Page 2 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 42
(continued from page 1)
…and of inward composure at once. There, in the first place, our ancient virtue, the consciousness of equality, was practised in an unforced manner, and the feeling of belonging together was strengthened.
Yet what avails it to look back and lament what is past and lost. The times have become other, and we must reckon with the new conditions. True, we have squandered our old sociability, like so much other precious inheritance of our fathers, in careless short-sightedness; all the more compelling is the duty to set something new, perhaps even something better, in the place of what is irretrievably lost.
We think, of course, above all of the poor, of the weak, of the people. We will not assert that the rich among us forget their duties towards the poor. That would be an ingratitude, a slander upon the Jewish character. No, we have an abundance of benevolence among us — too much benevolence, some say. But, characteristically enough, all altruistic institutions provide for the Jewish body; the Jewish spirit, the Jewish heart, never comes into consideration in the gifts and bequests. One believes one has done everything when one gives a starving father of a family the means to procure himself a pedlar's box, that he may keep the wolf from his door; one congratulates oneself upon the newest organisation which helps Jews seeking work to an honest livelihood.
But man does not live by bread alone. Who was it that spoke the profound word: "Provide me with my luxury; for my necessities I shall provide myself"? The kind and the measure of a man's earnings are very important factors in his life, but they are not everything. The morality, the social worth, the future of a family depend just as much upon the kind and the measure of its recreation. You, the rich, the benevolent, relieve the bodily distress of our poor brethren in race, you procure them work and earnings — excellent! We would complete your work and help them to a decent recreation worthy of human beings.
Our means are for the present slender; we must begin with small things. Two large rooms, well aired, well warmed and well lighted, must suffice for the beginning. A hundred chairs, a few tables, a platform, a piano, a large tea-kettle — that for the present is the whole furniture. Our hospitality is as modest as our furniture. We offer only a cup of tea and a biscuit — on request, da capo. Payment is out of the question.
From a fixed hour onward — let us say, from 8 o'clock — every guest is sure of finding stimulation in some form. There is a reading, a tale, a lecture, a discussion, a concert, an exhibition, an interpretation. Naturally Jewish questions stand foremost; naturally Judaism and Jewish letters are cultivated in the first rank. But we are far removed from confessional narrowness. All that is human is near to us. We draw art and science, in the most comprehensive sense, within our sphere.
And now we hear two questions:
- What sort of guests does the Jewish Toynbee Hall expect?
- Who is to entertain and amuse the guests?
The first question is put, not without a certain uneasiness, by those Jews who know the Jewish "people" from hearsay and from a few eternally money-needing specimens. We Jews have a comical fear of one another. This is not to be taken tragically; on the contrary, it proves how strongly conscious we are of our belonging together. One does not avoid an utter stranger, even when one sees his indigence upon him; he has, after all, no right to approach one with a demand. An acquaintance in shabby clothing one goes out of one's way to escape. We Jews guard ourselves against our "people" because we rightly feel that it is ill done to refuse them the help we owe them. To vary an old saying: "If we are not for ourselves, who is for us?"
Well then, this comprehensible fear of the "people" is greatly exaggerated. Our "people" is poor, very poor, but also proud, very proud! Professional beggars there are everywhere, and of these we have a disproportionately great number — but these are not the people. Such folk will not become burdensome to us, for they ply their trade only towards individuals. And should they come — the misfortune would still be bearable.
But we expect quite other people. Whoever has once seen the public which gathers year in, year out, and listens standing, when our excellent Lector Friedmann expounds Bible and Midrash, knows how many Jewish artisans, pedlars, small shopkeepers, clerks and brokers thirst to forget, at least once in the week, the tragedy of their loneliness in the desert of the great city, to feel themselves for a few hours members of a whole, and to satisfy the old Jewish need of spiritual nourishment. These Jews will be our welcome guests — the more numerous, the more often, the better.
And who is to entertain the guests?
That the London Toynbee Hall shall tell us.
Arnold Toynbee, an Oxford university aristocrat with all that reserve, remoteness from the world and delicacy of feeling which only the wholly peculiar English city of scholars upon the upper Thames brings forth, was the first to whom it dawned that all striving after culture and all self-perfection were in truth rather egoistic so long as the great majority of the common people has not even an inkling of the infinite world of mind in which a cultivated man moves. Toynbee descended — an immeasurable sacrifice! — from the height of the university aristocrat to the people, and sought to open to them the glory of culture. He died far too early (1883); but his impulse had fallen upon fruitful soil. In memory of this friend of the people the Toynbee Hall in Whitechapel was founded, which has become nothing less than the model for all similar institutions. Toynbee Hall has now become a generic term and has passed into all the languages of culture. A Toynbee Hall is a place in which the rich and the learned seek contact with the poor and the ignorant, the ground upon which the outermost strata of society peaceably come together, a house in which the ways are levelled for a future reconciliation of the social contrasts.
But who allures the people into Toynbee Hall? Volunteers from every circle of the intellectual aristocracy. The press of the cultivated to the Toynbee Hall evenings is very great; it would not be difficult for the director of the institution to find three lecturers for one and the same evening. Writers of the first rank gladly place themselves at the service of the work of education, and it has become a distinction to be able to take part in this work.