— 8 —
(continued from page 7)
…he regarded as a testimony of the solidarity of all Jews. Never had the Zionist movement, which upholds the traditions of our religion and our race, been more necessary than now, when even an anti-Zionist journal admits that freedom and security are gratifyingly gaining strength in the East, while the needle of the anti-Semitic compass points towards the West. In England the new book of Arnold White, which preaches Jew-hatred, was allowed to appear, and from America too there come of late reports of scandalous Jew-baitings. It is not a question of a passing movement, but of one that is settling itself down as at home. This assembly is the token of a union of the English-speaking Jewry, which will, it is to be hoped, soon become a reality.
Mr. J. Cowen occupied himself with a letter of Mr. O. J. Simon's published a short while ago in the "Daily Chronicle."
The Zionists, said the speaker, respect this honest opponent, who gives attention to the arguments of the Zionists and seeks to refute them. Mr. Simon's views with regard to Turkey are not the right ones. In Turkey the Jews are still comparatively best off. Nor is it advisable for an Englishman to attack the Mohammedan religion, since so many British subjects are its professors. The morality of Turkey, too, deserves no censure. Its women enjoy a better treatment than — let us say — many a woman in the Near Est of Whitechapel. As regards the so often doubted patriotism of the Zionist Jews, the opinion of a Canadian journal may be adduced as an instructive analogy. This esteemed journal, whose editor is a friend of the Prime Minister Sir William Laurier, expressed itself at the time of the Fashoda crisis to the effect that the French Canadians, who are loyal subjects of the British Empire, would deserve to be despised by their English compatriots if they did not testify a son's love towards the mother country. It is this son's love which the Jews, as men of honour, must cherish for Zion.
Loud applause greeted the next speaker, Dr. Gaster. He recalled the Hague Peace Conference, which, in spite of the trumpet-blasts that joyfully stirred the world and in spite of the good will of the participants, had achieved but minimal results and had furnished a justification of Zionism. The Congress of Basle had indeed been quite another thing, a true peace congress! "Our American brethren have spared neither time nor money in order to take part with us in what wretched ironists have called the Jewish Crusade. We work for a Zionism of the greatest and noblest kind. It is not for us merely a matter of withdrawing the sufferers of our race from persecution. We wish also to fill those who live in freedom with a new, Jewish enthusiasm. We are not content with a Zionism in a small edition. To transplant a comparatively small number of our brethren to Palestine — that is a task too narrow for our ambition. We would carry the old traditions over with us and quicken anew many a now dead Jewish element. The Jew shall become great again. That is no longer a dream, that is a distinct goal which, thanks to our patient labour, draws nearer from day to day.
Professor Gottheil, who now, tumultuously greeted, took the word, declared that he was at a loss for a theme. Were he to speak of the material condition of the Jews, it might easily happen that he would be cried down as a pessimist. Were he to speak of the Zionist hopes, he would be dismissed as an impractical idealist. Should he occupy himself with the Trust and the shekel collections? Then the opponents would say: The Zionists regard money and Jewry as synonymous. "I would rather take my stand," the speaker continued, "upon the high watch-tower from which Dr. Gaster contemplates Zionism. Our race, thanks to certain identities which have maintained themselves in spite of its dispersion, has remained pure down to our own day. We have the same blood, we suffer under the same hostility of a whole world. Only the identity of the religious and spiritual interests is doubtful and imperilled. Here vast differences gape open and fierce struggles have broken out. In Germany and in America synods came together which endeavoured to work for unity. Likewise, when I left New York, a new one was to be convened. But the religious differences were so violent that properly every party would have had to convene a synod of its own. In these confusions there is only one thing which brings together those who strive apart: that is Zionism, upon whose platform there is room for all Jews, be they of what conviction and tendency they may. As a reconciling force Zionism has to work at three points. It must reconcile the Zionists with the Zionists, must bring the various tendencies within the movement to a common footing. There are millions of Zionists, but on the other hand only some hundreds of thousands of shekel-payers. Mutual confidence is above all necessary. A gratifying example of such reconciliation is furnished by the entry of the New York Chovevi-Zion into the American Federation. Further, there must come about an accommodation of the Zionists with the Jews who do not stand in the Zionist camp. No Jew who has the interests of his people and his faith at heart can describe himself as an anti-Zionist. There have been misunderstandings which are beginning to be resolved through the growing insight of the parties. Thus in America the Sons of Benjamin, a great Jewish organisation, have joined the movement. In California the Rev. S. S. Wise spoke under the auspices of the B'nei Brith. Finally, Zionism will bring about a reconciliation of the Jews with the non-Jews. When the non-Jews shall see that our love for Zion is an active one, they will take part with us in the work. And so Zionism will contribute for its part to the peace of the world.
Mr. J. H. Mayer expressed himself enthusiastically upon the Congress, which by its sincerity and its courage had compelled the recognition even of its opponents. The union of the culture of the well-to-do Jews of the West with the capacity for enthusiasm of the poor Jews of the East would bring new wonders to pass.
There followed now the sensational speech of Mr. Alexander, who described himself as a Neila-Zionist. He had attended only the last sitting of the Congress, but had returned home a convinced Zionist and ready to place his strength at the disposal of the common cause. For three years a vehement opponent of the movement, he had now come to the recognition that Zionism brings the Jews back to Judaism.
The fusion of the Chovevi-Zion with the English Zionist Federation was the subject of a resolution brought forward from the meeting, which was supported by several speakers, as also by the chairman and by Mr. Greenberg. Mr. J. de Haas demanded in the first place guarantees that the insults offered to the leaders should cease, and that the praiseworthy principles professed on paper should not be contradicted in practice. The resolution was thereupon withdrawn, and the meeting closed after the adoption of a vote of thanks to the guests.
Printing-house "Industrie", Vienna.