No. 30 — "Die Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…tion ready to hand, that Palestine is not in a position to nourish all the Jews. Does the Heath of Hampstead bear all the animal and vegetable food which the millions of London daily require? — Of all the dainties that come upon the Londoner's breakfast table, not a single one grows upon the heath soil of London; but every zone of the earth strives to bring its best products to the London market. America vies with Hungary for the favour of supplying the millions on the Thames with white bread; India seeks to outstrip the Middle Kingdom as a purveyor of tea; Ceylon and the Congo State seek to displace the Mocha bean; Normandy sends in swift ships the best products of its dairy farming across the Channel.
And this amiability of the purveyors is not extorted by superior force, but won by capacity for work and by joy in work.
Do we Jews stand behind the English in capacity for work? The faintest-hearted among us will not assert that.
Or is it the will to work that is wanting?
Those Jews who assert it judge the great majority of our people either by a few bad specimens or by themselves; but we, who learn anew day by day in our own persons that the Jew must perform three times the measure of work, of intellectual or of bodily work, in order to obtain the third part of the wage of life that falls to the non-Jew; we, to whom the superhuman exertions of the Jewish masses are known, who have seen with our own eyes how a Galician middleman in all weathers mounts the grain waggon at three o'clock in the night in order to reach the fair by morning, how the whole day long he lifts sacks of grain weighing a hundredweight and ties them with half-frozen fingers, in order after this slave's labour to gain a ridiculously small and not always certain profit; we, who have seen the earth-workers of Boryslaw and the water-carriers of Tarnow, we know that our Jewish capacity for work, which is now squandered upon unworthy and worthless struggles, is great enough to create a fairer London upon the old soil that is our own. —
A second London sight, which again concerns us Jews far more than all other travellers, is to be found scattered over all the poor quarters of the town. It is, however, entirely sufficient to see one example of this remarkable institution.
A short journey out beyond the City brings us to Toynbee Hall. The red building with the narrow entrance stands out sharply from the warehouses of the noisy neighbourhood. High summer is not particularly suited to bring the purpose of Toynbee Hall before one's eyes, for it is vacation time; but the quiet court with its green walls, the salon whose windows stand open, the library, which is pretty well always in use, the chess room — these rooms alone show the visitor that he finds himself in a world which, though in space it lies in the midst of Whitechapel, is yet in spirit as far removed from that poor quarter of the town as the University of Oxford from a Hottentot kraal in South Africa. What has this academic building to do in Whitechapel?
Let one have the purpose of the several rooms explained by the secretary, and one will recognise the character of the whole. The rich and the educated seek in Toynbee Hall to come nearer to the poor and the ignorant. Young men from the best houses settle down in the midst of the poverty of Whitechapel in order to get into touch with the people. The wealth of the West seeks out the poverty of the East, because it feels that the social order of the newest age has divided the nation into two hostile camps, because a sound instinct tells it that this rift has even now led to a baleful system of castes and for the near future threatens the State with moral ruin. A modern people must not fall asunder into Helots and aristocrats; but England was in a fair way to reach that condition.
We Jews look upon the trim building which is to prepare the way for the solution of the social question in England, and think not without shame of the despised Klaus in far-off, unlettered Polackei. The Jews of the East, upon whom we Europeans look down so complacently, the poor, old-believing Jews of the Wonder-Rabbis and of the endless, sole-saving study of the Talmud — these people recognised the necessity of Toynbee Halls long before Arnold Toynbee, and in accordance with that recognition called countless Toynbee Halls into being. Whether Klaus or Bet-ha-Midrasch or Minyan — the name is a matter of indifference: in essence all three have the same purpose, and all three fulfil that purpose. Where there is a Klaus, there is no difference between poor and rich. Outside, in the market, in the shop, blind chance may rule, may smite the worthy man with poverty and shower riches upon the bad — in the Klaus, in the place consecrated to God and His teaching, there rules human reason, which makes good the blunders of destiny; there the pious man is honoured, the learned man admired; there the rich man counts himself happy to obtain a seat beside the worthy poor man. The social equality which among the highly civilised peoples has become a Utopia — the Jews of the East actually possess it, without perhaps knowing it.
And we, the western, the enlightened Jews?
As docile pupils of the nations we have torn asunder every bond between poor and rich; we have raised a wall between the weak and the strong, that the complaints of the unfortunate may not perchance disturb the fortunate in their comfort. Jewish brotherhood? Jewish solidarity? Oh yes, so long as one is oneself poor and stands in need of that brotherhood; the moment one climbs up into a higher caste, every contact with the poor is a defilement.
Meanwhile the sons of our rich men play at Marx and Lassalle and go regularly to London in order to study in Toynbee Hall the bloodless solution of the social question.
Look at it, this Toynbee Hall, ye participants in the Congress, and reflect whether we Jews have done well, out of sheer craving for culture, to destroy without judgment all the old Jewish institutions.
(Conclusion follows.)
Assimilationist Endeavours in Alsace.
By Dr. Elias (Mülhausen).
If anywhere the conditions for an assimilation were favourable, it was in Alsace from the time of the emancipation of the Jews. The Jewish population was relatively small, the State exerted itself with all its means on behalf of assimilation, the burgher class was enthusiastic for Voltaire and Rousseau, the people seemed the ideas of liberty