No. 14 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7
(continued from page 6)
…Hebrew Heine. This title, however, applied rather to his person (naturally in point of religion) than to his poems.
The mass emigration of the Jews to the oversea lands pressed the journalistic pen into his hand. The question was: America or Palestine? The elements concerned for the welfare of the Jews divided themselves into two camps: into "Chowewe Zion" and friends of America. Schapira belonged to the guard of the latter. In Palestine he believed — as many otherwise clear-sighted heads of that time erroneously believed — that he foresaw the dominion of the Schulchan-Aruch and of Rabbinism. The colonisation of Palestine is consequently, according to his opinion at that time, the return to the darkness of the Middle Ages. This conviction moved him to a vehement polemical writing against the propagators of the colonisation of Palestine, a writing which went beyond the frame of a journalistic polemic and culminated in the coarsest abuse and imputations.
Until the beginning of the nineties he lived in the belief that America was a far better place of refuge for the persecuted and hard-pressed Jews than Palestine. In spite of the failures of the emigrants and of the awakening of antisemitism in America he was by no means taught better. But when at length the national element of the Jewish question began to clear itself within him, and when the fiasco of the colonisation in Argentina was already unavoidable, Schapira attached himself to the party of the "Chowewe Zion."
Since the appearance of political Zionism Schapira has become a full and entire Philo-Zionist. After the first Basle Congress he signed his poems no longer "Constantin," but "Abe" (an abbreviation of his Jewish name: Ascher ben Eliah). He went about also with the thought of going to Palestine, in order to be able to close his life there as a Jew. The execution of this plan was unhappily not granted him, since death suddenly and unexpectedly carried him off.
A good part in his complete return to Judaism was borne also by the issue of the Dreyfus affair, which threw him, like many others, into feverish excitement. The rightness of Zionism would not before quite commend itself to him. The "Europeanism" of his youth still struggled a little within him — until the Dreyfus affair opened his eyes. To his indignation over this affair he gave expression in his last literary labour. He worked it up, namely, in a dramatic poem "Sodom," which appeared in print some months ago.
In his testament he has — as is reported to me from St. Petersburg — left behind some thousands of roubles for the "Odessa Society for the Support of Jewish Agriculturists and Handicraftsmen in Palestine," and bequeathed his whole library to the National Library at Jerusalem founded by Dr. Chazanowitz.
Gustav Bader.
Rabbi Werner and the Russian Rabbis.
The visitors to the second Basle Congress will still remember the aged man who upon the platform formed the centre of the group of orthodox rabbis. A man of venerable aspect, the face framed in a white full beard, a lofty thinker's brow and clear-glancing eyes. That is Rabbi Werner, the spiritual head of the orthodox "Machsike-Hadas" congregation in London.
It may be of interest to readers to hear something nearer concerning this man, who occupies so eminent a position in the circle of our English fellow-adherents.
A correspondent reports the following concerning Rabbi Werner: In one respect we English Zionists are in any case better off than our Russian brethren: the Russian rabbis who come to us and are placed at the head of our small congregations stand one and all upon our side. Three among them in particular deserve especial mention: Rev. Dogutzki, Jaffe of Manchester and Rabbi A. Werner. The last especially is an excellent Zionist, and wherever he speaks upon the movement one forgets his grey hair. One thinks to have a young Zionist agitator before one.
Some weeks ago there took place in Rabbi Werner's synagogue a great Zionist meeting, at which all the eminent London Zionists were present. The Rabbi presided. He delivered an excellent address.
In a private conversation Rabbi Werner expressed himself as follows upon the agitations of many Russian rabbis against Zionism:
It is our duty to be tolerant towards these rabbis, above all in regard of their position. We have not here to do with Protest Rabbis. The latter do homage to assimilation and are for that reason against our movement. But those defend their divergent standpoint with the best intention. He himself knows many of them whom he reveres and honours for their position and their learning. Their anti-Zionism is rooted merely in ignorance of the matter. Many among them read no newspapers; they know nothing of Jewish history, neither of the past nor of the present. Zionism they know only from hearsay and from the descriptions of third persons. We must go to work with great circumspection if we would win those rabbis. It is to be hoped that this relation will soon alter. We must seek to convince these earnest men that Zionism harbours no designs against religion.
That is the opinion of a man who stands at the head of the oldest orthodox congregation in England. He was called to England by some congregations to whom the shochetim authorised by the rabbinate here were not religious enough.
Rabbi Werner is a good Zionist and hopes that his Russian colleagues too will in time attain to the perception that Zionism desires to help Judaism as well as Jewry, and consequently cannot stand in contradiction to the Holy Scripture. We desire peace in the Jewish camp. It is assuredly to be deplored when rabbis stand in opposition to our movement. Already it has strengthened and fortified Judaism in the various lands. It harms nobody, and we are therefore sorry that there are still rabbis who are ashamed of Zionism and go hand in hand with Protest Rabbis, who maintain that the Jews are no people, but only a religious sect! One can but deplore how far blind hatred goes.
The Russian rabbis will assuredly rejoice in such confederates . . .
That, naturally, troubles us little. In the East End Zionism increases daily. Apart from the ordinary meetings of societies, there takes place weekly at least one mass meeting, mostly in a large synagogue.
L.
