Die Welt · Vol. IV, No. 45 · 9 November 1900
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 45

(continued from page 3)

…that it is high time to approach the investigation of the soil and the industrial opening-up of Palestine." I rejoice that my train of ideas and that of the article in Number 43 of the "Welt" coincide completely. By calling I am a technical chemist, until lately proprietor and director of a chemical factory, at the moment confidential agent of one of the largest drug houses of Russia. I hereby announce my adhesion to the Zionist Society for the Technical Investigation of Palestine. With Zionist greeting

Respectfully B. Goldberg.


Once More the "Allianz".

Fifty members of the Israelitish Allianz in Vienna have addressed a petition to its board of management in which, upon the ground of the provision of the statutes, they demand the convocation of an extraordinary general meeting. The agenda for the general meeting, which the signatories of this petition at once append, leaves no doubt as to the motives of this step. "The treatment of the Roumanian emigrants by individual members of the board of the Allianz" — this wording lets it be plainly recognised that no blow whatever is intended against the "Allianz" as such; nay, that not even the whole board of the "Allianz" is to be made responsible for proceedings which are probably not even known to it. But things are to be brought to speech by eye- and ear-witnesses which are by no means indifferent for the honour of the Jewish people, for the opinion which the civilised nations form of us, and for the value which is to be attached to the relief organisations that exist within present-day Jewry. The readers of our paper are acquainted with a whole series of facts which it was our journalistic duty to lay before the public for judgment. We did not stand alone at all with our communications; other independent Jewish papers saw themselves moved to the same course. In our reports we did not enter at all upon details which came to our knowledge, but brought forward only the most flagrant facts, which were vouched for to us. Although several weeks have elapsed, the board of the "Allianz" has not even made the attempt to invalidate our communications, still less has it taken us at our word when we made ourselves ready to prove the truth of our statements before a court. The board of the "Allianz" has preferred to be silent, perhaps in the opinion that the excitement would subside again, that the interest in the Roumanian question would once more retire into the background, and that what had happened would at last sink into the sea of forgetfulness. Such a hope, however, is not likely to be fulfilled, at least in the immediate future. Wherever the tidings of the facts reported by us have penetrated, everywhere they have called forth agitation, and that not merely in Jewish, but also in Christian circles friendly disposed towards us. That anti-Semitic papers also took notice of our communications, nay, even reprinted them in part word for word, in order in their own fashion to make capital out of what had occurred and to forge accusations against Jewry as a whole — that we could not prevent. Nay, even if we had foreseen this, it ought not to have made us waver. It is a favourite catchword of the anti-Zionists that we Zionists play into the hands of the anti-Semites, that we are confederates of the anti-Semites; we have even been called "Jewish anti-Semites". That will never hinder us from openly bringing to speech the abuses which we discover within present-day Judaism, and, if need be, from doing away with them by shaking awake the public Jewish conscience. Neither will it ever keep us from publicly unmasking and setting in the pillory defective or bad characters who play an influential part in Jewish organisations and thereby injure the Jewish people as a whole. If, then, some gentlemen from the board of the Israelitish "Allianz" should believe that in the reference to the exploitation of our reports carried on by the anti-Semitic papers they possess a weapon against us, then they are mightily mistaken. The consciousness that love of our people guides us, that we set our whole strength upon the raising up and the liberation of our people, is the surest guide

for our conduct — one that lifts us above every anxious regard for suspicions and calumnies. Our judgment upon the relief action of the "Allianz" also was determined only by love of our people, by care for its welfare and its honour. ...

One still remembers what indignation it called forth when the congregational potentates of Stanislaus called out the authorities against the Roumanian emigrants passing through. And yet in that case one had to do only with narrow-hearted, limited people who, in the cramped conditions of the small town and of the business of getting a living, have become stunted in mind and heart. But when one perceives, on the part of the greatest Jewish relief organisation of our Empire — which in § 2, II. of its statutes expressly declares that it has for its purpose "to offer an effective support to Israelites there, where they still have to suffer as such" — a procedure by no means better, then in the interest of the dignity of the Jewish people this may not be quietly acquiesced in. We readily believe the gentlemen of the "Allianz" that the demands which the rendering of help to the Roumanian emigrants made upon them were very great, and that many a sacrifice of rest and comfort was required of them. We believe them also that the Roumanian emigration took them by surprise. But when one accepts a place upon the board of so great a relief society as the "Allianz", one also takes over certain duties. The being taken by surprise by the Roumanian emigration might have been avoided, had the gentlemen concerned themselves more with the fate of their oppressed fellow-countrymen in the East of Europe, and had they listened more attentively to the cries of complaint pressing out of Roumania for so long a time past. If the gentlemen whom the board of the "Allianz" entrusted with the carrying out of the work of relief were not equal to the task they had taken over, then they ought to have declared this openly, and other men would have stepped into their place who would have carried through the relief action in a worthy and profitable manner. So great a society as the "Allianz", which the whole Austro-Hungarian Jewry has in a manner made its central organ for the help devoted to the unhappy Roumanian fellow-countrymen — a society to which the contributions to this work of relief have flowed in from the remotest communities of the Empire — must also justify the confidence shown to it by employing the means placed at its disposal in such a way that not only would those needing help really have been helped, but that the work of relief itself would have shaped itself into an imposing manifestation of the Jewish people holding faithfully and firmly together in time of need. How many a Jew living in modest circumstances has gladly strained himself beyond his powers, in the good faith that he too was contributing on his part to the exercise of Jewish solidarity and of the so much lauded Jewish "Rachmonus". But how bitterly disappointed would he have been had he been a witness of the manner in which the poor Roumanian emigrants were treated here in Vienna. To be sure, the defenders of the guilty members of the board will point out that among the emigrants there were also doubtful elements, towards whom an energetic bearing was called for. But let it not be forgotten that as against movements of a whole people the judgment of drawing-room fitness is out of place, and still much less so there where the question is of an escape from material and moral ruin. "Be he holy, be he wicked, the man of misfortune moves them to pity" — these words of Goethe's might have served the gentlemen of the Allianz too for a guiding line. But quite apart from all complaints of the brutalities that occurred, of the want of provision for shelter and food, the facts of the attempted and finally achieved closing of the frontier remain bad enough, and they alone would in fullest measure justify the agitation prevailing against those who caused it. If the guilty should to-day appeal to the plea that they had instructions from the Paris "Alliance", and that the reception of the emigrants on the part of the shipping companies or of the American authorities was doubtful, then it must be held up against them that it was they who informed the Paris "Alliance" and thereby provoked its instructions, and that the further course of the emigration has indeed taught how all the difficulties which opposed themselves to immigration into America could in fact be overcome. "Difficulties are there in order to be overcome" is the watchword of all