Page 2 — "Die ✡ Welt"
Dr. Güdemann remarks with displeasure that of late the idea that they are a distinct branch of a people has found numerous adherents among the Jews, who have consistently developed it further into the demand that the distinct branch must also obtain its own land and a national articulation in which it may live itself out as a State. "The midwife of this movement was indignation.... To indignation there then joined itself, as is natural, defiance." But this movement contradicts the essence of Judaism. With a great expenditure of citations from the canonical and the expository writings Herr Güdemann seeks to prove that the Jews are not a people, nay, that they may not form a people. The spirit of their faith, the course of their history since the destruction of the Second Temple, positively forbids them to feel themselves a people, to join themselves together into a united people. Their mission is precisely the overcoming of the national idea, the leading forth of mankind out of the narrowness of independent nationalism into the breadth and freedom of humanity. The fraternisation, not the separation, of the peoples is the task of Judaism. The Zion that is promised to the Jews, and after which their longing has sighed these two thousand years, is to be understood symbolically. It is a spiritual Zion. It is another word for the Kingdom of God upon earth. If Judaism be gathered into a people and organised into a polity of its own, it is hindered in the accomplishment of its mission, and a sin is committed against the ordinances of its faith.
I hope Dr. Güdemann will find that I have honestly rendered the leading lines of his pamphlet, and that I may with a good conscience take the foregoing composition of its essential contents as the basis of the discussion.
The Chief Rabbi of Vienna would fain conduct the struggle against Zionism upon theological ground. It would be childish of us to consent to follow him thither. Zionism has not the least thing to do with theology. It is not a religious movement, but a political, an economic, a moral-historical and a sociological one. Dr. Güdemann makes himself guilty of petty word-play when he uses — or misuses — the outward circumstance that the name of the movement awakens Biblical recollections, in order to fasten upon Thora and Mishna on account of the designation "Zion." When the Jews are inflamed with the wish to raise up a new realm of Zion, they draw the impulse thereto neither from the Thora nor from the Mishna, but from the distress of the times, from their immediate, living feelings, from their resolve not to endure the situation prepared for them in the midst of the nations. The name "Zion" has forced itself upon them not for religious but for historical reasons. It does not produce the Zionist craving, it does not justify it; it merely assigns to it a definite direction, it adds to it, through the memory which it awakens, a mightily dynamogenic emotion. This is still a very great rôle; a religious rôle it is not.
I can calmly assume — I need not for the present concede — that Dr. Güdemann's theological expositions are correct. Granted that Zionism cannot be founded upon Bible and Talmud; that would not alter the movement in the least, for it is for the movement wholly immaterial.
Anti-Semitism makes harder the bare, bodily existence of the unpropertied Jews, and in many places even threatens it with destruction; it wounds the well-placed Jews in their feelings and does not let them take joy in their life; it takes from the best, the most exemplary Jews the possibility of unfolding their faculties up to their natural limits, since free activity on every side and the striving after the highest goals are organic conditions of the full development of all powers. Out of this intolerable condition the Jews are striving with passionate urgency. The energetic among them see the only salvation in the founding of a Jewish State; the sentimental, the pious, the diplomatically prudent desire that the geographical frame of this Jewish State should be Palestine; but Palestine is not the essential postulate; should the acquisition of Palestine prove wholly impossible for the Jews, should it be far easier to find another land of sufficient extent and of suitable quality of soil and climate, then most, perhaps all Zionists would doubtless be ready without hesitation to settle that other land. Of Argentina there stands nothing in Thora and Midrash. Nevertheless hundreds of thousands of strictly law-observing Russian and Roumanian Jews, fanatically holding fast to tradition, were eager to migrate to Argentina when before their eyes there dawned the first faint gleam of hope that their earthly lot in Argentina would be kindlier than in the land of their birth. What then does Dr. Güdemann's argument signify, that Thora and Midrash neither prescribe nor justify the return to Zion? That which sets the deep masses of Jewry in motion is the vis a tergo, which I grimly translate as "a kick at the rear end"; it is the persecution in the land of their birth; the Zion idea works as a fore-team, as a drawing power from in front; it colours the goal with the fair blue of the ideal; it takes from the unknown, which darkens before every great political-ethnographical experiment, a part of its terrors by quickening it with images of promise; it helps the believing Jew over the dread of an uncertain future. But even without this element of the ideal which the Zion idea adds to the Jewish-national movement, the mere vis a tergo would suffice to call it forth. Scribes who have much free time may content themselves, in the comfortable digestive hours of Saturday afternoons, with holding up against one another shrewdly chosen passages of Bible and Talmud for and against Zionism. Amateurs find such pilpul entertaining. Any objective value I cannot ascribe to it.
But Dr. Güdemann combats not only the idea of raising up a realm of Zion; he also denies that the Jews are a people. Only out of "indignation and defiance" do they now feel themselves a distinct people over against their anti-Semitic persecutors. And if that were so? A phenomenon is surely not struck out of reality by the uncovering of its causes! The establishing of its causes is, on the contrary, a recognition of the phenomenon. Indignation and defiance are good feelings. I pity the milksop who is not capable of them. They are a healthy reaction against provocation and malice. The vital force of an organism is measured by the strength of its reactions against hostile stimuli. Defiance and indignation are rooted in self-respect, in the sense of honour, in the consciousness of strength. These are three sufficient sources of national feeling.
The Jews are to be no people? About this point
