No. 36. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
...culture which we wish to create is a non-culture, is in truth a retrogression. The modern development of our people must be honestly and unreservedly recognised, and the principle must be immovably adhered to that, like every genuine culture, the Jewish also must be at once humanistic and national. The Congress should therefore lend its authority to this, that the people devote itself to the work of its intellectual and national regeneration. National-Jewish popular education is not an also-Zionism; no, it is Zionism itself! (Lively applause.)
The Congress should further express its highest recognition to all pioneers in the field of popular education and popular training (Stormy applause) and, within the limits of its means, extend its highest support to the promotion of the Hebrew language and of Jewish literature. The rapporteur further advocates the maintenance of the Beth-hasepher at Jaffa and the support of the National Library at Jerusalem (Lively applause), urges the founding of free associations and circles as well as the holding of teachers' conferences, and finally moves the following resolution: "The Congress declares that the work of the intellectual elevation of the Jews forms, in theory and in principle, an integral part of Zionism." (Lively applause.)
In the debate upon this report Rabbi Reines (Lida) and Herr Taiz first take the word. They hold that culture is not the main thing, but rather that the people should get bread to eat and be secured generally in a material respect. Then the higher morality which is held out as a consequence of culture will come of itself.
After a somewhat lengthy debate upon points of order, the election of general speakers upon this item of the agenda is resolved upon, and the sitting is thereupon adjourned at ¼1 o'clock in the night until Thursday at 10 o'clock in the forenoon.
Fourth Day.
Forenoon Sitting.
The sitting is opened at ¼11 o'clock by Dr. Herzl, and thereupon once again a great number of messages of greeting are read out.
Dr. Leop. Kahn (Vienna) thereupon takes the word as co-rapporteur upon the intellectual elevation of the Jewish people. He designates it as a wrong to forsake the ancient traditions. The word "culture," which has called forth so many differences of opinion, may easily be dispensed with, but not the essence of the matter. He moves the following resolution: "With equal respect for every direction of conviction, and without setting up a definite, fixed programme for the lands of the Diaspora, the Congress makes it the duty of every Zionist and of the Zionist societies to work at the intellectual elevation of the Jewish people in the religious, moral and national respect. It deems it desirable that, for the easier attainment of this end, corresponding national organisations be created, which, where access to the State schools is made difficult for the Jews, shall call into life and maintain institutions in which, besides the general subjects of instruction, the study of the Hebrew language and a thorough knowledge of Jewish culture and history shall be introduced as obligatory subjects. Such organisations will have to render report to the Congress upon their activity." (Lively applause.) The rapporteur recommends the acceptance of this resolution in the name of the Culture Committee, since it signifies a middle course which can satisfy all. (Lively applause.)
Rabbi Reines (Lida) regards the culture question as something foreign to Zionism, and holds that whoever is for the inclusion of the culture question in the programme of Zionism either does not understand Zionism or bears himself passively towards it.
General speaker Dr. Weitzmann declares himself against drawing the religious element into the programme, since thereby many would be excluded from the Congress. No concessions should be made here. If the rabbis come hither as representatives of the people, they are welcome. But if they come as representatives of the synagogue, in order to hinder our deliberations, that is anti-Jewish. (Lively applause.)
Dr. Awinowitzky (Odessa) desires to see the culture question eliminated from the programme. Culture is a question by itself. To raise and discuss it here, however, would only call forth dissensions.
Leo Mozkin holds that the Culture Committee gave the rapporteur Dr. Kahn no such commission; nothing was resolved in the committee concerning elevation in the religious respect.
President Dr. Herzl states that no formal resolution of the Culture Committee is before them, and that Doctor Kahn has made this motion only in his own name.
Mozkin thereupon moves that the words "in the religious respect" be struck out of the Kahn resolution.
The rapporteur Sokolow refers, with regard to the culture question, to the Basle Programme, in which one has after all pledged oneself to elevate the Jewish national consciousness.
President Dr. Herzl states that Herr Mozkin, with his motion for the deletion of the word "religious," intends nothing whatever hostile to religion. He takes therein merely the standpoint which has been adopted at the previous Congresses, not to discuss these questions here, in order that no misunderstandings may arise as to the national tendency of Zionism. (Lively assent.) One must, now as before, abide by this, that Zionism excludes all questions of creed. (Lively applause.) Dr. Kahn has withdrawn his motion. Besides, a motion for passing to the order of the day is before the Congress. The same is adopted amid lively applause.
President Dr. Herzl communicates that the rapporteur upon the question of economic elevation, Doctor Isidor Marmorek, is prevented by family circumstances from delivering the report. He points to the importance of this subject, in which the Congress can accomplish something really practical. The proposals moved by the rapporteur run:
- Training for the economic struggle: a) Preparation for the chosen calling, rendered necessary by the closing of the public schools against Jews. b) Creation of professional corporations and trade unions.
- Provision during work and in the time of unemployment: a) Sickness, invalidity and old-age provision. b) Labour registries and insurance against unemployment.
- Measures for economic emancipation: a) Making possible of self-production (productive associations). b) Opening up of markets for this production. c) Creation of credit associations, loan banks, raw-material associations and consumers' unions.
Advocate Jasinowsky (Warsaw) moves, having regard to the short time still at disposal, and since with the existing means nothing considerable can be accomplished, to pass to the order of the day upon this subject.
President Dr. Herzl declares himself against this, having regard to the importance of the matter. Precisely here the societies could be very active throughout the year, and here it could be proved that one does not throw phrases about, but really has the intention of accomplishing something for the people. (Lively applause.)
The motion for passing to the order of the day is rejected.
Dr. Katzenellensohn (Vilna) discusses in a very detailed manner the economic position of the Jews, which in by far the most cases is a wretched one. By the aid of statistics he shows that it is not correct that commerce in Russia lies preponderantly in the hands of the Jews. On the other hand, the number of Jewish handicraftsmen and factory workers is a very great one. The speaker makes in particular the conditions in the more populous towns of Russia the subject of his address, where the manner of nourishment is the worst conceivable. Charity cannot help there; there intervention must be made in another way, and a suitable means thereto would be the founding of credit banks in all the larger towns where Jews dwell. In conclusion the speaker expresses the hope that the Jewish Colonial Bank will one day be able to support these credit banks. (Lively applause.)
Dr. Rosenheck (Kolomea) urges the creation of associations upon a Jewish-national basis, in order to procure for Jews without means a cheap and ample credit and in this way also to establish livelihoods. The organisations already in existence, too,
