"Die ✡ Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…poor Jews in Palestine, the assailant himself nevertheless pronounces desirable and praiseworthy.
Zionism will, with the certainty and force of a mechanically operating law of nature, bring about a grouping of the Jews into classes.
Whoever is weary of the oppression and feels an unconquerable longing for the civic existence of a wholly free man, without a cowardly flight out of Judaism, will declare himself without reservation for the Jewish State and will personally take part in the building of it;
whoever can endure to be treated in his fatherland by the powers of the State as a citizen of the second class, by many of his fellow-countrymen as a stranger, by some as vermin, whoever in such a position still finds life worth living, but has yet preserved the sense of fellowship with his Jewish kinsmen, will indeed remain himself in the place where he stands, but from his place he will seek to help the pioneers who stand up with their whole personality for the Zionist idea, even though perhaps timidly, in secret, and avoiding every loud word;
whoever has no longer even so much Jewish sense of fellowship that the thought of a political union of the Jewish people awakens in him a stirring of approval, of sympathy, or even of mere curiosity, but who yet possesses the average measure of human charity, compassion and beneficence, will at least value Zionism in its incidental effect as an undertaking of settlement, which seeks to prepare new homes for the poorest and the noblest among the Jews, for those who have absolutely nothing to lose and who by every change in their circumstances can only gain; and he will support Zionism, not because it seeks to found a Jewish State, but because it seeks to practise a thoroughgoing beneficence upon poor and wretched men;
whoever lacks not only every Jewish feeling, but even the average love of mankind, whoever takes part neither as a Jew in a deliverance of the Jews from political and social outlawry, nor as a man in the release of his fellow-men from the bitterest distress, him the whole matter does not concern; Zionism does not exist for him, he will assuredly not support it, but his cold-heartedness, his indifference, will at least preserve him from attacking it;
hostile to Zionism only one category of Jews will come forth: that of the self-seekers, who fear for themselves some remote evil consequence of the Zionist movement, who feel at ease as despised and insulted men, and who cannot forgive the discontented and the impatient for daring to venture an exertion without regard to the quiet comfort of the sated and the well-pleased — in short, the occupants of the boat who strike with the axe at the hand of the shipwrecked man clutching the gunwale, because they fear that the vessel might, through overcrowding, become unsafe for themselves.
I do not regard it as my task to assign Chief Rabbi Dr. M. Güdemann to one of these classes.
Paris, end of May.
Russian Jews.
By Dr. Theodor Herzl.
There exists also a certain West-European arrogance which treats the Jews of other lands as very backward creatures. He is always a barbarian who is not understood. "Barbarus hic ego sum, quia non intelligor illis." And so one pictures to oneself the East-European Jew as a sort of Caliban. What an error. For me, I confess it, the appearance of the Jews from Russia was the greatest event of the Congress. For some time past I had been in an absorbing correspondence with several of them, and had also received various visits which interested me. But I took good care not to form a picture of the mass from these men of culture. Only the reports of the bodily efficiency and the love of labour of the lower Jewish strata in Russia did I accept as true, and was bound to accept as true, since they appeared sufficiently attested and were confirmed by every eye-witness who had seen the poorest Russian Jews at their handicraft or at field labour in the philanthropic experimental stations called "colonies". The efficiency of these handicraftsmen and Unskilled labourers is indeed one of the foundations of our plan. To them, after all, falls the task of performing the first work of civilisation in the desolate land. They shall be, they will be the reclaimers of the soil. But we had never imagined anything else than that they would be dependent upon our intellectual help and guidance. And then there rose up before us at the Basle Congress a Russian Jewry of a strength of culture we had not expected. That is not Caliban, but Prospero. Some seventy men from Russia had appeared at the Congress, and we might say with all certainty that they represent the opinions and the feelings of the five million Jews in Russia. And what a humiliation for us, who had believed ourselves their superiors. All these professors, physicians, advocates, engineers, manufacturers and merchants have a level of education which is certainly not below that of the West Europeans. On an average they speak and write two or three modern languages of culture, and that each must be efficient in his own field may be surmised from the hardness of the struggle for existence which they have to sustain in their country. In the publicity of the Congress proceedings they purposely did not come much to the front, because one must reckon with the fact that the purposes and aims of Zionism are as yet not sufficiently known in the world. The error might arise, or be called forth by the malevolent, that at Basle something was being deliberated against the established order of things. The Russians had therefore, for intelligible reasons, to impose a certain reserve upon themselves until the ground should be levelled in this direction, and every single speaker, from whatever country he might have come, took this situation into account. To-day it may surely be assumed that the Government and public opinion in Russia also are completely enlightened concerning Zionism. The Russian journals have treated the Congress with attention.
But although our Russian Zionists took only a modest part in the public debates, we nevertheless came to know and to esteem them in private conversation. If I sum up this impression, which was a very strong one, in a single word, it is this: they possess the inner unity which most European Jews have lost. They feel themselves to be national-
