No. 49 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
…was never personally present, and can therefore, from his own observation, have no judgment whatever as to whether even the accusations already published — let alone those which are first to be brought forward at the general meeting, and which he does not so much as know — are well founded. To be sure, as a member of the board of the "Alliance" he might have taken cognisance of the correspondence and the books, and thereby have gained sure grounds for judging one part of the activity of the accused members of the board. But Dr. Güdemann has with a light heart set himself above all scruples, and by his proceeding has declared himself in solidarity with the accused members of the board, and therefore jointly responsible with them. His last sermon accordingly characterises itself as the intervention of the Chief Rabbi Güdemann on behalf of the board member Güdemann. "Qui s'excuse, s'accuse," one is tempted to say. But that he appears in his own cause does not release him from his duties towards the truth. What is one to say to it that the Chief Rabbi, from the pulpit, brings the "Neue Freie Presse" into the field as a classic witness for the "Alliance"; that he invokes an inserted article, as to whose provenance no one versed in the matter can be in doubt, as an irrefutable witness for the board of the Alliance, an article which dissolves into nothing all accusations already published and still to be published in the future against any member of the board of the "Alliance." That signifies either a high degree of naïveté or an intended and conscious misleading of the hearers. But those who know the Chief Rabbi Güdemann do not hold him to be naïve.
The struggle which the board of the "Alliance" is now waging against the Zionists is not a struggle for the elucidation of the truth, but a struggle for its suppression. These gentlemen, and in the first place the Chief Rabbi, may let it be said to them that they can indeed, exactly as the members of the French General Staff did in the Dreyfus affair, set themselves against the advance of the truth with well-nigh superhuman exertion and with brutal force, but that the truth is nevertheless mightier than they. With Zola we too may say: "La vérité est en marche et rien ne l'arrêtera." We Zionists still form the minority in Vienna to-day, both in the representation of the community and among the members of the Alliance. But in the struggle which the board of the "Alliance" has forced upon us we shall conquer, however vanishing our minority in the general meeting may be, for we have the mightiest ally that there is — the truth. To the Chief Rabbi, however, we would say even to-day that the pulpit exists to proclaim the word of God, and not the word of Messrs. Dr. Alfred Stern, Dr. Kuranda or Dr. Katzau; and that nothing will hinder us, with all the reverence we pay to his office, from criticising the ethical qualities of his person. We would remind him even to-day that there exists an independent Jewish press which will throw light upon his doings without reserve, and that there exist Jewish popular assemblies which will not pass over his acts and omissions in silence.
Ivri.
The Statement of Account of the Vienna "Israelitic Alliance."
The board of the "Israelitic Alliance" has spoken at last. It has not, indeed, refuted the accusations brought forward in our paper; still less has it given us the opportunity of furnishing before a court the proof of truth repeatedly offered in our paper. Least of all has it hitherto made haste to convoke the extraordinary general meeting demanded, in order to hear the reproaches raised against it in a clear and sharply defined form and to rebut them with the aid of the documentary material at hand. This assuredly most effective manner of defence the board of the "Alliance" has hitherto shyly avoided. It has preferred to have printed a report upon its relief action for the Roumanian Jews thus far, to circulate this report in many thousands of copies, and to have it discussed not only in the Jewish subsidised press but in the daily papers as well. The board of the "Alliance" has reckoned shrewdly. It knows that there is an enormous number of people upon whom every printed word imposes, so that they venture not the slightest doubt, not a trace of criticism; it knows further that with uncritical people a suggestion cleaves the more deeply the oftener it is repeated, the louder the voice with which it is proclaimed, or the greater the mass of copies in which it is spread abroad; it knows further that there are still very many naïve minds among the Jews who picture the liberal daily papers to themselves as a sort of divinity hovering above mankind, as absolute wisdom and absolute truth, and who, in reading an article in these papers, never once reflect that it was written by a concrete human being who has flesh and blood like all the rest, is subject to the same errors as others, and to whom, just as to these, a greater or a lesser degree of confidence and of credibility is due. In its clever reckoning the board of the "Alliance" has overlooked one thing only, and that is that the mightiest thing in the world is the fact; that facts cannot be got rid of even by loud clamour; and that there are, after all, still some thinking men who will not be turned aside from the sober fact by the finest phrases, by the most sentimental turns of speech.
To-day we do not mean to pluck the whole report of the "Alliance" critically to pieces; we do not mean to analyse and illuminate it sentence by sentence, section by section. It is enough if we adduce a few samples, sufficient to lay bare the whole method upon which the report is fashioned, and thereby to illustrate its entire worth.
The report hurries over the events of May and of June in a few words and dwells longest upon the occurrences of July, when the waves of the emigration ran particularly high and the gentlemen of the "Alliance" came into straits. And yet it would be of the very greatest interest to learn what moved the board of the "Alliance," as early as the 29th of May, to address to the board of the Budapest community the demand that it should procure from the Hungarian Government the closing of the Roumanian frontier against the Jewish emigrants. One searches the report quite in vain for compelling grounds which would justify, or even so much as explain, this step. One searches just as vainly for a justification of the fact that the "Alliance," at the very time when, according to its own report, there was absolutely no question of a crush, let the Grünberg party encamp for three days and three nights under the Reichsbrücke without providing for their maintenance, so that Rabbi Reich of Baden and the head of the community there had first to intervene in favour of the poor emigrants.
The question also remains wholly and entirely unanswered why on the 26th of July the "Alliance" let the 642 emigrants who had arrived by the State Railway go hungry, although Dr. Katzau was awaiting them at the station, and sent them some provisions only towards four o'clock in the afternoon, after Dr. Gustav Kohn, member of the Provincial School Board, had been made aware of the scenes of misery by the pneumatic card of a Southern Railway engineer and had intervened. Willing as we are to believe that the finding of suitable rooms for lodging was difficult, the procuring of foodstuffs for 642 persons presents no difficulties in Vienna. One need only have the good will, and not set out "to wear the people down." It remains altogether unfathomable, too, why it was so utterly impossible, during the two days' stay, to pick out from these 642 the numerous young, vigorous, able-bodied people and to forward them further, the strike in Rotterdam being already at an end. That "the people were encamped in the open field" is surely no insurmountable obstacle; it was, after all, possible to sift those quartered upon the Danube barges, who were likewise in the open. Ah, if only there had been somewhat more good will and somewhat less helplessness! Touching is the helplessness which reveals itself in this, that because Rotterdam and Antwerp failed for the time being (by way of Hamburg the Alliance has never despatched anyone at all — this by way of correcting the report), the embarkation of the emigrants had to be dropped altogether. Let the gentlemen but inform themselves how many other ports stood at their command! Equally touching is the helplessness which comes to light in the care for the lodging of the emigrants staying in Vienna; that neither the Ministry of War nor the Ministry of Commerce would place rooms at the disposal of the "Alliance," the gentlemen might have foreseen with a little penetration; had they but sought — and for that there are advertisements, appeals, agents and much else besides — they would also have found; and we ourselves undertake to name to them a whole series of premises which would have stood at their disposal at the time of their greatest embarrassment.
