No. 44. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
…lated themselves upon their peculiar generosity. Prudence and insight, statesmanlike or simply sound common sense — these were not to be found in the equipment of these gentlemen, or else were found only in conjunction with a sufficiently large measure of dilettantism, so that these qualities could not be turned to account. In 1890 they apply the method of the year 1881; in 1901 they will have grown not a whit more modern. Already in the year 1881 there were sensible Russian Jews who declared that what they needed was not palliatives but a cure from the ground up. Only now is the wisdom of Western Europe beginning to realise this correct idea. And yet there are to be found even at the present day people who, notwithstanding the reports of their own commissions, persuade themselves that the Jewish question can be solved locally. How, they do not say. They wring their hands and lament over the situation. That is childish, or something worse still.
What have these organisations, which after all were founded for the same purpose that Zionism strives after — namely, to help the Jewish people — accomplished up to now? For the Persian and Moroccan Jews they have been able to do nothing. In Roumania the Jews fare worse than ever; in Austria, Germany and France Antisemitism stands in luxuriant bloom. By an ill-advised mode of emigration they have made pariahs of the Jewish fugitives in Germany, and in England and America have newly created a communal Jewish question. What the condition of the London East End over-population is need not be set forth; it is well known to all the world. Similar conditions exist in New York and other great cities of the United States — the result of the activity of those societies. In New York a Jewish ghetto in the east of the city was already thought of last year: so far has it come. The Argentine project has brought about only a temporary settlement. With the enormous sums that were there expended nothing has been attained but a new and sorry variety of the type of the Wandering Jew.
The protests and attacks of the Anti-Zionists leave us cold. We should like to see ourselves combated in quite another fashion. Namely, with a reasonable, well-elaborated plan of help. Let the Anti-Zionists lay that before us. They may count upon it that we shall examine it more thoroughly and with less prejudice than they have examined ours.
This suggestion is not offered in evil intent. One fact weighs more than a multitude of theories. The policy of laissez faire on the part of those who have nothing ready for the comfortless situation but their honestly meant lamentations is worth nothing. Without wishing to raise a panic, without painting grey in grey on principle, we ask: Is a movement of the Jews of the East towards the West an absolute impossibility? How many riots must yet occur in order to induce — let us say — only 5000 Galician Jews to emigrate to Austria, Hungary, England or America? What are 5000 Jews? A handful! And yet all the Jewish organisations of Western Europe, even if they united their forces, would not be able to help this handful! The big drum would have to be beaten in order to collect a fund; conferences, assemblies and deliberations would take place in abundance; many kilogrammes of paper would be consumed for the minutes alone — and all this because one small Galician town had emptied itself of its Jewish inhabitants.
What would our opponents and critics do with these fugitives?
Such an increase to the Jewish population of England would at once make the Aliens Bill a fait accompli. The American immigration inspectors would have thousands of reasons in readiness for refusing the fugitives admittance. Australian Jewry has for years prevented a fresh immigration of Jews; South Africa will not and cannot receive the poor; the administrators of the Argentine colonies may not, even with the best will, so much as hold out the prospect of providing for the emigrants.
Whither, then, would these poorest of the poor, who are our brethren, go; what could we do for them, what begin with them? What I here say is no hypothetical argument. The events of the year 1881 came unforeseen. From those of the year 1890 men still took no lesson.
By what means is a recurrence of the misery in the year 1900 to be prevented? Whoever keeps his eyes open must see that the situation is already acute to-day. Hundreds of Jews who have suffered shipwreck over yonder in America are sent back to England, from England to Russia, and there they remain until sufficient travelling money has again been raised.
Every week another microcosm of the suffering Jewish world presents itself to our contemplation. Thus one may often enough meet in our streets a Roumanian Jew who has left his country because life was made impossible for him there. He went then to Austria, to Germany; there too life was made intolerable for him. At last he comes to London, and he shrinks back before the inhospitality and unfriendliness which he encounters here at every step. The language of the country he does not know. Often he is glad if he can but obtain the travelling money to return home again. Or else we find him after a year and a day in a terrible, hopeless struggle for a terrible, hopeless existence. Tougher already is the Russian Jew; he also finds many countrymen there before him and knows how, on occasion, to fight his way through. And how many even of the Russian Jews perish miserably?
On the same day on which I set eyes upon such a Roumanian Jew, I met emigrants from France, fugitives from Algeria. What becomes of them? They are helped as far as the next town. What then?
And then, if we would find them again, we must seek them in the dregs of mankind.
I call upon our opponents to tell us how they mean to better these conditions; to tell us with what — non-Zionist — hope they mean to keep the blood warm in these emaciated bodies, to raise up in these despairing hearts the courage which they who fight for life have need of. I call upon them to tell us what they have already done to solve this most lamentable problem of human misery; what they will in future do with the thousands of our people who must be helped if the sun of peace is to rise over the life of our people.
The Week.
Vienna, 2 November.
Out of the palisade fence which encloses ex-Captain Dreyfus a massive stake has of late been broken by the Court of Cassation in Paris. But it is nevertheless still doubtful whether the prisoner can through the new gap which has now arisen in the bars of his cage finally win his way into the open. For the Dreyfus affair has shown us that not only fortune but justice also stands upon a ball. And if everything does not deceive us, in our case it is a well-fashioned cannon-ball.