Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 43 · 28 October 1898
13printed page
scan 13 of 16
Facsimile · scan 13 of 16
Scan of p. 13
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 43. — "D'r W 'r" — Page 13.

After this declaration of Brisson's the sitting was adjourned. Upon the resumption of the sitting, after Brisson had declared that he would lay before President Faure a decree for the appointment of a provisional Minister of War, and that he must beg the Chamber to adjourn until Thursday, several orders of the day were brought in. The order of the day of the Republican parties was adopted by a large majority. It ran: The Chamber affirms the supremacy of the civil power, placing its trust in the army. Then began the well-known game with supplementary motions, by which so many French ministries have already been overthrown. In the end an amendment of the Clerical Mahy, "the Chamber invites the Government to put an end to the campaign against the army", obtained a majority of 53 votes, although it had been opposed by the Government. When another supplementary motion, which was to express confidence in the Government, was rejected, the Ministers left the Chamber and handed in their resignation to the President of the Republic. Faure accepted it. The sitting of the Chamber is an incontestable victory for the anti-revisionists. It is beyond question that the fall of the Brisson Ministry will have the worst influence upon the further conduct of the revision. The affairs of the French State, too, are moving towards a grave crisis. The dictatorship, and perhaps something worse, have drawn nearer, perhaps so near that all will soon be publicly known concerning it.

England.

London, 25 October. The most interesting event of this week is, in my opinion, the following letter, "Zionism and Labour", which Lewis Lyons has addressed to the editor of the "Jewish World". It runs:

Under the title "Notes and Gossip" Reynold's Newspaper prints an interview which its reporter had with a Jewish financier of the City of London. To the journalist's question what was to be thought of the return of the Jews to Palestine, the financier answered: You see, this is Jerusalem! Whether it is only the City of London or the whole of England that is "Jerusalem" for this gentleman, the paper is unable to say.

It may be that the rich in this country feel comfortable, "Jerusalem-like". It is of more importance that the majority of the Jewish population of the United Kingdom belongs to the working class, and that this majority, which surely demands our greatest attention and regard, finds itself in a wretched economic condition, which naturally carries with it the danger of a moral deterioration as well.

Yes indeed, this majority suffers want, and in this respect it will grow worse still. Within a few years — this is my firm conviction — the whole Jewish population which now occupies itself with tailoring or is employed in the mantle and boot trades will be turned into the street and given over to hunger. This is no vague prophecy. Who will take up the cause of these poorest of the poor? Who will provide for their food and their shelter?

I raise my warning voice before it is too late. I know whereof I speak. A movement is already afoot to withdraw work from the Jewish population in certain districts. The matter is very serious, and the sooner the working Jews pass out of this Jerusalem into another, the better will their future welfare be provided for. It is true enough that they are exposed to no religious persecution. But who will deny that they are absolute slaves? Out of this bondage they must free themselves, in all composure, but also with all speed. For there is a design to drive them into a corner, to take from them the possibility of ever rising.

There will be people enough who will dispute the possibility of what I assert. Matters will never come to that, they say. Only patience! These people have no opportunity of looking behind the scenes. They scarcely know what is going on there, and regard this economic question from their own narrow standpoint. They sit at home in the neat and cosy drawing room and dictate letters to the newspapers against Zionism, against the crime of wishing to give the poor Jews a new home. Their bread, thank God, is spread with butter sufficiently, and economically they depend upon quite other people than the poor foreign Jews ... Their interests are secure. There exists a British army, and it looks after the interests of City men. But the people?

Only let things go their own way, we are told. If the people is still poor now, has to work hard, dwells in unhealthy homes and must pay high rents for them, if it eats adulterated food — all that will change in time; in the long run the poor people will work out for itself its whole and full right.

For forty years the Jewish workman has lived as is described above. And what has he worked out for himself? The full wrong! The development is against us. We have further been told that we should quietly lay our cares in the hands of the Jewish spiritual guides. Kind-hearted people these, our spiritual guides, of that there is no doubt. But they will have enough to do to care for their own life and for the life of their congregations when the time comes. And it is coming. It will be too late to look about for a new home when work, money and energy shall have been taken from all. Now we must look about for a new home, before all the preparations are completed for robbing the Jews of the possibility of labour and therewith of existence.

I call upon those who make a stiff opposition to the Zionist movement to obtain a deeper insight into the economic condition of the poor Jews. Is that so difficult? Let them institute enquêtes, examine the matter themselves and go to work without prepossession. Only they must not consider this question from the standpoint of their own surroundings and by the measure of their own conditions of life.

Particulars of my argument, which tell in favour of the view expressed in the first part of my letter, I purposely suppress, because it does not appear advisable to me to give everything away to the public. I have simply wished to point to something which is at present in preparation, in connexion with the future of the Jewish workman. But if, in spite of this warning, Zionism should meet with the further opposition of the City men, then the responsibility for the irresistible growth of human misery, the responsibility for the progressive disfranchisement and repression of the Jewish poor, will lie upon the shoulders of these light-hearted gentlemen, who know how to carry the burden of their wealth and their easy living with so much grace. How will they withdraw themselves from this responsibility? By flight? . . . Money is an obliging thing and follows everyone — everywhere . . .

I attach great importance to this letter for the reason that its writer has devoted the best years of his manhood to the cause of Jewish labour in England. The number of the strikes from which he has emerged victorious is probably as great as the number of those in which he has been beaten. In any case it is due to him that the Trade Union movement has found an entrance among the "foreign" Jews in England also. Some fifteen months ago he informed me that he was studying the Zionist question. The conclusions at which this earnest man has now arrived are therefore by no means the result of a hasty judgment. But what makes his letter so important is the following. In the course of his many years of activity Lewis Lyons has done more for assimilation than a dozen theorists. His endeavour went towards imbuing the "foreign Jews" (perhaps before the time was ripe for it) with the ideas of English labour organisation. It is chiefly to be ascribed to his activity that the Zionist agitation, in so far as it came into conflict with the economic question, has hitherto had so little success. And now the same man who had called upon the Jewish workers to combine and to co-operate with their English, non-Jewish fellow-workers says: "A movement is already afoot to withdraw work from the Jewish population in certain districts!" That proves two things: first, an increase of the Jewish misery which the municipal treasury (exchequer) is not easily able to cope with, and secondly, the existence of an incipient Jew-hatred.

A danger threatens English Zionism. An organised attack on the part of those rich in money and influence is impending. Well, if even but the half of what Mr. Lyons asserts rests upon truth, the organisers of this opposition will probably soon arrive at the conviction that they have chosen a very unsuitable moment for their campaign!

J. de H.