Page 2. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 9.
(continued from page 1)
...able intelligence of the Jews. It is true, the Jews are talented, uncannily talented; but of what use will all that be to them when great national and economic mass-movements turn against them?
With all our talents and little talents we sit high and dry if we spin ourselves into our brain-humanity and will not see that struggles of peoples are not fought out with paper and ink alone. Here Zionism alone can help, with its concentration of the bodily forces and its agrarian-political support. Friedrich Ratzel, the brilliant geographical historian, once said somewhere that the heart-muscle has made far more history than the cleverest thoughts of the brain. Ever since the Greeks fell behind the Romans, who in intellect willingly subordinated themselves to them, ever since the Romans were subjugated by the naive Germans, the world has known that a people becomes great upon the ground of its intellect alone as little as does the individual man. Strong will must not be wanting to greatness in the world's history. Endurance in bearing the hardships of war, capacity for the march alone, is a quality of peoples of historical significance. Greece stood in Rome at the summit of its intellectual and artistic effect at the very time when politically it had become a nothing; it did not in the least raise its political influence by its intellectual predominance. What have the Jews of their hypertrophy of the brain, if they are not man enough to avow themselves the sons of their fathers. History has shown times without number that all decadent pride of culture has come to grief upon self-sacrifice, the capacity for renunciation and rigid discipline. But it seems that no people can learn from its history; it seems that all the catastrophes of history must repeat themselves, and that in such movements of peoples only small portions of the peoples can escape destruction and propagate their national culture.
Jewish Music.
"Music is the true, universal language of mankind." (C. J. Weber, Demokritos, VI, VIII.)
"What is music?" The answering of this question, which is doubtless as old as the art itself, has to this day not been accomplished in a generally satisfactory manner. Lessing, it is true, meant to write a second part to his Laokoon, in which he purposed to set music over against painting and poetry — but he never came to it. Since then many, called and uncalled, have taken pains to do the like of the great poet-philosopher and to determine the boundaries of music. Although it is not the purpose of these lines to furnish an aesthetics of the art of tone, it will nevertheless be necessary to enter a little upon this question.
It may be that nowadays every art is practised for its own sake — certain it is, at all events, that no art arose as such; rather does every art represent only the ennobled form of a human need acknowledged to be generally necessary. Man needs a secure dwelling-place, and by way of rock-dwellings and pile-dwellings arrived at the art of building; he wished to possess a tangible image of his deity and became a sculptor; he testified at last his reverence to the deity by praising it in inspired poetry.
And music? Out of what need did it arise? — Oh, it is old, and far, far back lies its origin; nay, it was created together with the first man; and for those who believe that the first man was not "created" but "descended," I add: the first specimen that we can range under the genus Homo sapiens is that which called the primal form of music its own: speech — or better still, music, the primal form of speech. "A nation," says Herder, "in its first wild origin stares at all objects like a child; terror, fear, and thereupon wonder are the sensations of which alone the two are capable, and the language of these sensations is — tones...... Men did not speak, but sounded... they sang, therefore, as many peoples still do to this day and as the ancient historians throughout assert of their forefathers: men sang in common life, and the poet only heightened his accents in a rhythm chosen for the ear; since as yet there were no writers, they immortalized the most remarkable deeds by songs..."
Out of this beginning of the sounding speech there came then the speech set to tone, music. If we keep this manner of the origin of the art of tone before our eyes, it will also become clear to us why the aesthetician meets with such difficulties: it fares with him as with the mathematician — the simpler a proposition is, the nearer it approaches the axiom, the easier becomes the comprehending and the harder the explaining. Musical beauties are felt by well-nigh every man — but asked what it was in a piece of music that really pleased him, he will not be able to say, as with a picture or a statue: this or that; rather will he find himself in about the same position as one to whom the question is put: "Why do you like the Hungarian language?"
The original, modulating and sounding speech was moreover transformed by degrees into art precisely there where man has longest remained the natural, believingly receptive child: in religion, at divine service; there, where we bring our inmost and most primitive feelings to expression, we do it also in the most primitive speech. And that people in particular, whose whole life and feeling is so intimately bound up with religion, was directed to music by the prohibition contained in its statutes: "Thou shalt not make unto thee any image nor any likeness..." as the sole mediatrix of a personal relation to God.
Thus music has always played an eminent part in the life and in the history of the Jewish people.
In the consideration of Jewish music we must therefore never forget that in ancient times it was not art but divine service; and in so far as we still find remains of it, these fall not under the criticism of the aesthetician, but under that of the historian.
The Bible offers the investigator not much, and he is for the most part thrown upon conjectures; it mentions Jubal as the first player upon the harp and the flute, which is of significance in so far as it appears therefrom that tuned instruments were known already in earlier times; now these must be tuned in fixed intervals always remaining the same, and hence there existed even then an established scale. In many passages songs are spoken of, as for example Miriam's song of victory, which we must conceive as delivered by the precentress and a chorus, or the antiphonal song of Deborah and Barak. By some the "Song of Songs" is held to be a Singspiel, a musical-declamatory pastoral play. In favour of the possibility of such a performance speaks the existence of yet older Singspiele among other Oriental peoples, as for instance