Die Welt · Vol. III, No. 29 · 21 July 1899
4printed page
scan 8 of 20

Page 4. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 29.

The German National-Socials and Zionism.

By Max Aram.

The National-Social movement in Germany is an expression of the famous German idealism. After Bismarck, by his mighty personality, had forced upon the Germans the sense for the real, for a realistic policy and for a realistic, almost philistine and place-hunting conduct of life, those Germans too were obliged to take up an attitude towards it whom Napoleon had called ideologues, who had drilled at gymnastics under Jahn, and who had already been mocked by the young Heine, but who had also fought the Wars of Liberation and had still pursued their courses in the mad years of the revolution. This attitude, however, could not be the simply antithetical attitude of the liberal and democratic parties; for even the German Kyffhäuser idealists were realists enough to feel the abstractions of Liberalism and of Democracy as mere phrase. Their antithetical position might rather be designated by a logical process which will be known from the gibberish of the Hegelian philosophy. Thesis — antithesis — synthesis. A grain of seed is sunk into the soil — it has been destroyed by processes of putrefaction — but out of this putrefaction there has none the less come forth the blade, the tree, the fruit. And what was present in the thesis has by the destruction passed through, by the antithesis, only been raised to a higher stage, the synthesis. Thus the National-Socials turn, with their humane and free sentiment, against the Borussian Germanism; but at the same time they preserve an open sense for all the real necessities of practical politics. Whereas the Freisinnige in the year 1893, when William II. was upon the point of calling a member of the Freisinnige Vereinigung into the Ministry, made this impossible for the unprejudiced monarch by their narrow-minded opposition to the Army Bill, the National-Socials are particularly solicitous for the maintenance of the military greatness of Germany, and above all for the development of the German sea-power. If they have hitherto been able to achieve no essential successes at elections to the Reichstag or to the Diets, one may well assume that their hour might have come if — what is after all possible — the Emperor should one day quit the paths of the Stumm policy and return to the great beginnings of his reign. They would then be, to apply the Hegelian word once more, the synthesis between idealistic and realistic politics.

Now one will certainly expect that the National-Socials would bring a quite particular understanding to the Zionist movement, and will regard the expressions of opinion of their eminent leaders with astonishment and wonder. Were the custom here that of the country which so-called "Jewish" journalism is said to rule, one might very easily dispose of the two utterances with cheap journalistic witticisms. Herr Naumann says: "I expect that the Zionist movement will lay hold of the educated younger Jews in fairly large numbers and thereby gain a lasting influence upon the whole intellectual culture of Jewry. But I believe that it will have only limited practical successes." Herr v. Gerlach is of opinion: "I hold it very easily possible that the Zionist movement will become strong enough to create a Jewish national community in Palestine which shall attain a certain political autonomy. But it seems to me out of the question that the educated, religiously indifferent Jews, who stand eminent in political, scientific, or artistic relations, should become accessible to Zionism.

Now the objection of Herr Naumann is indeed neither new nor unheard-of, but perhaps the one which is most frequently met with in discussions upon Zionism. He has formed for himself, by ocular inspection and by literature, a picture of the conditions in Palestine, and believes that the land is far too little productive to repay the expenditure of great means. He records a lamentable condition of the Palestinian Jews. One might point to reports of the contrary tenor, which tell downright of a flourishing of the Palestinian colonies. But it would be idle to dispute about it, and it would also not be honest. For if Zionism will not allow a bad success of Jewish colonies in Palestine to count as an argument — as little as Socialism need allow the failure of socialist colonies to count as a counter-argument — then neither may it appeal to a thriving of Jewish colonies. Rather will Zionism decline every connection with individual foundings of colonies. It will here bring forward the proposition which Karl Marx introduced out of chemistry into political economy: namely, that quantitative differences at a certain point turn about into qualitative ones. If the colonisation were to begin at once upon a great scale, so that roads of communication could be laid out and marshes drained in the necessary measure, then the outlay for every single colony would also pay itself in quite another fashion. One might there think of the difference between a mason who with materials begged together — a subject for a Jean-Paulian idyll — should build his little dwelling-house and draw the water out of the pond, the motionless pond upon which the full radiance of the moon reposed, in order to slake his lime, and a workhouse-building company which should obtain its mortar from mortar-works conducted upon a factory scale. Zionism is also quite well aware how fundamental this point of view is; within the circle of its adherents it will sooner forgo valued comrades and partisans than enter in any way into a compromise with endeavours after single-handed colonisation.

The actual creation of a Zionist commonwealth would, however, make its influence felt yet further afield than upon economic conditions, such as ameliorations of the soil and the like: it would also influence purely ideal, intellectual relations. Herr v. Gerlach is of opinion that in particular those Jews who stood eminent in political, scientific, or artistic relations would never become accessible to Zionism. And in truth one sees the intellectually most considerable Jews confronting the Zionist movement most coldly, and — now with Goethean humanism, now with formal mastery of the German language — labouring after a complete assimilation. But this comes after all only from the Diaspora of the Jewish people; the Diaspora makes it unlovely, and with the Diaspora it will at the same time pass away. The poet, the artist, has need of the loud acclamation of criticism and of the public; and the most gifted has need of it for the dark working of his genius no less than the superficial man for his vanity. When there shall now be offered to the Jewish artist, in a Zionist commonwealth, in towns and villages, a public, he will assuredly have nothing further to object against Zionism. When above all those whose importance is rooted in their position among the host people shall have died away, the youth, upon whom after all everything depends, will certainly, solely upon