No. 6. — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 11.
(continued from page 10)
…against the Chacham, whom, on the contrary, he greatly esteemed. The congregation must be proud of the appreciation which Doctor Gaster had found at the Basle Congress. Dr. Gaster, however, had been elected Chiefrabbi of the Sephardim already on the ground of his well-known learning, and the congregation had no need to have the excellent capacities of its Chacham first confirmed by the Zionists. It was true indeed that Dr. Gaster had occasionally emphasised at Zionist meetings that his standpoint was that of a private person, but the press none the less saw in him the Chacham. The motion concerning the salary had merely the purpose of giving him (the speaker) an opportunity of speaking upon the matter. Only a short time ago, on the occasion of the festal dinner of the "English Zionist Federation," it had become plain that the public did not keep apart the Zionist Gaster and the Chacham of the Sephardim. Thereby the congregation was brought into a false position. He (the speaker) was personally against political Zionism, which would pass away without leaving a trace behind.
Mr. de Castro then summed up his motion in the following words: "Since the public activity of Dr. Gaster in respect of the Zionist movement is opposed to the views of the Synagogue Elders, the congregation most respectfully begs the Chacham either to withdraw from the Zionist agitation, or else at every public appearance to emphasise that he is giving expression not to the views of the Spanish-Portuguese Congregation, but merely to his personal ones."
Being called upon by the chairman to take up a position, the meeting declined to express itself upon the question, in regard to which no unanimous judgment prevailed.
Sir Francis Montefiore said it was not Dr. Gaster's fault if the press described him as that which he was. The motion was decidedly to be rejected.
Mr. E. L. Mocatta desired a discussion upon Zionism as little as the previous speaker. In free England everyone, and therefore Dr. Gaster also, had the perfect right to free expression of opinion. The speaker moved the following amendment: "Since the views of the congregation in respect of political Zionism are not settled and unanimous, the Chacham is requested to appear at public meetings as a private person."
Mr. E. de Pass supported the amendment. Mr. de Castro had raised a "storm in a teapot."
Mr. G. Lindo took exception to it that the Chacham had not previously asked the congregation for advice. Dr. Herzl had taken Palestine into his plan and had made a national movement. Do the Zionists mean to await the Messiah in Jerusalem? And who is the Messiah to be? The speaker laid stress upon spiritual Zionism, in whose sense his friend Mr. Herman Landau had expressed the wish to die in Jerusalem.
The chairman thereupon brought forward the following compromise motion: "The Chacham is requested to notify the Jewish press that as a political Zionist he speaks only for his own person and not as representative of the congregation, which as a corporate body has neither been consulted upon political Zionism nor has expressed itself thereupon."
Sir Francis Montefiore supports the last motion, while
Mr. J. de Castro demanded that the Chacham should ask permission of the congregation (for his public activity). (Mr. de Pass: "That is tyranny!")
Before the division Mr. J. M. Levy declared that it must be made evident in Mr. de Castro's motion that no decision of the Synagogue Elders in respect of Zionism had been arrived at. After a correction to that effect had been added, Mr. de Castro's motion was carried by 10 votes against 4.
* * *
The Sephardic congregation of Canada has addressed the following letter to the Chacham Dr. Gaster:
"... At the general meeting of our congregation lately held, a resolution was adopted amid enthusiastic applause, in which our deep satisfaction is expressed at your remarkable participation in the Second Basle Congress. We acknowledge it quite especially that you are one of the men who say to the House of Israel: Now is the time for action. As a Sephardic congregation it affords us a quite peculiar pleasure to see that the head of the English Sephardim sets so noble and worthy an example.
J. L. Samuel, on behalf of the Spanish-Portuguese Congregation 'Shearith Israel' in Montreal, Canada."
London. The protest of the Synagogue Elders of the Spanish-Portuguese Congregation will in no way influence the activity of Dr. Gaster. He continues to assert his own opinion, and since he became a short time ago the first President of the English Zionist Federation, he has delivered speeches at two public meetings. Next week he will speak in Manchester, Liverpool and Leeds. The whole executive committee will accompany him. Sir F. Montefiore will likewise speak in Manchester, and also in North London, and that within this month. I know also that the Federation is making considerable efforts to gain only trustworthy members, and further to create a sound financial basis for the Federation. All classes of the population show lively interest in the activity of the Federation, and great results are looked for very shortly, to the general advantage of the movement. Of interest is the appeal for a subscription in order to purchase the Maccabean graves. 1000 pounds are to be raised. The English Federation intends to buy the graves and to present them to the Congress.
America.
New-York, end of January. It is very probable that all the Zionist societies of the country will shortly join together under one banner. Some time ago, at a conference of the leaders of the two existing federations, with the participation of the two members of the Actions Committee for America, the resolution was adopted to work towards a union of the federations. I hope to be able to communicate to you, within a few weeks, the closer details of this union, which would mean a representation of all the States and of all the larger cities and would embrace more than a hundred societies.
* * *
On the 30th of January a public meeting of the West Side Zionist Association of New-York will take place in the synagogue of the Spanish-Portuguese Congregation, the oldest Jewish body of New-York. A speech is announced by Dr. Aron Friedenwald, one of the most esteemed physicians of Baltimore, upon "The Colonisation of Palestine." Dr. Friedenwald, known as an ardent Zionist, has but lately returned from a prolonged visit to the Holy Land.
* * *
A promising phase in the development of American Zionism presents itself in the attempt which a group of earnest-minded students is undertaking, to form an academic Zionist association, to which local student clubs at all the universities of the country would have to attach themselves.
* * *
A very interesting occasion lately united several Zionist societies in a federal meeting at Minneapolis (Minnesota). Some Christian friends, just returned home from a journey to Palestine, presented to the Zionists, as an expression of their sympathies with the Jewish national movement, a splendid banner of heavy white silk with the Shield of David embroidered in blue in the centre. In the course of his address the donor described Palestine as "a land without a people," the Jews as "a people without a land." "But we see this land awaking again out of its sleep of many hundred years. God alone knows the end. We raise a banner; the word has gone forth into all the world. We have seen Jerusalem. What a city! And we say unto you: Enter in at the holy gates, join stone to stone, raise the banner ... Jerusalem must be built again!"
* * *
Upon inquiries from many quarters concerning the origin and the development of the Zionist movement, the Federation of American Zionists has begun the publication of a series of pamphlets. The first, just issued, comes from the pen of Professor Richard Gottheil and bears the title: "The Aims of Zionism." The publications will appear monthly.
S. S. W.
