Die Welt · Vol. III, No. 52 · 29 December 1899
7printed page
scan 11 of 20

No. 52 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 7.


(continued from page 6)

…breaking a path for itself. Numerous meetings in London and in the provinces have carried the understanding of the movement into wider circles. With the help of the "Messenger of Zion" and of the Jargon journal "Das Volk", and further through the appearance of Jargon speakers, we shall in all probability attain a great influence upon all classes of the people and be in a position to attach at least one society a month to our organisation.

It will also interest your readers to learn what is going forward in our congregational circles. First of all I must point to the meeting of the "Anglo Jewish Association". (Be it observed in passing that this society possesses a considerable number of Shares of the "Jewish Colonial Bank".) The Association was founded twenty-seven years ago with a certain Zionist tendency; in reality it is a union similar to the Parisian "Alliance israélite universelle". With the emergence of the Jewish question in Russia and the rise of the Russian relief committee a great part of its work fell away. The formation of a society with a similar tendency took from it a further portion of its field of activity. Already in the lifetime of Sir Julian Goldsmid the sphere of action of the "A. J. A." was a purely cultural one.

Some of the older members did not indeed grow weary of raising objections against this narrowing of the original programme, and it was very congenial to them when Dr. Gaster two years ago called upon the members to turn to Zionism. But the time for that had nevertheless not yet come, nor is it come even now. Still, one may assert that the old guard of the Association bears Zionism a certain sympathy.

Perhaps it was this very circumstance which contributed to the fact that at one of the latest sittings of the "Jewish Historical Society", which is connected with the "Anglo Jewish Association", Zionism came quite unexpectedly upon the carpet and called forth an exceedingly interesting discussion. Mr. Claude G. Montefiore, the President of the Association, had, namely, sent in to the "Historical Society" an essay which was read out by the author's friend, Mr. Israel Abrahams. In this treatise Mr. Montefiore sets forth that citizenship and Jewish nationalism are irreconcilable opposites, and that the Jews must decide for the one or the other.

He felt, he said, that nationalism must founder upon the rock of universal Judaism, and that this in its turn would be destroyed by the reawakening of a Jewish nation, whose existence would not be impossible, as he proved from history. Naturally Mr. Montefiore is for a "universal Judaism"; but he set up an alternative and required of his friends and hearers that they should reflect upon the problem — as he called it — and decide.

Chance would have it that this lecture in the "Jewish Historical Society" was delivered in the presence of both Chief Rabbis of London, Doctor Adler and Doctor Gaster, and that both were called upon to express their opinion upon it. The chairman declared that he would utter his own view only as the last speaker. Dr. Adler recalled his articles upon "The Jews as Citizens" published in the seventies. The Jews, he said, were a religious brotherhood, not a nation, and he was an Englishman of Jewish conviction. — Then rose, enthusiastically greeted by his friends, Dr. Gaster, and declared himself for the absolute contrary. He treated the company to a chapter upon "hysterical patriotism" which did not fail of its impression. He observed in a humorous vein that half of what Mr. Montefiore said he could accept and support. Thus, then, was the question of Zionism thoroughly discussed in this illustrious society. And that is a gratifying sign of the times. J. de H.


The Delegates' Conference of Hanover.

The following minutes were transmitted by the committee of the Zionist Association in Cologne to the Actions Committee for publication in the "Communications of the Actions Committee". Now the space allotted to those Communications does not permit of bringing the minutes in their whole extent. We hold it right, however, not to withhold from our readers the wording of these minutes. They would have appeared earlier had they been sent in earlier by the "Zionist Federation for Germany".


Minutes of the Delegates' Conference of the Zionist Federation for Germany at Cologne. Hanover, the 22nd November 1899.

Delegates are present from Altona, Berlin, Bonn, Cologne, Dresden, Freiburg i. Br., Hanover, Heidelberg, Kattowitz, Hamburg and Leipzig. The gentlemen elected in Berlin and Frankfort-on-Main are prevented from attending.

Dr. Bodenheimer greets the Delegates' Conference and expresses the wish that, in accordance with the third Basle Congress, this Delegates' Conference may devote itself in the first place to the internal building up of our organisation, to the questions of propaganda and so forth, now that the preceding assemblies have sufficiently considered the programmatic side.

Stiftsrabbiner Meyer of Hanover bids the delegates a hearty welcome in the name of the Hanover local group.

A telegram of greeting is despatched to the Actions Committee and its chairman, Herr Dr. Herzl in Vienna.

Mr. van Cleef of Cologne presents the treasurer's report as the deputy of the treasurer, Gust. Wolff of Cologne.

Mr. Wolffsohn of Cologne gives, upon several inquiries relating to particularly large items of expenditure (for example calendars, etc.), information satisfactory on all sides. "In the first years larger sums have perhaps been expended upon certain agitation material than the successes thereby attained have since justified; we were beginners, and have learned from such errors as were made." The unfinished state of the organisation also, he said, had occasioned many additional outlays. The speaker begs that the local groups may support the central body more strongly than hitherto, and may require of their members, in accordance with the statutes, that they become members also of the "Zionist Federation for Germany", which, as is known, has reduced the minimum subscription to 1 M. p. a. The state of the treasury was at present favourable, but chiefly because a few larger voluntary contributions (donations) had come in; with a stricter centralisation such things would become unnecessary.

Dr. Klee of Bonn reports upon the activity of the bureau. Since the last Delegates' Conference the groups of Freiburg i. Br., Freiberg in Saxony, Mittweida and Bonn have been newly founded. Suggestions have been given, and committees respectively created, in Göttingen and Coblenz. At Karlsruhe, at a South German conference, a propaganda committee for Baden and the Rhenish Palatinate was elected, with its seat at Freiburg i. Br., which, thanks to the extremely faithful work of the Freiburg gentlemen, has already some successes to show, and which after a projected larger agitation will, it is hoped, achieve further progress. Suggestions have further been given to Cottbus, Lüneburg, Münster in Westphalia and to various towns of the province of Posen. The founding of district organisations was recommended to the groups in the province of Silesia and in the Kingdom of Saxony. It is reported that steps towards carrying out these organisations are to be taken in the course of this winter.

A list of speakers, the compiling of which proved more difficult than had originally been supposed, was sent to the confidential agents; further, two new leaflets, the so-called Hamburg one (upon yellow paper) and the Freiburg one, were taken over by the central body for the agitation. In many hundreds of copies leaflets and calendars, pamphlets and Congress speeches were despatched in the various directions. There went out to the confidential agents, further, an instruction upon organisation and agitation, and moreover a summons concerning the propagation of the "Welt", and in particular the laying of it out in restaurants and cafés and at the railway stations. Lectures were arranged in Cologne, Coblenz, Dresden, Antwerp and Hanover. Intensive activity in this direction will be brought by the winter, at the beginning of which we as yet stand.

Mr. Wolffsohn discusses the agitation. He desires to see the emphasis directed rather upon the collection of the shekel.

Dr. Friedemann begs that the confidential agents may change as seldom as possible.

Mr. Cohen of Hamburg proposes that the institution of discussion evenings be cultivated more zealously.

Mr. Levinsohn of Hamburg begs that Wolffsohn's suggestion be not followed. Only from really convinced Zionists should the shekel, which confers the active and passive franchise, be taken; others may pay contributions as donors. The speaker recommends the creation of reading-