Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 38 · 23 September 1898
6printed page
scan 6 of 16

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 38.

(continued from page 5)

…Lezion is likewise bad, in Kastinie the school is tolerable, in Sichron-Jakob the school is fairly bad. The school in Rosch-Pinah is beneath all criticism, and even the school in Jaffa has not answered my expectations.

I must say a few words here about the school in Jaffa. Years ago this school was the hope and the pride of the colonisation societies — as regards the idea with right, but as regards present conditions without right. All the reasons were set forth to me why this school does not in fact answer the expectations which we attach to it. But the fact remains that at the present moment this school does not yet answer our expectations. This school is to form the future Jewish secondary school, and hopes were rightly expressed that it would be improved, the more so as quite recently an excellent teacher has been added to the earlier ones.

Ladies and gentlemen! I do not wish here to call forth the impression that I do not praise this institution. As regards the idea I praise it, and I wish that the Zionists may further this institution; for the chief reason why this institution can show no better results is the lack of money. Had this school such sums at its disposal as are required for secondary schools, the school would look quite otherwise. So much must be said, that in this school a great willingness to sacrifice has been displayed by various teachers, solely for the sake of the idea.

A model school in a certain respect is that in Rechowoth.

All these judgments I pronounce after having observed these schools very thoroughly. I made visits of three and four hours, and was accustomed to be present at the examinations of all the classes.

At present there are in Palestine 29 schools with 2500 pupils. In six schools Hebrew is taught, and in twenty the Hebrew language is treated in the instruction as a living one.

The greatest misfortune in the school system is the lack of uniformity.

Ladies and gentlemen! I regard the Congress not merely as the place upon which we are to resolve only that which we have to do as a federation, but as a place from which we may criticise all Jewish life; and so I think it is not unjust if I address to the Zionists and to the Chowe we-Zion the wish that a uniformity may be brought about. Only when a uniformity of programme, a uniformity of activity, and a uniformity of administration are present — only then is it possible to create a real school after our own mind.

The chief reason why the schools in Palestine also do not answer our expectations is the circumstance that in the Rothschild colonies the supreme supervision of the schools has been committed to girls who have enjoyed their education in Paris for a short time, one or two years, and who, in the opinion of the administration there, may be in a position to bring the culture of the West into these schools. Most of these girls are very young and exercise a very pernicious influence, so that even good pedagogues are hampered by them in their work.

One school I must mention particularly, and that is the school in Mikweh-Israel. Much as we have to condemn the activity of the Alliance Israélite in the matter of language, in Mikweh-Israel also, we must on the other hand pay this school a quite unusual tribute of praise, and that not merely on account of the beautiful and magnificent plantations which one gets to see there in the neighbourhood of Jaffa and which are a joy to every visitor, but also on account of the earnestness with which agriculture is there carried on. Indisputably this school might have an enormous value as an agricultural school, and if this is not yet the case, the reason lies in the following. The Alliance Israélite is inexplicably at pains to bring French influence into Palestine. We do not really know the reason, and we do not understand why precisely the French language should be imparted to the Jews in Palestine. I well understand that the Jews in Palestine should learn the French language too, but not that French should become the living language among the Jews. It is a fact, however, that to our greatest sorrow the intelligent Jewish element speaks far more French than Hebrew. It might be otherwise, and the Alliance Israélite ought in this direction to stand absolutely upon the standpoint that every school in a Hebrew land which is in the future to belong to the Jewish people can be Hebrew only.

In the library of Mikweh-Israel I found, among some 48,000 volumes, 65 of Hebrew content, the remainder throughout in the French language. You see, then, what nourishment is offered there at present. Not as though I would lay down the principle that the present Hebrew literature already fulfils all our demands. That principle I did not wish to lay down. But if in Palestine the Hebrew language be not regarded and cultivated as the central point, our hope in this respect for a future solidarity and uniformity is likely to be destroyed.

There is but one circumstance which helps the Hebrew language to come to the front, and this circumstance awakens certain hopes. Since the Sephardic and the Ashkenazic Jews have come more and more to be thrown together, the Hebrew language must in certain parts be spoken. They can make themselves understood in no other language. And to our greatest joy we must record that the Sephardic Jews, even if they are not great Hebraists in respect of their learning, are yet fairly practised in the Hebrew language.

It is therefore to be expected that the Hebrew language will become the one in general use among the Jews there. Only we must work from here, that in all the schools in Palestine and in the colonies, where a struggle for the language is being waged — and a struggle of a quite unheard-of nature — the fight may be fought out in favour of the Hebrew language.

Is a certain regeneration of the Jewish people, or let us say of the Jewish colonists, to be observed in Palestine? To that I must answer with a somewhat conditional, but yet with a "Yes." There prevails a dexterity in the various bodily exercises, for example in riding and in shooting, such as is unhappily absolutely not to be found in the Golus Jew, perhaps not in the non-Golus Jews either, in the European Jews; and, in great part, fearlessness.

We may set up no demand here that all the colonists shall at once absolutely give up those habits and peculiarities which they have taken into themselves thanks to the Ghetto. But that in this respect no comparison whatever can be drawn between the Jews of the colonies and the Jewish mass in Eastern Europe is for us one of the most gratifying facts.

Most of the Jews are conscious that they have to protect and to defend themselves. In the course of the last years countless fights have been fought out between Jews and Arabs who had been incited against them, and in most of these fights, though