No. 5. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
As for the objection that the Jews, thanks to their harsh individualism, are the least fitted for the creation of an autonomous state, that they feel at ease only under a foreign rod, a dispute over it would be as idle as it is childish. That which once, during the Roman dominion, brought them to their fall will hardly ever return, because conditions have become quite other, and a Diaspora of two thousand years has not passed over them wholly without a trace. To be sure, it is not to be denied that with a mass immigration into Palestine everything cannot run so smoothly, that struggles of every kind, even religious feuds, will not be wanting: but the same happens everywhere. Without struggle — no progress! On the other hand, however, the Jews will carry with them out of their several fatherlands so much experience — partly of a sad, partly of a useful kind — into the new home, and will moreover find stored up in their sacred books, to which they hold fast with iron tenacity, in the Bible and the Talmud, so rich a treasure of ethical first principles, that these will merely have to be extricated from the old rubbish of ritual petrifactions and introduced into practical life, in order that the Jews may crystallise out into a healthy, culturally and ethically sound people... My faith in the ethical educability of my people, which is what matters to me first of all, is firm as a rock ...
Many Ghetto Jews, and indeed the sated and the over-sated, trouble themselves not at all about Zionism, because they trouble themselves about nothing whatever that does not concern their beloved ego. The skin of these gentlemen is as proof against the mass misery of their people as against the thousands of moral boxes on the ear dealt them daily by their Aryan neighbours. "Live — so long as living is possible; enjoy what the moment grants thee: après moi le déluge!" To be sure, from time to time — out of an inherited fear of a beating in the world to come — many a scrap is magnanimously flung to those in need, nay, hospitals and houses of prayer are even erected — but with that the matter rests. "The Jews," it is said, "have suffered for two thousand years and are living still; they will live yet another two thousand years and — suffer: such is the course of the world; nothing can be altered in it ... For us, on the other hand, provision is made for the present."
But there are also such Ghetto Jews as count themselves indeed among the intelligent, but whose intelligence has soared no higher than to Jewish anti-Semitism. From some accidental grounds they have not yet quite cast off Judaism, but in return they cry in every street that the Jews are a miserable, base people — their own person they of course except! — that the Jews fully deserve the fate which befalls them ... From these wretches are recruited most of the contributors to anti-Semitic scandal-sheets after the fashion of the "Nowoje Wremja," kindred spirits of Arthur Meyer and Gaston Polonnais ... It is the same breed of men that once stood by the Greeks when the Maccabees, their heroic co-religionists, fought the desperate fight for their freedom ... From this vermin no sympathy for Zionism is to be expected ...
There are of course also many intelligent Ghetto Jews who are otherwise thoroughly worthy and right-minded, but who are to this day so tainted with cosmopolitanism that they have betaken themselves wholly and entirely into the camp of the liberal Aryans, in order to labour together with the latter at a social evolution. The Jewish question, they hold, is not of a national nor yet of a religious, but exclusively of an economic nature; it is a special case of the "social question" and will find its solution as soon as the latter shall have been solved. The so-called "social question" thus remains the sole scapegoat for all Jewish woe. And withal there are among these evolutionists very few who have made clear to themselves wherein this social question actually consists? For most of them it is a shibboleth, a winged word, nothing further! Very few grasp how complicated this question is, that it embraces not only economic contrasts, contrasts of class, but ethical, national, religious and æsthetic ones as well — and that it is precisely these manifold contrasts which make the solution of the social question in the sense of social justice so infinitely difficult, if possible at all. And for this Messiah, who by the declaration of even optimistically minded sociologists will not arrive for centuries to come, the poor Jews of the Ghetto are to wait in faith!! If in the Europe of to-day, in lands whose inhabitants are divided from one another neither by race nor by religion — but merely by language and nationality — a struggle for hegemony is waged for life and death — between Czechs and Germans, for example — what future then awaits a people which stands out so glaringly from its Aryan neighbours by race as well as by religion and national peculiarities, and which is present besides in a minute minority? The blossoms of this future have already shot up in the Ghetto lands: the Czechs beat the Jews because they are Germans, the Germans — because they are Czechs, the Poles and Roumanians — because they are Jews ... The fair fruits of this social fraternisation will ripen only in the twentieth century, and at that I shudder!
Now there is a goodly number of nationally minded Ghetto Jews, true and worthy sons of their people, who devote their whole lives to the furtherance of Jewish culture and the Jewish spirit, who live and suffer with their co-religionists, but who nevertheless are no Zionists, because they believe neither in the practicability nor in the expediency of a removal to Palestine in particular, although they wish nothing more ardently than that the Jews should somewhere or at some time live out their life as a nation ... They are, then, Zionists, only without Zion. With these I will contend no further, because I am convinced that they will become our most faithful allies as soon as we shall have achieved the first practical successes.
Mention I must make, however, of a black band that houses in the Ghetto, a company of Korah, which actively burrows against us with every reprehensible means of Jesuitical underhandedness, which sets specially paid agents in motion in order not only to slander, to suspect and to denounce Zionism, but the leaders as well, and to cross their plans. These honourable men are recruited precisely from sanctimonious sneaks and hypocritical rabbis who give themselves out as "guardians of the Law." Fortunately their number is not great ... I am indeed far from condemning those orthodox Jews in general, and rabbis in particular, who do not approve of Zionism from the religious standpoint, who the redemption from the Golus through a
