Die Welt · Vol. III, No. 3 · 20 January 1899
14printed page
scan 18 of 20
Facsimile · scan 18 of 20
Scan of p. 14
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 14. — No. 3.

In time to come men will marvel and shudder at the mendacities and cowardices with which so honest a piece of poetry had to contend, and all that will only increase the fame of the upright poet. The servile snatchers after success may duck and crawl before the prevailing public opinion; whoever is a man finds his highest delight in being himself. What a wretched occupation the writing of books and plays would be, if one did but render back the ruling opinions of the multitude. Certain precious and over-refined poets do indeed find the adroit way out of simply evading the strife of opinions. They strike off sideways into the bushes, away from the conflagration of the questions of the day. They sing as the bird sings. Art is to exist only for art's sake, and whatever more there be of such twaddle. We, however, hold that art must above all have a meaning, and that can be no other than the meaning of the actual life which we live through, sobbing and laughing. A relation to that portion of life which is most familiar to us, to our own present, which surely does not consist of betrothals and Eheurichen alone, will therefore be nothing unpoetic. In the last years it has generally been found highly praiseworthy that literary stage-works should faithfully render the local colour of towns and districts, nay even the dialect. But the presentation of the movements of the time is proscribed. And yet that is only a chronological local colouring of human destinies.

To be sure, the socialists have gradually compelled civic respect for their drama of the present. But although the social question might be turned into poetry and at last performed, that is still far from being the case with other questions. Ours, for example, the Jewish question, may not enter into the higher literature. Firstly, because it has already been definitively treated in Lessing's "Nathan". Secondly, because there is no Jewish question at all. Thirdly, because this question possesses the property of frightfully exciting everybody. It is, as one sees, pretty much the well-known reasoning about the broken pot, which the borrower firstly returned quite whole, which secondly was already broken when it was lent, and which thirdly was never lent at all.

The people who hold Lessing's "Nathan" to be the last poetic word in the Jewish question are about as clever as those who regard Freytag's "Journalisten" as a definitive work upon newspaper-writing. Ah, certainly, those were remarkable works for their time, but the time has become another. For Mendelssohnism — if the expression be permitted — "Nathan" was doubtless the last word, and it occurs to none of us to think lightly of that word and of the movement in Judaism which corresponds to it. But the history of the Jews has gone further, not without great new pains. Already the times which for the poet of the "Nathan" were the later ones are past. The Jewish question seeks another poetic shaping, and it is in keeping with the whole manner in which of late the destinies of our people are unfolding, that it is now Jews themselves who take up the poetic word upon the Jewish question, no longer in the Ghetto, no longer in the confidential whisper of the jargon-poetry, but before all the world. Just as we Zionists have set up at Basle a political tribune in Europe, where we can say what lies at our heart, so we seek also to create the literary occasion for this same purpose. The sitting continues! as that French President of the Chamber said. Max Nordau has the word.

And as at Basle for the hearers, when this exquisite orator mounts the tribune in order to depict in grand strokes the condition of the scattered Jewry in the year that has run out, so it is a festal moment for the reader of the book-drama.

"Doctor Kohn" is the tragedy of assimilation. Certain silly fellows who wrote about it in the shamefaced-Jewish sheets have of course completely misunderstood the meaning of the piece. Or is it the good form of the shamefaced-Jewish sheets — these are such as are made only by Jews and for the most part read by Jews — that one should seem not to understand the matter. They supposed that the poet had been concerned to show, in the figure and in the fate of Doctor Kohn, how disagreeable it is at the end of the nineteenth century to be a Jew. Quite wrong. The poet wished rather to set forth how disagreeable it is — apart from the uselessness of it — when a man denies his Judaism. A "bourgeois tragedy" is what the piece is called. Well, the bourgeois element in it is the case of Julius Christian Moser, while the tragedy of Dr. Kohn which runs alongside of it is properly a romantic one.

The piece plays in a small Central-German university town. There lives Julius Christian Moser, a Privy Commercial Councillor and captain of Landwehr retired. He is a right stately gentleman, highly respected, rich, allied by marriage with the noble officers' family of the Herren von Quincke. His wife is a born von Quincke, his sons are staunch anti-Semites, the elder a lieutenant in the Life Regiment, the younger a lad in the dashing Corps of the Franko-Thuringians. In short, Herr Moser has brought it as far as ever he could bring it; every trace of his ineffaceable blemish of birth seems to be wiped out. For Herr Moser has made a happy play upon letters with his name — he was originally called Moses! He is a baptised Jew, but so gloriously assimilated that nobody who did not know it could do him the shame of holding him for a son of the despised people. Upon the Jewish wilding a German and noble scion has been grafted, and the shoots which it has put forth, the sons, remind him of the old stock no more in anything; neither do they wish to be reminded of it any more by anything. But Herr Moser, né Moses, has also a little daughter, Christine, and from that side the trouble breaks in.

In the small Central-German university town there has, namely, established himself as a Privatdocent of mathematics a certain Dr. Leo Kohn. Dr. Kohn comes to know Christine and to love her, and she loves him in return. He does not venture to sue for her so long as he is only a Privatdocent, and the professorship they will not give him because he is a Jew and is called Kohn. But at the prize competition of the Stockholm Academy he wins the world's prize for mathematics, and since now a professorship, if not at this university, is assured to him, he resolves to come forward as a suitor. Before this the Rector of the university, who was moreover well disposed towards him, had informed him that the Senate had refused Kohn's petition for appointment as extraordinary professor, because the statutes of the university set it forth as a Christian-Evangelical one. Dr. Kohn appeals against this, in vain, to the constitution, which lays down equality of rights. He thinks, however, that by this showing of colours something has after all been gained. "The lie of equality of rights is uncovered before all eyes, it is officially proclaimed that the constitution is a scrap of paper by which one need not abide."