Die Welt · Vol. III, No. 42 · 20 October 1899
13printed page
scan 17 of 20

No. 42 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 13

(continued from page 12)

…settlement of the Jewish people in Palestine and a condition akin to local self-government. Secondly, to obtain commercial concessions, e. g. for the construction of railways and harbour works. Thirdly, to acquire the necessary tracts of land. Fourthly, to support poor immigrants by the grant of material assistance in the founding of colonies and factories. Dr. Herzl is a decided opponent of the continuance of the present immigration into Palestine, even on the part of well-to-do Jews, since thereby the price of land is driven up without any simultaneous strengthening of the legal position, and because, further, the difficulty of the negotiations is increased. "Let us," he says, "come into Palestine as into a State which does not regard us as foreigners, and we promise you a flourishing modern commonwealth which, in the heart of the world, a mediator between East and West, will send out lines of railway to India and Bagdad and will regenerate not Israel only, but Turkey as well. No one desires that the Jewish people should emigrate in its whole mass. But a recognised centre of Jewish life shall be established once for all and then left to the forces of development that dwell within it. A centre of labour and of dignity, of which it may be expected that it will powerfully attract the persecuted and the patriots."

The arguments usually brought forward against Zionism Zangwill disposes of with a simple statement and summary, without occupying himself with them further. "It has been asserted that Zionism is dangerous, that it puts a weapon into the hands of anti-Semitism, which in any case seeks to cast suspicion upon the patriotism of the Jews. That it contributes to the raising of the price of land and thereby disturbs the development of the otherwise prospering colonising works of benevolence in Palestine. In the religious respect it is a blasphemous attempt to forestall Providence; in the spiritual, a distortion of the true future and mission of Israel; in the intellectual, a mere caricature of that exaggerated nationalism which in our time has taken the place of the cosmopolitanism of the eighteenth century; and in the political respect it is the surrender of all those constitutional rights which Israel has obtained with so much toil from the civilised communities." More than these anti-Zionist grounds, Zangwill is interested in the question of the practicability of the Zionist plan. As regards this, it is urged against Palestine that it is a poor land, that it suffers from a lack of water and lies waste over great stretches, and that the security of agreements with Turkey is not to be rated too highly. It is feared, too, that at the moment of the repeopling of Palestine many old religious questions of the land-laws will arise, and men point with anxiety to the contentious character of the Jews. To this the writer of the article gives the following hearty answer: "It is precisely the so-called practical man, who is apt to lay too much weight upon these intimate difficulties, that is in truth a dreamer. Perhaps Dr. Herzl has been preserved from such discouraging thoughts even more by his more objective position towards Judaism than by his political insight. He has above all furnished the proof that the feeling of brotherhood in Israel, whose isolation is in part to be ascribed to that very feeling of brotherhood, possesses strength enough to create the working basis for a common effort to regenerate the Jewish soil. Upon the other dark clouds also, with which men would fain overhang the heaven of Zionist hopes, silver linings are to be discovered. The beauty and fruitfulness of Palestine is like a glow living on beneath the ashes. The hill terraces can again, as of old, be clothed with vines and olive trees; here and there the wild flowers grow rank. The cedar has remained faithful to the slopes of Lebanon. A re-afforesting would bring back the rain and thereby improve the climate. By abundant planting of eucalyptus trees the fever can be met. The old wells could with slight trouble be dug out again. Already there are places in the land where through Jewish labour "the desert blossoms as the rose" . . . . If the Rothschild and Hirsch colonies have had so little success, this is to be ascribed solely to the circumstance that they are philanthropic foundations and not the product of creative enthusiasm.

The report of the Colonisation Society founded by Baron Hirsch forms the pathetic memorial of a heroic exertion of strength to roll a rock up the mountain. In the "home secured by public law," and in that alone, lies a true value and a real prospect for the future, and however much money were expended to attain this end, it would be well expended. For the rest one must rely upon spontaneous immigration, upon the enthusiasm that works of itself without material support, upon private capital and private labour."

"It is impossible to assume that the Jewish business spirit" could fail even in a land like Palestine. Dr. Herzl's idea of making the holy places of Jerusalem extraterritorial, as the Vatican in Rome is in like manner, presupposes merely a possible compromise with Christianity . . . The present prohibition of immigration plays directly into Dr. Herzl's hands. As for the well-known utterance let fall in Washington, according to which Turkey does not think of selling Palestine, that is a theatrical stroke not further disquieting: the dagger-blade is already slipping back into the sheath. To buy Palestine as a country is not quite the intention of Zionism, and were it so, the views of the Sultan are no invariable quantities either. Sultans' whims come and go — and Sultans too. To move the Alps away is perhaps a thing of impossibility; in politics, however, there is no immovable condition. And besides, as one who has spent many hours haggling in Oriental bazaars, I am not the man to let myself be frightened by the word, sounding so resolute, of him who in this case is the seller. The word of the Lord goeth forth from Zion, and I say to myself that the word of the Sultan goeth forth at present from Washington."

Even from the Zionist standpoint there is little to improve in this rejoinder. To it there attaches itself a neat and intelligible lesson for people who coquet with the theories of the "Choveve Zion": "Even though the prospects in Palestine are not so gloomy as at the first glance they appear, gloomy enough they are in any case to discourage every immigration save that which follows Herzl's plan and the (so to be called) heroic. The thought of erecting upon the ancient soil of the homeland a Jewish State, of whatever kind, is an ideal which at the very least brings about a strengthening and heightening of Jewish self-consciousness throughout the whole world. To advocate, on the other hand, an immigration after the method hitherto pursued is simply criminal. The "Choveve Zion" — an organisation for the gradual, sober colonisation of Palestine, are guided neither by an inspiration nor by an ideal, nay, not even by the pretence of a practical system. In order that a single peasant and his family upon the holy, yet