No. 20. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…lay before it, by falsifying the letter D. into Dreyfus, could only have proceeded from a person initiated into the proceedings of the trial. This flight into publicity was above all intended to produce a movement of indignation against the promoters of the revision, and thereby to deter and hamper them, and Picquart in particular.
When it was perceived that Picquart was not to be induced by these means to abandon the trail of Esterhazy, he was denounced to the Chief of the General Staff by Henry's right hand, the secret agent Guénée, in a report of the 30th of October 1896, to the effect that Picquart had told Guénée that he had communicated his doubts of Dreyfus's guilt to an "old friend," and that the latter had confirmed him in them. Immediately thereupon — the date unfortunately cannot be exactly ascertained; General Gonse says between the 1st and the 14th of November — the Deputy Chief of the General Staff, Gonse, had the secret dossier handed over to him by Picquart, because Picquart was now suspected, through Guénée's report, of having shown official papers to unauthorised third persons, and it was therefore not desired to leave the secret files in his hands; and on the 2nd of November (according to Gonse's deposition) Henry delivered to him his notorious forgery, the alleged letter of Schwarzkopfen to Panizzardi, or of Panizzardi to Schwarzkopfen, with the injunction to deny all relations with Dreyfus. In order to produce it, Henry required the pieces of the secret dossier, among which he inserted it. It was high time that the files should be completed by the one piece of evidence which showed the name Dreyfus written out in full, for the interpellation of Castolin (it was postponed from the 12th to the 18th of November) stood at the door, and it was necessary to furnish the Minister with convincing material by that time. It was reserved, however, for Billot's successor, Cavaignac, to lay Henry's forgeries before the public as the proof of Dreyfus's guilt. On the 10th of November 1896 the "Matin" thereupon published the bordereau, and in all probability this indiscretion likewise proceeded from the General Staff, in order to prejudice public opinion against the revision, since the facsimile of the bordereau is correctly reproduced, whereas the dictation to which du Paty subjected Captain Dreyfus is distorted to Dreyfus's disadvantage. The secret agent Guénée, moreover, knows who occasioned this publication in the "Matin" as well as that in the "Eclair" of the 15th of September, but refuses, pleading official secrecy, to say it.
The Campaign against Picquart.
After the long-missing link had been fitted by Henry's forgery into the demonstration that Dreyfus was guilty, the endeavour of those upon whom the responsibility for the trial of 1894 weighed was directed to the ruin of Picquart, the dangerous promoter of the revision and the man most deeply initiated into the matter. On the 16th of November 1896 Picquart was sent upon a special mission to the eastern frontier, and thence — without being permitted to return to Paris for a few hours to fetch linen — to Marseilles, under the false pretext that the Minister awaited him there. At Marseilles he received orders to embark at once for Algiers; from Algiers he was sent to Tunis, and finally to the Tripolitan frontier. General Boisdeffre had even proposed to send him to Tongking. The very first days of his absence Guénée turned to account for a fresh denunciation, in which he asserted that the "old friend" to whom Picquart had shown the secret files was the advocate Leblois; and since both Henry and Gribelin afterwards declared upon oath that they had surprised Picquart in his office in the act of laying the secret files before Leblois, proceedings were now taken against Picquart, the former head of the espionage service, for high treason. The trial which the civil court is making of him upon this charge is still pending, after the military court had already punished him for it with dismissal. As for the incident itself, which according to Henry's first deposition is said to have occurred in October 1896, Leblois can prove that in that year he was absent from Paris from the 5th of August to the 7th of November.
After Picquart had left Paris his letters were intercepted and opened by the Intelligence Bureau, as though he were suspected of the gravest crimes, and the contents of the letters were then employed for fresh forgeries, in order to compromise him. Thus among the letters addressed to Picquart there was one which the secretary of Picquart's fifty-year-old friend, Mlle. de Comminges, had written by her direction on the 27th of November 1896. It contained the sentence: "The demigod asks the Comtesse every day when he may see you." The name of demigod had been bestowed by the circle of the Comtesse de Comminges upon Captain Lallemand, a friend of Picquart's. At Tunis there now reached Picquart a letter of the 15th of December 1896, previously opened at the General Staff, bearing the signature Speranza, to this effect: "Your precipitate departure has brought us into difficulties. The season of the festivals is particularly favourable for resuming the work. Come back quickly. Say a word. The demigod will act." There Picquart further received a letter of Henry's of the 31st of May 1897, couched in a strikingly insolent tone, in which Henry already felt himself strong enough to let the accusations of the General Staff against Picquart be discerned, and which acquires a peculiar significance from the fact that General Gonse had read the letter beforehand. There followed a letter of Esterhazy's dated the 7th of November 1897, in which he reproached Picquart, in the same terms as the "Dixi" article of the "Libre Parole" which appeared only on the 15th of November, with being the author of the campaign against Esterhazy. On the same day on which this letter arrived (the 10th of November), Picquart received a telegram with the signature Blanche, in which it was said that the proofs were in hand that Georges (Picquart's Christian name) had fabricated the Petit Bleu, and on the following day (11th Nov.) the following telegram with the signature Speranza: "Stop the demigod. All is discovered. The matter is very serious." A letter with the same signature Speranza was dated the 10th of November. Since, however, it is not forthcoming, Picquart having burned it, it shall not be taken into account here. Various indications point to it that the letters and telegrams with the signature Speranza were instigated by Esterhazy with the support of the General Staff, for only at the General Staff was the word "demigod" known from Picquart's intercepted letter, while the telegram Blanche (that is the Christian name of Mlle. de Comminges) presumably proceeds directly from the General Staff. The purpose of these machinations, to blacken Picquart with the Minister, was completely attained, for precisely at this time Picquart's superior at Tunis, General Leclerc, received in quick succession two orders from the Minister instructing him to examine Picquart as to whether he had not allowed a secret document to be purloined from him by a woman, and whether he had not permitted a person not belonging to the army to inspect secret papers. Captain Cuignet has deposed that from two other telegrams addressed to Picquart, which Picquart does not mention, and from two letters sent by Picquart to Paris poste restante, the conviction was obtained that from Tunis he had communicated with his friends in a preconcerted form of writing. Whether this is correct, whether this exchange of ideas has reference in particular to the Dreyfus affair, and whether Picquart is incriminated by it, the trials pending against Picquart will doubtless show. On the 26th of November 1897 Picquart travelled to Paris to give his evidence in the Esterhazy trial; two days after Esterhazy's acquittal, on the 13th of January 1898, he was brought before a council of honour and dismissed the service. The next blow against Picquart was a court-martial charge of forging the Petit Bleu. At Picquart's departure from Paris the Petit Bleu was still in its old condition; soon afterwards, however, it appeared that the address had been erased and written afresh. By this forgery the suspicion was to be aroused that Picquart, in his endeavour to set Esterhazy in the place of Dreyfus, had put Esterhazy's address upon the letter instead of another. Therewith, to be sure, Picquart would have been undone and Esterhazy exonerated. The experts established, however, that the erased word had likewise read Esterhazy. Nevertheless the charge of forgery is maintained against Picquart. He has lain in preventive detention since the 12th of July 1898.
Attempts to Rescue Esterhazy.
The same means which aimed at the destruction of Picquart were designed at the same time to rescue Esterhazy, and Esterhazy says not too much when he asserts that he was "the man of the General Staff." In the middle of October 1897 a consultation had taken place at the Ministry of War, at which the proposal was made to apprise Esterhazy by an anonymous letter of the danger threatening him; the proposal, however, had been rejected. Nevertheless, on the 18th of October 1897, at Dommartin, Esterhazy received a letter with the signature Espérance, which acquainted him with the suspicion against him. Esterhazy hastens to Paris, and now follow those mysterious meetings at which du Paty in a false beard, Gribelin in blue spectacles, Henry, and (according to a too little regarded remark of Vertulus') Boisdeffre's adjutant Pauffin de St. Morel instruct Major Esterhazy to the smallest particular concerning the danger threatening him of being charged with the authorship of the bordereau. He was even given a cipher key, that no unauthorised eyes might obtain a sight of his correspondence with the General Staff. At this time, at the end of October 1897, Esterhazy then wrote, at the dictation of a General Staff officer, his well-known letters to the Minister of War, to General Boisdeffre and to the President of the Republic, in which he applies to them to intervene for his rescue. In the letters to M. Faure he even threatens to appeal to the German Emperor and to publish an important state secret (the much-named "liberating" document). The effect of these letters showed itself forthwith in the investigations of General de Pellieux and Major Ravary, and in the treatment