No. 6 — "Die Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…decidedly answer: No, we are Jews no longer! Let us then look about us betimes for some other surrogate for our Judaism, for with that it is coming to an end sooner or later.
But be of good cheer! We are still Jews, and shall and will remain so unto the end of days. Legalism is not at all the foundation, the primal essence, the substance of Judaism, but nationality is. This legalism is but the outflow of the Jewish national spirit, and only through that spirit does it gain an unshakable foundation and an everlasting continuance; without nationality, however, Jewish legalism hovers in the air and is blown away and dissipated by every breath of modern enlightenment and of the progress of culture.
I can very well conceive a Judaism as pure nationality, wholly without legalism; mere legalism, on the other hand, without nationality as its bearer — a certain sanctity of works, a faith in the letter, a thoughtless practice of ceremonies — is no true Judaism. Always it runs: "Thou who hast chosen us from among all nations and hast given us Thy Thora"; at all times nationality is presupposed. The Jewish religion without the Jewish nation is a baseless sham-Judaism.
Even the belief in the One and Only is bound up with the existence of the Israelitish nation. "Hear, O Israel, the Eternal, our God, is the one and only God." "Israel is the fellow of God," teaches the Talmud in this sense. From this very fellowship the people draws its eternity, becomes that "Am-Olam," "People of Eternity," of whom the prophet speaks. "I, the Eternal, have not changed, and ye sons of Jacob have not ceased." I and ye.
Setting out from these presuppositions, modern Zionism may be regarded as positively liberating and redeeming and be greeted on every side; and both the Orthodox and the Neologues knew not what they did when they came forward so violently against it. The Orthodox not, for with all their strictness of law they are not in a position to counteract the corroding and dissolving power of modern progress in culture. The Neologues not, for the labours of corrosion and dissolution straight into the hands. What they there say of the "exalted mission" of Judaism among the peoples is the purest humbug. Of a Judaism as a nationality which confronts other nationalities self-consciously, worthily and vigorously, with all its definiteness and its destiny, something of the sort might at a pinch still be said, but not of a community of faith without faith.
Thus, then, has Zionism appeared upon the scene at the right time, to effect a regeneration of a Judaism fallen into grievous decay and tending towards dissolution — a regeneration in head and members. Zionism has awakened Judaism to self-recollection, not in respect of its consciousness of faith, but in respect of its consciousness of nationality. Israel had, as the prophet already laments, forgotten its nationality. It sought to adapt and to attach itself to foreign nationalities, and no one thought or suspected that thereby the faith and the confession too had been deprived of their sole support and foundation, and that the whole edifice, at which men had jointed and carpentered through thousands of years only to set it up right worthily and firmly, must sooner or later sink together.
Zionism, yes, Zionism has a great mission to fulfil, at first, to be sure, only for our own people. It seeks to join together again all the members of the nation, whether high or low, rich or poor, cultured or uncultured, orthodox or neolog, faithful to the Law or estranged from the Law, into one single great corporate body. It seeks to accomplish the great work of union, the work of Elias, and to turn back the heart of the fathers to their children and the heart of the children to their fathers, that all may be of one mind and learn to know and to feel themselves as children of one father. And last of all it seeks to create for the Jewish people, in the land of its fathers, a home secured by public law.
All this considered and surveyed, we arrive at the final result: We Zionists can answer the question "Are we still Jews?" with confidence: "Yes, we are still Jews! We therefore regard the one as well as the other, whoever he may be and to whatever tendency in respect of the legalism of faith he may belong; we regard every Jew whatsoever as one of our own, and reach him our hand for the bond of brotherhood."
The Jews in Roumania and in Germany.
As we lately reported, Prime Minister Carp declared to a Viennese interviewer that, in view of the anti-Semitic feelings of the Christian population, there could be no thought of granting the political rights to the Roumanian Jews. The Roumanian Prime Minister seems still to have preserved something of the so-called sense of shame before "Europe." He expresses himself only within four walls, almost shyly, and as though begging pardon for the Roumanian population that it is as it is and not yet otherwise. One feels almost pity for this young civilised people, whose Prime Minister has so great trouble in training it for a European state of law. How long will this young people require before it raises itself to the moral sense of right of the great civilised nations of Europe, of the "people of poets and thinkers," for example. The Roumanian Prime Minister might have learned much had he, upon his present European journey, devoted more intimate study to the arrangements of the Prussian judicial service. Perhaps he would have come to know things still more interesting than mortals of less exalted station learn now and again from the newspapers, which lately again had the following to report:
Berlin, 31st January. In the Prussian House of Deputies the setting-back of the Jews in the judicial service was brought up to-day, during the deliberation upon the budget of justice, by the Freisinnig deputy Peltasohn. The speaker showed that the Minister of Justice, in the appointment of notaries, makes a distinction between advocates of the Christian and of the Jewish religion, and that he no longer promotes Jewish judges at all.
The Minister of Justice, Dr. Schönstedt, answered the Liberal deputy and admitted that he did indeed restrict the number of Jewish notaries. That was no reproach against the Jewish jurists, of whose capacity, honourableness and trustworthiness he had no doubt. But he must have regard to the views of the population, which for the most part was not inclined to discuss matters of confidence with a Jewish notary.
The Freisinnige Dr. Barth expressed his astonishment at the Minister's answer. The Minister of Justice, said he, has taken up the position that in the appointment of notaries it is not the interests of the advocates who desired to be appointed notaries that are decisive, but, as he expressed it, the interest of the population. The principle that adherence to any confession whatsoever can furnish no ground for treating the citizen in question worse than the adherent of any other religion is one of the most important principles of our whole constitution of the State. (Quite right! from the Freisinnige.) If the Minister does not proceed by a strict interpretation of this principle, but says, I break through this principle in that I put what I hold to be the interest of the population in the place of the relevant provision
