No. 5 — "Die Welt" — Page 15.
Review of Periodicals.
"Le Flambeau" (Revue mensuelle. 76 Rue Taitout, Paris. Director: Jacques Bahar). "The Torch" is the name of the new monthly which our well-known fellow-adherent Jacques Bahar has begun to publish in the French language. The first number, which lies before us, will satisfy even great demands on the part of the public. The article by Bernard Lazare, "The Jewish Proletariat in Face of Anti-Semitism," is written with the elegance and thoroughness, but also with the fire, which we can always admire in Lazare's publications. Even people who may not share the views he develops will read this article with interest and pleasure. An excellent piece of work is Jacques Bahar's "The Cuban Algiers" also. With an intrepidity worthy of the greatest praise, Bahar shines, truly as with a torch, into the rotten Algerian conditions. What he brings forward in the way of statistical data shows, as do the expert expositions to be found upon almost every page, how exactly he knows the Algerian circumstances, and how many fables have been spread within and without France concerning this French colony. Clearly and convincingly Bahar proves that the whole Algerian Jew-baiting is only the consequence of the political conduct of the Jews, who, in spite of all enticements and threats, show a devoted loyalty to the mother country, France. The picture drawn for us of Algerian anti-Semitism is no less characteristic than the delineation which Bahar furnishes of the Algerian authorities. — There follow, further, a number of smaller contributions. Noteworthy also is the programme with which the periodical introduces itself. "This organ of Zionist and social Jewry is published not in order to defend the Jews in the manner hitherto practised, but in order to summon the Jews to self-help and to show them the ways and means which a reasonable action requires. The solidarity of all Jews is expressly emphasised, and the evil situation of the Jews of Algeria and of France particularly insisted upon. The point is to clear up the false ideas prevailing among the Jews; then the way to salvation may surely be entered upon."
In the "Grenzboten" the chief editor of the "Nordd. Allgem. Ztg.," Karl Trost, writes an article upon Judaism and Revolution. The author is an adherent of that "liberal" anti-Semitism which simply declines or repudiates Judaism without hating it. Political anti-Semitism has nothing to do with the Semitic race; it bestows its hatred exclusively upon the Jewish people. Economic anti-Semitism, originally sprung from trade envy, has soon raised itself to a nobler (!) stage. The combating of the Jews is even moral (?). Striving after power (that is, equality of rights), the Jewish people tears to shreds and crumbles away all institutions, and works revolutionarily. The Germans ought not to be good-natured enough to concede to the Jew in fact a privileged (!) position by admitting him to the competition upon a footing of equal right with the German. The article is indeed very shallow, but on account of the position of its author it is characteristic.
"Sifre Schaschim", No. 1—2, second series, contains: 1. "That too a Dream" by I. L. Perez, 2. "A withered Flower" — Libosizky, 3. "On the Way to Egypt (description of travel) — Sluszer, 4. "My Gravestone" (poem) — Tschernichowsky, 5. "The Recent Past (tale) — Wiernikowsky, 6. "The Tailor (poem) — Fernhof, and several poems and tales by Rothblum, Samuely, etc. To be obtained from Isak Fernhof in Zloczow (Galicia).
The World of Books.
History of the German Jews by Dr. Adolph Kohut, illustrated by Th. Kutschmann. Berlin. Deutscher Verlag. 1898.
With the unerring feeling of the artist, Theodor Kutschmann has set before the text, as the first plate of his illustrations, a picture from the old cemetery at Prague. To me this choice appears a peculiarly significant one. Whoever has ever seen the old cemetery at Prague will remember, even after years, the mighty impression he there received. A glorious piece of the Jewish past speaks out of those crumbling stones, half sunk into the ground, in the grandiose, run-wild garden which is known as the old Prague cemetery. There many a Jew has come by an inkling of the greatness of the people of which he knew so little or nothing at all; yes, there that has shown itself in full which may be called a mark of our history. Our history in Bohemia, as in other lands, is a history of graves. Long before anyone undertook to record our fortunes, the grave-inscriptions told us of our good and our evil days, of our greatness and our decline. And alas, more than among other peoples, care has been taken among us that we should remember our graves! Thus the cemetery has for the Jews truly become the "good place," their refuge when heavy things threatened them, the place of their collectedness when they mused upon the destiny of their people, and at the same time the place of hope which promised them their final resurrection, their redemption. With no better frontispiece could this history of the German Jews, which is intended to be a popular one, have been adorned. The picture prepares one, full of mood, for the text. Of the latter also much good may be said upon the strength of the first number before us. A conclusive judgment is hardly possible before the reading of the complete work permits a careful criticism; but even from the first number the reader gains the conviction that Kohut is doing his best to furnish, in brief outlines, a complete cultural history of the German Jews. We say, of the German Jews. The author has fortunately not chosen the — moreover unscientific — designation "Jewish Germans." How indeed could it be otherwise. Who, that occupies himself with the history of the Jews, could use another word. "The historical and culture-historical life of the German Jews" is what Kohut would depict, "and the gradual intellectual development of the Jewish stock upon German soil." Involuntarily a lofty tone already rings in the preface when the author comes to speak of the stock whose history he now means to write. "For undeniably the Jewish stock is a highly gifted one, intellectually especially developed and of high standing, and thus the following records shape themselves involuntarily in many places into pages of glory of the Jewish stock, which, embodying the most conservative element of peoples in Europe, has furnished the proof that it has outlasted the thousands of years without going under and without forfeiting its cultural individuality." It is not an overweening pride that makes the author speak thus, for he shows in other places that he is by no means blind to the injuries which the Jews, in the course of almost two thousand years of suffering, have sustained in their national character; but he recognises the indestructible ideal trait that dwells within Judaism, and he rightly employs the simile of the thorn-bush that stands in flames and yet is not consumed. What he says of the similarity of character and the identity of ideas between Germans and Jews we should not, however, subscribe to so without further ado. And it strikes one as strange when he believes that his work might above all serve also to dispel the prejudices against Judaism. This optimism we unfortunately cannot share. Nor indeed should such a work aim at that at all. Such an effect would be heartily to be wished, but it stands far behind that which the historical work, if it be really kept popular in character, might have upon the Jews themselves. We live to-day, thanks above all to Zionism, in a time when the Jews are beginning once more to take an interest in their own history. The Zionists do not weary of setting up again and again the postulate of an exact knowledge of Jewish history. Without regard to the hatred or the favour of the peoples dwelling about us our history should be written, should be told to our children. It would be highly to be regretted if the author should wish to make the elective affinity between Germans and Jews, so willingly accepted by him, into a guiding idea of his book. We hope that a history of the German Jews, and a popular one at that, can also be written without one's having to spin out further, with polite readiness, the very fable of the oriental Germany which Palestine is alleged to have been. — But we will not further emphasise these few points, which might excite misgivings. The work has, after all, not yet advanced beyond the second number. We shall, as we have said, only be in a position to report upon it really in detail after the completion of the publication. Nevertheless every historical work by Jews about Jews seems to us worthy of the most exact examination, but also of friendly encouragement. We greet Kohut's history too in the friendliest manner. That Theodor Kutschmann was won as illustrator can only benefit the work. The illustrations are uncommonly careful, some of them excellent in their kind. The Deutsche Verlag has altogether taken pains in point of substance to procure the work an easier entrance by the handsome get-up as well. The total price of the complete work is comparatively small — 20 marks for 10 full parts, the first of which contains 84 pages. We believe that we may recommend the work to our readers with a good conscience. W.