No. 38. — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
…ty; and withal the few Jews who happen to dwell there feel nothing of the molestations which otherwise fall to their lot from anti-Semitic hatred—such as that hostile or derisive glances follow after them, or that they are actually reviled. But this modest condition too has for its presupposition that the Jews make up only an inconsiderable fraction of the population. The happy conditions in England and France lasted, after all, only so long as the Jews there formed less than one per cent. of the population. In France anti-Semitism arose and grew with the unnatural growth of the (above all Parisian) Jewish population in the last decade, and how conditions in England will shape themselves as soon as the Russian immigrants begin to set up pretensions as Englishmen is not hard to foresee. Just as the most ideal conditions in this respect prevail in Spain, Liechtenstein, Portugal, Finland, Sweden, Ireland, Norway and Montenegro, where the Jews are not represented at all or only quite minimally (up to 0·05 per cent.). Now in Holland the percentage is indeed quite high, even higher than in Germany, and if hitherto the relation of the strata of the population dwelling side by side has really been so good a one, that may at any rate be worth mentioning and worth considering. But then again the percentage is still only half as great as in Russia and in Austria-Hungary, and these Dutch Jews, who are for the most part Portuguese and the descendants of those exiles, have already dwelt for centuries in their land. And finally, however much more substantially the Dutch percentage may exceed the French and the English, and however well it may have been permitted to prove itself, it is nevertheless to be assumed with certainty that in the event of a quasi-nomadic invasion of foreign Jews it would succumb to the general law whereby the unconstrained ease of Jewish existence is possible only so long as it remains inconspicuous.
Indeed, not only does the being-in-one-another already come no longer into consideration, but properly speaking neither does the being-beside-one-another; that over which the "patron saint" is to spread his hands in blessing may well be the condition of being-under- and being-above-one-another. For this patron saint has "in one of his most beautiful pictures painted the merciful Samaritan, who stands at the gate of his house and admits two men carrying in a sick beggar." "It is," the interpreter lets himself be heard, "as though Rembrandt had wished to proclaim the glory of his fatherland, which magnanimously opened its gates to the persecuted."
Thus the "Schutzjude" is to come to life again, who is a somewhat milder new edition of the "Kammerknecht"; and when the "Vorwärts" once alluded to the yellow badge of those Kammerknechte in a polemic against the "Centralverein deutscher Staatsbürger jüdischen Glaubens," one must unhappily admit that in the Jewish national character a strong servility and a characterless, cowardly need of protection is in fact present, in consequence of an ill-starred historical development. Only a few narrow lanes distant from the Jodenbreetstraße (upon the great Waterlooplein, a kind of long market-place) dwelt Baruch Spinoza, who taught that one should neither bewail things nor exult over them, but before all else understand them. The Jewish people has lacked that which the poorest labourer still has and wherewith he can maintain his personal dignity: that he reacts at once to every attack and "hits out about him."
It might surely, even as a minority, have thought at least of resistance—might, for instance, have pitched its dwelling-places upon secure, fortress-like sites where a defence would at any rate have been possible; and even if one fell in such a defence, that glorious death would have been by far preferable to the death of being slaughtered defenceless. But since it simply never thought of helping itself, its need of protection was bound to develop, of which the much-famed gratitude of the Jew towards his protector is one part, whereas a noble vassalage is something wholly different.
Yet it is one thing to understand a matter, another to acquiesce in it. And if the interpreter of Rembrandt is willing to renounce the highest pride of personality, that of self-protection, and to place himself under the protection of a foreign people, however noble and just, then Zionism—monstrously hard though precisely this task may be—works at the very least against the patron-saint disposition.
Bismarck as — a Zionist.
By I. Sachs (Dwinsk).
In one of the latest numbers of the "Welt," S. Lublinski closes his interesting observations upon Bismarck with the question what the great dead man would have said of our Zionist movement, had even only its beginnings come within his field of vision.
It is doubtless hard to give a direct answer to this question, because it is in fact not known to the public whether Bismarck ever expressed himself at all upon our modern Zionist movement as the first Congress created it. But Bismarck's own utterances and endeavours might serve as an indirect answer—utterances which we should like to recall upon this occasion, and which gave us occasion for the heading above.
Like every one who judges objectively, Bismarck too perceived the singularly unhealthy conditions under which the Jewish people must live everywhere; and like the Zionist, Bismarck too is said to have known how to draw the right conclusions from these circumstances; at least this is reported to us from one quarter.
Some remarks of the Prince upon the Jews deserve to be adduced here as vouchers for such assertions. Thus he once said: "They have, properly speaking, no real homeland." "Something generally European, cosmopolitan; they are nomads. Their fatherland is Zion, Jerusalem. For the rest they belong to the whole world, they hang together throughout the whole world. Only the small Jew has anything like a feeling of home. And among these there are quite good, upright people."
And then, after he has related an instance of the honourableness of such a one: "Of such Jews there will perhaps not be many more. For the rest, they too have their virtues: "Respect for parents, conjugal fidelity and benevolence are credited to them.")
That Bismarck, now, was not content with the mere acknowledgment of the fact that the Jews had properly speaking no real homeland, but wished in his very own person to set his hand to a work which we should call the realisation of the Zionist idea—that is assured us by none other than — Mr. Arnold White.
In the June number of the "Newbery House Magazin" there appeared in the year 1893—that is, five years ago already—a sensational article by him with the striking title: "Bismarck as a Zionist." Although his utterances there bear an almost incredible character,
*) Dr. Moriz Busch: "Graf Bismarck und seine Leute, während des Krieges in Frankreich."