Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 36 · 9 September 1898
9printed page
scan 9 of 20

No. 36 — "Die Welt" — Page 9

Report by Leo Motzkin on Palestine.

Honoured Assembly!

At the end of April of this year, in the Vienna preliminary conferences — to which, besides the Vienna Central Committee, a number of Zionists from abroad had also been called in — the unanimously adopted resolution was passed to have an investigation made into the social and economic conditions of the Jews in Palestine. This resolution had reference properly to the long-settled population, in order to ascertain what prospects the Palestinian elements offer for the future, and whether they might eventually be suited for colonising or industrial undertakings. It soon became clear, however, that the shortness of the time did not permit so thorough a piece of work; the resolution in question was therefore at once narrowed and widened. The inquiry was henceforth to embrace the entire Jewish population of Palestine with particular regard to the colonies, but on the other hand was not to produce a finished work; the demand was made that a glance be cast into the Jewish Palestine of to-day, that statistical data be gathered so far as might be possible, and above all that the impressions of a social and ethno-psychological nature be reported to the Congress. Only after this limitation had been made could I resolve to accept the commission, having previously declined to undertake an investigation that could not be carried out by the time of the Congress.

In order to attain my purpose I travelled through almost all the Jewish colonies, Jerusalem, Hebron, Tiberias, Jericho, etc. I had to deny myself much that I should so gladly have examined or viewed more closely, but I was compelled to deal with my time in the most sparing fashion in order to satisfy my duty even in some measure. My method consisted in coming into contact with the most various circles, but above all in entering into conversation with as many people out of the common ranks as possible and in passing unobtrusively to a discussion of their life. Field and house, school and synagogue had to be sought out in suitable fashion, while the street often afforded the necessary instruction and offered occasion and clue for further study. At various places I stayed for a longer time in order to observe something of the life at first hand, thus at Sichron-Jakob, Chedera, Kastinieh, Rischon-Lezion, Jerusalem, Jaffa; at other points I had to content myself with brief periods of observation.

It appears already from my earlier words that my work does not in the least exhaust the theme of Jewish Palestine, that a far more thorough investigation is called for; yet it would be advisable to unite such an inquiry with a larger work of research, although I cherish the firm conviction that my general views upon the Jewish conditions will find confirmation even after a longer and more leisurely study. It is not merely a question, however, of exploring in greater detail the conditions and peculiarities of our Palestinian brethren; it is of the very greatest importance to study the land closely, to arrive at a fully elaborated view of the climatic and sanitary conditions, and to establish the prospects and possibilities of new industries as well as the legislative conditions, whereby we shall gain clearness as to the worth and the direction of our endeavours in higher measure than by disputations. By its clearly marked purposes such a commission would be sharply distinguished from the non-Jewish ones hitherto existing, to which some might wrongly point as a substitute, since it would pursue neither ecclesiastical nor historical, nor even scientific-geographical studies of a topographical character. After a special study it would be able, with data in hand, to answer the question whether the greater Palestine is in a position to receive millions of Jews, how far the climatic conditions are favourable to a settlement on a mass scale, and under what circumstances a prosperous colonisation is possible. Only afterwards can a better-grounded propaganda be carried on and rational activity be unfolded, especially also with a view to contributing to the creation of a basis in public law. For the knowledge of the economic value of the land and of the chances of its regeneration likewise confers a certain power.

There is, to be sure, no lack of investigations of Palestine on the part of various Christian nations. I do not speak, of course, of the countless descriptions which in earlier centuries, and still at the beginning of our own, were almost without exception the custom: these were for the most part utterances of particular feelings, called forth by faith. Every stone called forth hallucinations and transported men into the world of dreams. What value dreams in particular have even for our historical work we know well enough, since we too always reckon with moods of the soul; but for our practical activity and our spirit of enterprise only those researches have a certain significance which have begun since the middle of this century, inasmuch as they have in part taken account also of the geological and meteorological side.

Since the fifties the interest of various countries has turned towards Palestine, proceeding for the most part from particular societies. First from France, which ever since Napoleon's adventurous expedition to Palestine, in which numerous investigators also took part, bestows a particular attention upon the holy places and represents Catholicism in the Orient, attending to all Catholic endeavours. Then come England, Germany and Russia. In every case it is religious points of view that from the first moved the societies in question to seek influence in Palestine, but gradually strivings after power took shape; the masses of the people, to be sure, remained aloof from them. The literature upon this subject has grown to a monstrous extent; the scientific form has displaced the ecclesiastical. It was single individuals at the outset who began to explore the land; investigators such as Ritter, Robinson, Seetgen, Luynes, Tobler and others devoted themselves to this activity. In the sixties a turn occurred; societies are founded in order to explore the region in the most exact manner, above all the famous English one, which has published numerous works and, as Ankel expresses it, has accomplished the most considerable thing that has ever been done in the systematic exploration of a country outside Europe. Afterwards come the German Palestine Association and the Orthodox Society, which issue communications and collective volumes. Maps of enormous dimensions have been prepared. The representatives of one nation frequently accuse the representatives of another of cherishing, besides scientific and ecclesiastical, yet other designs — and this reciprocity is our consolation. A bibliographical compilation for the year 1894 was able to show 516 works and essays upon Palestine, of which, however, only a fraction bears a scientific character. England sought through its scientific society to disturb the French influence; Germany quietly founded colonies, while Russia endowed as many ecclesiastical settlements and hospices as it could.

One need only cast a glance into the Palestine of to-day to convince oneself that the land forms an object of contention among the various churches, while