Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 27 · 8 July 1898
9printed page
scan 9 of 16

No. 27 — Page 9

Convention of the American Orthodox.

New-York, June.

The convention of the American Orthodox was held in the last days of June in the Scheërith Israel Synagogue. Rev. Dr. H. Pereira Mendes welcomed the delegates from Buffalo, Baltimore, Charleston, Chicago, Cleveland, Dayton, Hartford, Jersey city, Lancaster, Louisville, Montreal, Newark, Newport, Newhaven, New-York, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, San Antonio, Syracuse and Washington. Some 100 delegates were present, among them the following gentlemen: Richard Mayer Sulzberger, Rev. Meldola de Sola of Montreal, Doctor Klein and Sarahson of New-York, Dr. Hertz, Doctor Solis Cohen, Dr. B. Drachman, Dr. Schaffer and Rev. Jacob Josephs.

In the course of the sitting the following resolution was brought in, an extract from which may here follow:

"That it is desirable and necessary to offer to those of our brethren who live under the burden of oppressive laws a legally protected place of refuge is beyond question. The logic of the fact points to Palestine and the adjoining fertile territories as to the Land of Promise.

Historical ties and the promises of the prophets lend this land a great power of attraction for the Jews. The nations, too, concede to no land, as to this one, the fitness for the end aimed at.

The proposal to support the already existing colonies, both by drawing in capable members and by opening depôts for the reception and sale of the colonial products in the commercial centres of Europe and America — is so exceedingly practical and so full of promise that it must meet with general approval.

We do not hesitate to affirm that the most enthusiastic recognition of Zionism is perfectly compatible with the most ardent American patriotism. And what holds good of us American Jews may likewise be asserted of our brethren in England and Europe.

In full confidence in the promises of the prophets, the Jew looks forward to that time when all men shall live in concord and peace, without inquiring of one another as to race or land of birth. But while he awaits the fulfilment of his ideal of the perfect brotherhood of man, he remains a loyal and law-abiding citizen of that nation in whose midst he happens to live. Why should a Jew hesitate more to be an inhabitant of Palestine than of America, Great Britain or any other land?

One need only regard the situation from a general point of view to perceive with what an idle chimera our good friends discourage themselves.

Were a Jewish State, whether independent or subject to the Sultan, to be established in Palestine, the Jews of the whole world would take a particular interest in it, for the very same reasons that inspire their patriotism towards their present fatherlands."

The debate was reopened, and Mr. Drachman brought in the amendment: "All congregations are urgently to be enjoined to further Zionism."

Mr. S. M. Roeder holds it dangerous to touch upon this subject. Mr. Max Cohen brings in an alternative amendment: "to recommend all Zionist endeavours in the direction of the Zionist teachings of the Bible, and to further the activity of the congregations in this direction." This is, to be sure, somewhat indefinite, yet all the enthusiastic Zionists were satisfied with it, and the report was adopted with this addition.

"Jewish World".


Letter-Box of the "Daughters of Zion".

Mr. F. Sch. in C. Most cordial thanks for your lively interest. Having returned from my journey of duty, I come only now to the answering of your esteemed letter. — There is so much to be said upon the idea raised that it scarcely appears feasible, within the compass of this journal, to extend oneself over the whole complex of our programme of work. As a professional nurse of the poor and of children, I am acquainted with all the reefs which a Jewish order of nursing sisters has to steer around, and for that reason I must insist upon its religious framework. There, where the English missionaries possess "kosher" humanitarian institutions, no Jewess may be employed as a nurse of the poor in whose performance of her duties the exceedingly scrupulous Chaluka public would find anything to object to. Nor can I expect of any but a religious Jewess that she should be able to take up with success the struggle against the pauperism of the Jerusalem Jews; for a good measure of resignation to God is needed to know oneself cursed and reviled for one's benefaction, as is to be expected of professional beggars when one would rear their children into useful men. A sister not religiously disposed would very soon take to her heels upon coming to know misery in its nakedness, and therefore we would rather reckon upon few, but in every direction thoroughly reliable, forces. As one of our fellow-adherents in Hungary informs me, a Cracow organ has attacked my endeavours, without honouring us with a copy of this attack. I can blame no one who has never stepped out of the narrow world of the Galician globe and does not know that in Germany the religious sisters of the Evangelical confession, and the Jewish sisters in Frankfort and Berlin as well, may return every day into their family circle, and that marriage is not forbidden them. If I stand for a duly regulated administration of the service of nursing the poor, this happens for so many reasons that I could set them forth more closely only in a special treatise. Whoever would subtly deduce from our draft statutes that we: 1. may not marry; 2. must from morning till evening turn the leaves of the "Korban-Mincha Siddur" or the "Zeeno Weureno"; and 3. would parade nun-like airs and lead an idle cloistered life, is on the wrong track. But whoever believes that under the title of "humanitarian activity" we mean to issue a licence for everything that our ritual law wisely forbids, is likewise mistaken. — Within the order one has to observe those commandments which the dietary law and the laws of morality and of the love of one's fellow-men prescribe. Married women, betrothed women, mothers of children and the like are unfit for service as professional nurses for the very reason that their bodily and mental activity must be wholly absorbed in the general good, which is not easily possible in the case of persons bound otherwise. A fixed term would not on our part have been appointed for the exercise of the sisters' service either, if it were out of the question that one or another lady might wish to undertake, at the society's expense, a little pleasure or study journey to Palestine. With the costs of conveyance to the Holy Land and of training, a minimum term of service of two years surely stands in keeping. Should a lady not wish to enter upon a permanent obligation of service, let her furnish the society with a security to the amount of the costs of travel, training and equipment. Invalidity acquired in the service entails lifelong maintenance in an institution of the society.

As regards the objection that the training of the sisters should take place in a European city and should also extend to the learning of French and Hebrew, I observe that the training has to be governed by the needs of the Holy Land and therefore has to take place on the spot. To each sister the directress will assign the place where she best answers the purpose. Hebrew and French are best learned there where they are used as the language of daily intercourse. The whole sum and substance of the nursing service will be drawn theoretically from Pfeiffer's pocket-manual, but practically from the actual needs. With these expositions I believe I have met the inquiries and observations from all sides, and remark finally that I am a religious Jewess who does not wish to be misunderstood by her fellow-believers, or rather her fellow-adherents. If I desire to bring the matter before the Congress at Basle, this lies in the fact that I know of no other forum which at present would be composed of the Jews of all lands and would pass resolutions of general validity. Perhaps it will be possible for me by then to refute all the objections of opponents and to bring the true aim of Jewish philanthropy nearer to its realisation.

To several inquirers. The statutes will, as soon as they have been approved or modified at Basle, be submitted for the sanction of the political authority competent for Jerusalem. The committee will be active in Europe, the order in Palestine. With the powerful European organisations we do not wish to compete. One must begin there where it is most needed, in the ranks of those in Jerusalem who stand in need of help.

The sisters who have announced themselves have been entered on the list.

The Projectress.


Tribune.

To the Jewish Law Probationers!

Not long ago several Jewish law probationers were appointed auscultants. To this unusual event a symptomatic significance appears to have been attached in wider circles, inasmuch as Jewish probationers are now applying in greater numbers for admission to the judicial service. In view of this I esteem it my duty to