and not according to confession. And what business have the notaries to transact? The notaries are persons of record; they have to attest in documentary form the declared will of two contracting parties, they have to protest bills of exchange, to record instruments of sale and to draw up wills. What is it, then, that moves the Jews to take up this calling? Most of the other callings are closed to them! They were for a time forbidden to carry on anything but trade; then at most they might still become physicians. Scientific activity was in great part barred to them — at least its public and official exercise; the administrative offices are in the main closed to them, and so likewise the judicial offices. There remained to them only the practice of the law. Therefore they turned to it, and now you would take from them the possibility of becoming a notary! You say they may indeed become notaries; but it does make a very material difference whether one becomes a notary after 8 years or after 18. You are for ever meeting them with fresh barriers. We thought that the old barriers ought to be removed which hinder the amalgamation of Jewry with the population, and you are thereby strengthening the very qualities of the Jews that are disagreeable to you. You are strengthening Zionism, which I hold to be just as reprehensible as anti-Semitism. Otherwise the Government affects to be exalted above the moods of the people; here it gives way to backward views and popular passions. If, upon an unrestricted admission of Jewish advocates to the notariate, the Christian notaries really disappear — what a confession of poverty that would be for the Christian advocates! Assuredly, do you know any other explanation for such an utterance than the fear that the Christian advocates could not stand the Jewish competition? Constitution and laws exist for the protection of minorities. And when I studied law, we were taught that in the first instance the letter of the constitution must be decisive. And the King, too, has to exercise his rights of appointing officials within the framework of the constitutional prescriptions. Yes, indeed, he may not go beyond them. For these provisions concerning the qualification of citizens for the offices of State and their equality of rights do not stand in the section which treats of the rights of the authorities and of the monarch, but in the section which treats of the rights of Prussians. The Minister of Justice appealed to the acts of the presidents of the higher provincial courts and of his predecessors in office. His predecessors have not uttered views of that kind here; the presidents of the higher provincial courts, however, may not decide upon principles at all, but only upon individual cases; the principles of appointment the Minister of Justice alone has to lay down. Thus it has also happened more than once that, against the wish of the head of the higher provincial court, Jewish advocates have not been made notaries, and so forth. The Minister has sought cover in the other departments; he thought our attack had come unexpectedly. That is not the case, for Herr Peltasohn had caused his intention to be communicated beforehand. But the Ministers are unlucky; they run off the rails at every moment now. The other day this happened to Herr Brefeld, when he spoke of the necessary evil of the coal dealers; now it is the Minister of Justice, who, precisely in such programmatic declarations, ought from the outset to be very exact. (Quite right! on the Left.) He sought to give the matter a humorous turn; that is here little in place. It is also peculiar that he does not know how so important a question is dealt with in other departments. Herr von Bülow appealed to the practice in Mecklenburg. That is the classic land of intolerance. Until 1848 a Jew could not even acquire landed property there. It was precisely with regard to these conditions that the Jew Law was enacted in 1869. (Cry on the Right: Unfortunately!) Unfortunately? In the year 1869 the whole of the Conservatives were in favour of it. I esteem Christianity very highly, in relation to other confessions and as a factor of civilisation particularly highly; but in my opinion those esteem it less highly who maintain the opinion that a State which has 98 per cent. of Christians in its population cannot after all endure equality of rights with the one or two per cent. of those of another faith. If equal duties are imposed, equal rights must also be granted.

Minister of Justice Schönstedt: Deputy Richter has treated me with a measure of friendliness such as is customary at first greetings. (Laughter.) The greater number of his utterances gives me no occasion for a reply, since they do not directly touch my department. The attack of Deputy Peltasohn did not take me unexpectedly, for his intention was indeed communicated to me before he took the floor. In the main, Deputy Richter now maintains that we have here to do with a violation of the constitution. We have discussed very fully what the constitution says, and have not come to an agreement upon it. If one follows the arguments of Deputies Dr. Barth and Richter, we arrive after all, in a certain sense, at a somewhat mechanical interpretation, in which fidelity to the constitution is, as it were, measured with the yard-stick. In public life there are, after all, certain imponderabilia which no statesman may leave out of account (Quite right! on the Right and in the Centre), and which may not be disregarded by a politician either without danger. (Renewed applause.) These exist in this field also. Further occasion for a reply to the arguments of the previous speaker I do not believe myself to have. I shall await what is further brought forward. (Applause.)

Deputy Werner (Antis.): Deputy Crüger has compared us with bands of Boxers. (Quite right! on the Left.) Quite right, for we too stand upon national ground. The speech of the Minister of Justice pleased me. (Cry: Naturally!) At Rickert's speech, on the other hand, the old verse came into my mind: "Upon the roof there sits an ancient man who knows not how to help himself." The Jews have received rights enough through the constitution. They can become peasants. (Laughter on the Right.) Why will they not do so? They would rather become officers. From that may the good God preserve us! (Stormy laughter.)

Deputy Dr. Wiemer (fr. Vp.): We have taken the liberty of bringing in the motion: that in the appointment of notaries the interests of the population as a whole be taken into account in accordance with the constitution. In Breslau a Christian advocate has been appointed notary, although he stood four years behind a capable Jewish advocate in seniority of service, and although the chief president had recommended the latter. Against Deputy Werner I will not proceed with the same ordnance; we should otherwise descend to the level of an anti-Semitic rowdy meeting. (Quite right! on the Left.) Amid the applause of the Right, Werner sought to deny the Jews the qualification for military service. (Laughter on the Right.) In 1870/71 the Jews did their full devoir. At that time, from 132 places, 2531 Jews took part in the campaign, of whom 26 as officers (Laughter on the Right), as lieutenants, 26 as physicians and 188 as non-commissioned officers. All did their duty and their devoir. To that you are silent (turning to the Right. Laughter on the Right. Interruptions!) Of duty and devoir, of right and equity, you have, to be sure, other