No. 36. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 13.
(continued from page 12)
…all those present. The following gentlemen were elected members of the committee: H. Chwatt, S. Diamant and D. Wertheim. In conclusion, numerous new members joined the society. H. F.
Review of Periodicals.
The September number of the "Jüdische Chronik", published by Dr. A. Kurrein in Teplitz, has the following contents: Monthly Survey: Jom hadin. — The Judgment. — The Feast of Tabernacles. By Dr. Adolf Kurrein. — The Synagogue Service. Set forth by Dr. M. H. Friedländer. — Rabbi Isaac Kampanton, or the Religious Dispute in Spain under Pope Benedict XIII. A tale by Josef Löwenstein. Danish Writers on Jews and Judaism. By Dr. H. Goitein. — Jewish World-Chronicle.
The "Wiener Allgem. Rundschau" publishes in one of its latest numbers some unprinted letters of Berthold Auerbach, which the literary historian will assuredly read with especial interest. One of these letters, which Auerbach addressed to an intimate woman friend on the occasion of the unveiling of the Hanger Spinoza monument, and which holds much of interest for us Zionists in particular, we reproduce here in extract: "— — To me it is also of especial moment that the monument to the absolutely free philosopher is likewise the first monument to a Jew. Whether it be the general temper of the times or the season of age that brings it about, I am becoming an ever stronger Jew....
"The Alien People."
II.
It is certainly worth while first of all to characterise the manner in which Chamberlain*) proceeds in his assertions. The more numerous the examples with which I document his art of furnishing escamotage proofs, the more clearly will his literary character stand forth; and the oftener I quote him, the more easily will one be able to appreciate his great statistical gifts, his mental agility, his brilliant technique. Chamberlain knows how to say what is false with such bravura that it produces the effect of truth itself. Downright paradigmatic of him is the passage in the third chapter: "Consider only that it lasted more than two millennia before the mathematically demonstrable, palpably conceivable structure of the cosmos became a firm and general possession of human knowledge! Is not the understanding, with its eyes and with its infallible breviary of twice two is four, more easily moulded than the blind heart, for ever befooled by selfishness?" When the eloquence of these words, with the graceful sentimentality of their closing cadence, comes whirring towards one, one is at the first moment tempted to say yea and amen. Only later does reflection come, and show the fundamental error of this sentence. The simplest psychological experience teaches how easily the heart is inflamed, and how hard the understanding, with all its eyes, is to win over. The heart will sooner intoxicate itself upon a thousand marvels than the understanding will have grasped the one marvel of the spherical form of the heavenly bodies. How often does the understanding not succumb to this "blind" heart, and how very seldom is it able to triumph over it. The heart
*) Houston Stewart Chamberlain. "Die Grundlagen des neunzehnten Jahrhunderts.
reacts to every impression with unreflecting spontaneity, whereas the understanding examines, ponders, re-examines, and thus performs an incomparably slower labour. From the effect of his aphorism alone Chamberlain might perceive this — of this sentence, which with its uttermost point strives to reach and to win the feelings, until reason, hurrying up later, rejects it.
But Chamberlain understands not only how to turn himself with elegance to the wrong side in his own aperçus; he possesses also a fabulous dexterity in shifting his scientific evidences into whatever light he pleases. He can become really dangerous with these feats of illumination, for he knows how to distribute the shadows so that everything remains in darkness which he would leave unlighted. If, after the example cited above, one may perhaps charge him with errors of thought, or infer a distorted manner of calculating, yet in the way he employs his evidences every error on his part appears excluded. What he accomplishes here is not absence of purpose, for he is too exact a man of learning for that, — but he knows the worthlessness of empty assertions and knows very well how firmly a thesis stands that is shored up with the beams of facts. So he drags his timber together from everywhere, and it is to help him to prop his tendencies. What must be laid to his charge more seriously than his involuntary fallacies are those which he commits consciously and with definite intentions. Sometimes the matter lies palpably open, as in the passage: "Jeremiah gives of the moral constitution of the Jews a characterisation such as Monsieur Eduard Drumont could not wish more highly coloured: 'One friend deceiveth the other and speaketh no true word; they take pains how one may cheat the other, and it grieveth them that they cannot make it worse.'" Here one has the feuilletonistic hop from Jeremiah to Drumont, which cuts so prettily striking a figure, and one positively feels, before Drumont's name, the pointing dash which Chamberlain's good taste has suppressed. It is amusing how zealously Chamberlain here labours to take the prophet's sermon for a character-sketch, how naively he sets about it in order to be able to pass off admonitions as descriptions. Jeremiah, to be sure, certainly meant the Jews only; but for many centuries civilised men have accustomed themselves to read the Bible sub specie universitatis, and those words of Jeremiah have since then not always fitted the Jews alone, nor have they since been applied to the Jews alone. But if Chamberlain would have us believe that chap. 9 of Jeremiah is a characterisation of the Jewish national character, and that his accusations are to be restricted solely to the Jews, then he simply asserts that nowhere in the world do "men take pains that one never cheat the other", and then one must wish for him that he may never see disappointed the high opinion which he cherishes of the whole of mankind, the Jews excluded. Chamberlain even draws from Jeremiah a fundamental conclusion for his work. Immediately after the citation of the prophet he asserts: "For the incredible ignorance concerning the nature of the Jew which prevails among us we alone are therefore responsible; never has a people given so comprehensive, so sincere a picture of its personality as the Hebrew in his Bible..." In truth, the conclusion is not so bad. Only, besides